1) Enter if you wish, knowing you'll get your points back, later.
2) If you absolutely feel you need to "do something" about the fake giveaway then send a ticket to Support.
3) Go about your business without posting anything in comments suggesting the giveaway is "fake."
Comment has been collapsed.
Support won't (and shouldn't) do anything about reported fake giveaways, unless it's a case of region locked keys, or the maker clearly stating the giveaway is for something else than advertised, both of which show up in a description. Any other conclusion will have to wait 'till the giveaway is over and done with, which will result in a "not received" for the maker, anyway. You shouldn't be encouraging people to make pointless support tickets.. Y u do dis Khally? :0
Comment has been collapsed.
First off, I don't make "pointless support tickets," nor do I encourage others to do so. Second, I don't usually make tickets for "fake" giveaways, although I have occasionally done so after checking thoroughly. Support does check these out when they have reason to do so, and they know better than I. I have even been mistaken on at least one occasion. My "step #2," above, could have been worded more clearly, so I've edited it.
Comment has been collapsed.
?? All my giveaways are legit, even though I'm not a native.
Comment has been collapsed.
People sometimes make giveaways for games not understanding properly how the site works. I've read an account of someone's friend doing exactly that on the forums before.
They somehow believe that if they create a giveaway then that game will be given by Steamgifts themselves, and that they had a chance to win it, or that if they create a giveaway they will be given the game. This definitely does happen.
People without a very good understanding of English are more prone to do that kind of thing. I am NOT saying that all, most or even many of the people on SG fall into this category, but there is certainly a greater scope for misunderstanding the whole concept of the site if English isn't a person's first language and their English isn't great if all they've heard is that they can get free games here.
I think, or at least I'd hope that a similar point being made rather than Non-native English speakers = bad because that would truly be a crappy thing to say.
Comment has been collapsed.
Although the points regenerate, sometimes you may want / need some more to enter stuff you really wanna win, or you might need a lot of points for a forum or group event with loads of giveaways. Hence, being a little cautious in what you spend your points on is warranted.
Comment has been collapsed.
But we get "i didn't got my game what to do" threads and i think support has a lot of these type of tickets to deal with, even though they can't do nothing about it.
Comment has been collapsed.
er.. according this list, many of today's top contributors' first giveaways were fake.
Comment has been collapsed.
I always call that a FAAAAKE when i see one.. dunno why ...
Comment has been collapsed.
Then you risk being suspended. Calling others out is against the rules, period. Try scrolling down to the bottom of any page on Steamgifts, and on the bottom right, clicking "FAQ" to read the site rules some time. Like maybe right now.
Comment has been collapsed.
Not a terrible guide, but I've seen plenty of new users create multiple, high value giveaways for multiple games just because that's what they're here for. If you ever see me doing that, then fear that I've gone wrong and probably avoid it.
Comment has been collapsed.
just hitting a few of those critiria does not indicate for a fake....but if one hits almost all of them, one should be aware.
the new users making multiple high value giveaways do that to promote a game for greenlight or soem youtube channel in the descrition and therefore apply the second list overriding the first list :)
Comment has been collapsed.
Don't get me wrong, friend. I hate private profiles as much as the next guy (I have my raisins) but you're being a little unnecessarily harsh here. I've already stated this is a questionable, but not terrible guide but imo after stating my piece I've decided it's best to go the other way. My further activity here cannot contribute to the discussion, which is otherwise going well among those interested in participating. Your post, however, is likely to be considered spam or flaming.
I'll be the first to laugh at the notion that the system is perfect, but there will always be those looking for ways around the guidelines if they want something. All we can do is try to enjoy the site for what it is, which is really more than any of us are entitled to.
Comment has been collapsed.
steamgifts wants me once a week to go public for the sync.
if you read carefully, i say if one meets most of the first list but none of the second, there is a high likelihood, its fake. its just a heuristic applicable to giveaways to determine a probability for beeing legit - you may use it or ignore it.
for my private profile: i am a bit of a security nerd, keeping most online activity as private as possible, encrypting wherever possible. perhaps beeing a computer science guy with interests in security make one a bit paranoid ;)
Comment has been collapsed.
Never bothered me :P
The stuff you really should be paranoid about, should simply never be in any way digital, or be on the internet (including being on a machine connected to the 'net). And anything else like user credentials, which are an inherent part of the digital world, can and should be kept secure in your head, nowhere else. Anything else as far as paranoia and security go should have more to do with securing your machine from malware / intrusions than encrypting or obscuring stuff, as far as I'm concerned.
Comment has been collapsed.
Unless you dont want people to see how much game time you have on questionable games ;)
Comment has been collapsed.
Asides from obvious reasons, it's because it's a high-priced game that lots of people play, so fake givers know that lots of people will enter it.
Comment has been collapsed.
I disagree. There is some useful info here to new ga members. I would change the phrasing of the topic, but I think the OP's intent and message is good.
Comment has been collapsed.
I don't doubt OP's intent, but there have been numerous cases where people gave away (AAA) games on their first day on here (even from their wishlist). If someone ends up not entering a GA due to this "guide" and it turns out to be real, that's somewhat counterproductive to the sites purpose.
And on top of that, the amount of fake GAs' is so small, that it is not a big deal at all. It's just that everyone should be aware that there are and always will be fake GA's, so to not be overly disappointed in the event you win one of those.
Comment has been collapsed.
i never said you can do a 100% classification based on the guide. its just a heuristic you can apply. i never saw a "real" giveaway where almost all of first list and none of second list hit.
the amount of fakes is very low on the low-prices games, but quite high on the high-priced ones. included call of duty, because i observed a very high quota of fakes there - more than half of the call of duty giveaways in the last weeks were fake (either deleted by support or winner did not recieve gift)
Comment has been collapsed.
"call of duty" Now that just made me laugh, nice one xD
Comment has been collapsed.
Most of your indicators are bullshit, except for the obvious ones (no games on account, game on wishlist and Call of Duty). You're just spreading confusion and misinformation. The only people that fall for fake ga's are those who don't check profiles and dum-dums, anyway.
Comment has been collapsed.
some of us enter fakes for fun... too many points on our hands =D
Comment has been collapsed.
just needed time to do some obeservations to verify/falsify some assumptions before making the guide.
and if you really read it -> hitting few of the criteria says nothing ;)
but good point, i should adjust this to 4 weeks as soon as i hit 2 month ;)
Comment has been collapsed.
and this topic serves what purpose other than eventually encouraging people to call out actually legit GAs? Let me go on my own example by your points:
My first GA was non-bundle puzzle GA for Assasin's Creed Director's Cut Edition.
registered less than 2 weeks ago - when I created this GA I was 2 weeks on SG only
less than 20 games on steam - I had 18 games on steam
giveaway game on whishlist - It was my wishlisted game, I intended to activate it myself that's why I bought it but decided to give it here instead
less than one year on steam - I was only 9 months on Steam
game not on sale last few month - game was not on sale - like I said - I intended to play it myselfSo judging by your rules all people should just tell me to fuck off, don't enter my GA and most of all disencourage me to do anything on this site whatsoever? Everyone started some time - some people will start and leave, some people like me will stay around and eventually become one of top contributors. You cannot judge people by some shitty first impressions neither encourage people to do so - if I were to do the same looking at your profile and your own rules I'd call any non-bundle GA you make FAKE as well. All due to your points.
Not to mention points are free, fake GAs are the slightest margin and you want to put all newcomers to the same basket? In my book you're a newcomer as well, so should I put you in as well?
Comment has been collapsed.
zelghadis, you fucking hax0r, what the fuck have you done???
Comment has been collapsed.
still someone seeing 5 of 10 points filled (heck, even 1/10) may yhink it's a reason good enough to call out fake GA. and each and every time like this you lose opportunity to get great site member. Potentially loosing great contributor seems much worse than loosing imaginary points you paid nothing for and in case of fake GA getting them all back anyway.
Comment has been collapsed.
Seen many people give a description on their first giveaway and even "welcomes" reply the first few "thank you" comments. They ended up "not understanding how SG works". And if I recall, the only indicator of non-delivery was that they were new to SG, small steam library, and no gift in steam inventory. So three from the first category and one from the second.
Did I solve the puzzle?
Comment has been collapsed.
13 Comments - Last post 18 minutes ago by Chris76de
1,830 Comments - Last post 44 minutes ago by Axelflox
9 Comments - Last post 1 hour ago by Chris76de
87 Comments - Last post 1 hour ago by Glas
386 Comments - Last post 2 hours ago by adam1224
31 Comments - Last post 2 hours ago by OneManArmyStar
207 Comments - Last post 4 hours ago by sensualshakti
4 Comments - Last post 4 minutes ago by dooder
10 Comments - Last post 20 minutes ago by Provos
0 Comments - Created 21 minutes ago by VahidSlayerOfAll
732 Comments - Last post 38 minutes ago by Arvennios
77 Comments - Last post 39 minutes ago by tarikgoethe
9,544 Comments - Last post 48 minutes ago by EveryShadeOfLife
124 Comments - Last post 53 minutes ago by GuiDoteiro
indicators suggesting fake giveaway:
registered less than 2 weeks ago
less than 20 games on steam
giveaway game on whishlist
no games in steam inventory
high priced giveaway
no description
less than one year on steam
multiple copies given away
game not on sale last few month
call of duty
indicators suggesting valid giveaway:
has done some giveaways
description (first giveaway, promoting something ...)
active member for some time
if most of the first list match, but none of the second -> probably fake
if at least one of the second matches -> probably legit
edit: do not call someone out, just because he fits this heuristic, its just probabilities and the giveaway may be legit. it just should help you spread your points where your chances of winning (and recieving) are higher.
Comment has been collapsed.