Actually, after some time, I'm adapting and the contributor giveaways created by members seem to be working nicely.
Just hope bundle keys rule be more strictly enforced so the contributor isn't abbused. Grats on the Krater policy.
So far contributor giveaways seem to be free of some hundreds or thousands of leeches entering them.
Thanks for the good work. Keep-up
Comment has been collapsed.
Interesting, thanks for the time you guys put into this. The UI changes to me are something of a drawback. It would be nice if we could choose to see only contributor, or only group giveaways at a time, like we can choose New, open and closed.
Visually, the additions are good, but I think they'd be better as additions, not a new format. I think that way, it would be more easily viewable.
Just my 2 cents.
Comment has been collapsed.
Looking at some of the required amounts (like 59.98), it seems that some people are making the contribution limit the maximum they are allowed to. Interesting.
I would like a way to hide the contributor giveaways I'm not eligible to enter but, now that it's shown on the front page, that isn't as important.
Comment has been collapsed.
I think contributor giveaways are a pretty shiny new feature, already created one. Hope to create more in the near future.
Thanks to loko and cg for all the great work you are doing for the site. :)
Comment has been collapsed.
You do realize that your browser has a back button that will alow you to exit the giveaway. Plus having people see what they're missing might encourage more of them to actually give back instead of just leeching.
Comment has been collapsed.
Look's like you didn't understand(or my thought is unclear). I want to have change option for the old style were (contributor/group/private){Game name}. It's very uncomfortable(mostly for eyes) to review is it contributor or group.
Comment has been collapsed.
Hello everyone,
This is probably going to be a longshot, but I might as well try anyway.
Basically, I have some concerns over the new contributor giveaways:
Other than that, it's a very good addition, I just hope it doesn't create the vicious circle I described in my first point. I do have one last concern, and it's that I'm making an enormous amount of points - and by that extent, everybody does. I think I make more than 100 points per 8 hours. The problem is that I'm entering giveaways for games I don't necessarily want, so that I keep making points.
Comment has been collapsed.
Your 2nd point is invalid. That's like asking why would someone give Skyrim away when he could keep it for himself.
The day you will start to contribute to the community you will understand why people make contributor giveaway instead of public.
Comment has been collapsed.
Agreed. Actually, I think it's sad that I can make a contributor giveaway with limited value of entry to twice as much as I gave already - like I once said, the more options, the better and if I want to make a giveaway just for certain people with X$ given away then it's my damn right. I'm tired of people who didn't give a shit discussing how should I spend my own money.
Comment has been collapsed.
all valid points. Everyone should be entitled to giveaway a game the way they want and to who they want; as long as it isn't in exchange for something in return... that wouldn't be generous at all and defeat the purpose of SG, in my opinion.
There'll probably be a mass decrease in public giveaways, but at least they'll be appreciated more (unlike some previous cases where people would be self-entitled to the point of actually COMPLAINING about the game being cheap!). In turn all the greedy leechers will be forced to actually give away something in order to gain access to the contributor giveaways. I just hope that beta keys don't count for the sake of those who actually paid for their gifts.
inb4: "look who's talking. You're a leecher as well. "
I'll be giving away soon enough, but my intentions won't be to be to gain access to "better" giveaways, but rather a way to say "thanks you guys".
Comment has been collapsed.
As someone who has never made a giveaway, and is unlikely to ever make one:
1 - That's a possibility. If the public giveaways are mostly contributor, then it means I have an easier time entering all the giveaways I'm allowed to. So I'll start entering for a wider range of games. 100% of public giveaways being contributor will probably scare off a lot of new people to Steam gifts, but remember that the current limit forces someones first giveaway to have no contributor requirement, which will keep off that problem for a while. So lets worry about that only if it comes up.
2 - The limit forces the existence of low contribution giveaways, which create more temptation for someone to make their first giveaway than if they were all $1000+ contributor giveaways.
3 - Grab the SG Enhancement Addon to filter them.
Comment has been collapsed.
Not everyone can contribute back, so it wouldn't necessary be fair. I like the idea of having the opportunity to thank the people who makes gifts but I don't want this to turn into leaving out the people who can't or don't want to. You can make all your giveaways contributor only if you wish, but some people are generous enough to make some for the whole community.
Comment has been collapsed.
I just noticed that when typing a game's name on the upper-right search box, the old format is used instead of the new layout. (Plus it doesn't even tells you if it's a contributor's giveaway.)
Comment has been collapsed.
11 Comments - Last post 1 minute ago by Almostn33t
16,336 Comments - Last post 18 minutes ago by Kenruyoh
339 Comments - Last post 31 minutes ago by UnbakedBacon
82 Comments - Last post 32 minutes ago by thanhsonvn8x
1,865 Comments - Last post 42 minutes ago by ngoclong19
1,021 Comments - Last post 42 minutes ago by sensualshakti
108 Comments - Last post 58 minutes ago by xxxka
9 Comments - Last post 6 minutes ago by Matwyn
8,035 Comments - Last post 9 minutes ago by JMM72
890 Comments - Last post 10 minutes ago by MyrXIII
28,285 Comments - Last post 10 minutes ago by crez3088
6,296 Comments - Last post 12 minutes ago by Oppenh4imer
105 Comments - Last post 15 minutes ago by Mikurden
78 Comments - Last post 19 minutes ago by 0ldNick
Hey everyone, we pushed a few updates live over the last day.
First off, the option to create contributor giveaways is now available to everyone. Head over to the create a giveaway page, and you'll see a new input box for contributor only. Simply enter an amount, and only users that have successfully sent that value or greater to other users in the community will be able to enter. The maximum amount you can enter is twice your own contributions. For example, if you have contributed $25.00, you can create contributor giveaways between $0.01 - $50.00. The option is disabled for users that have not contributed in the past. This option can be combined with both private and group giveaways as well. Keep in mind, group giveaways look at contributions in general, not for that particular group only.
Next, the display of giveaways has slightly changed. For example, take a look at lokonopa's profile. Contributor giveaways list the amount necessary on the right side. It'll be displayed in green if you can enter, or red if you cannot. Also, group and private giveaways are coloured. Once again, take another look at lokonopa's profile, this time, the won page. You can easily see private and group giveaways highlighted. These same display options are used on the homepage and general giveaway listings.
Comment has been collapsed.