Question: I believe I understand the calling out for fake rule, but I would like a little clarity since I have been here under a year.
Is it calling out if the user posts that it is an alpha key in the giveaway and then people post underneath that alpha giveaways are not allowed? It isn't making an assumption. I think you are supposed to just report it and not post, but I am not sure when the original giveaway indicates it is against the rules.
Comment has been collapsed.
yeah people shouldn't do that either.
ive seen users that even attack the giveaway creator calling them "retards" and even bothering to leave the same comment on their steam profile.
i hate those users even more
Comment has been collapsed.
I agree that insults directed at those giving away the game are real problems. I just saw a lot of "Alpha key giveaways are against the rules (Link to FAQ/Rules)." Those didn't seem to be calling out to me, but I have been told my definitions are wrong so I wanted clarity.
Comment has been collapsed.
it still is, they are assuming the game is fake/alpha/beta whatever, beforehand, there's a report button for a reason.
i dont really care about those though, most people dont even question or search the forum to know where the keys are coming from, the creators themselves don't even read the faq to know the rules.
Comment has been collapsed.
The report button is there for a reason indeed, but as far as I know, it's currently not working O.o
So at this moment... it's there just so you know there once was the possibility to report a giveaway, I guess :D
Comment has been collapsed.
My understanding is that the Report User button is what was broken. I could be confused, though.
Comment has been collapsed.
Funny how you used "triple a" in the text instead of "AAA". :P
Now on a serious note, many of those giveaways clearly state on their description they're alpha keys. So, maybe those can be deleted without a doubt.
Good luck, poor mods... All that work in a saturday. :/ I'm afraid too many people reporting will lead to multiple reports of the same GA, which might take even more time from the mods to check them out..
Comment has been collapsed.
I'm afraid the track record for these things is nobody that actually go for it cares one yota even if you stuff the whole forum with threads about it.
BTW games that get abused this way don't end up on the bundle list, usually they are removed completely.
Comment has been collapsed.
just a suggestion:
why not just remove evolve until November 2 ends then bring it back again? the EVOLVE Alpha ends on November 2 right?
this way, the alpha keys wont be given away and wont work at all when the code is input.
the full game codes will work.
Comment has been collapsed.
I'm on board with this solution. I can't tell whats a legit giveaway and whats an Alpha key. The few that I've reported (By pressing the report button that people seem to ignore in lieu of calling em out in the comments, people please...) are ones that openly admit to them being Alpha keys in the description.
Some don't have a description/too generic... which is all too confusing. I'd enjoy the chance to win the game, but, digging through all these for a real one is a bit tough. I can only imagine what its like for the mods.
Comment has been collapsed.
Sorry, but the Report button doesn't work currently. :( You have to open a support ticket.
Comment has been collapsed.
That's the report button on profiles for reporting users, not the report button on giveaways for reporting... giveaways.
Comment has been collapsed.
You're right, I thought all of them didn't work, but maybe I internalized this because of these reasons (both the linked post and the post below).
Comment has been collapsed.
What about people who won them? Will they get suspended for not owning evolve when alpha ends?
Comment has been collapsed.
well.. you always can set it back to not receive later anyway
Comment has been collapsed.
But will people remember to do it before the SG lurk police finds them and reports them for "not activating won gift"?
Comment has been collapsed.
release by a big publisher, well cover from media, hype, costly as hell, shinny to look at....etc
Comment has been collapsed.
So people who give away an alpha code will get to keep the CV boost?
Comment has been collapsed.
As long as support is made aware of the GA being incorrect (i.e. alpha key was given), then the user will not receive any CV. I'd also be sure to mark it 'not received' since it's not the correct item as well. It depends on the winner most likely doing that.
Comment has been collapsed.
Ok, I'll correct myself: they'll get the CV unless the winner marks the game as Not Received.
Comment has been collapsed.
apparently this psa is kinda useless.
quote: BEWARE it's a two ALPHA keys for somebody who want to try the game, please dont enter if you are already have it, I would check it before sending. Moderators allowed to giveaway it, so I hope it would be useful for somebody http://www.steamgifts.com/forum/7ZRGz/psa-about-evovle-alpha-keys
Comment has been collapsed.
Thank you Raiden, Shobo, and the other mods who are dealing with this mess. We appreciate your time and effort in keeping SG a nice place.
Comment has been collapsed.
I really think people shouldn't be able to make Evolve giveaways until after all this free alpha/beta stuff is over. The number of actual game giveaways compare to the number of free key giveaways is just too great. I like the extra points and all, but this is getting pretty stupid. Same goes for other stuff available as a free giveaway, like Nosferatu: The Wrath of Malachi, and Borealis.
Comment has been collapsed.
Except so far there has been an alpha, now we have the big alpha, which may be followed by a beta, big beta, holly crap is this a huge beta, gamma, another gamma, then it will be released to full version. May as well wait till they're done with all the free testing versions, the stated release date is 10 Feb, 2015 after all.
Comment has been collapsed.
I can see a bunch of people getting banned in the future for "not redeeming" their winnings, as the alpha will disappear from their steam account. But the win will remain on sg. Do yourself a favour and don't enter these giveaways. Report any that state they are alpha as it is still against the rules. Report anyone trying to give you an alpha key if you win, and mark it as not received.
Comment has been collapsed.
When the giveaway description clearly says it's for alpha keys, I don't understand how you can justify not deleting them....
Edit: okay, I guess they are being deleted now
Comment has been collapsed.
351 Comments - Last post 47 seconds ago by missiloon
44 Comments - Last post 51 minutes ago by Icepick87
8,481 Comments - Last post 1 hour ago by FranckCastle
15,562 Comments - Last post 1 hour ago by FranckCastle
78 Comments - Last post 3 hours ago by icaio
782 Comments - Last post 8 hours ago by MeguminShiro
595 Comments - Last post 9 hours ago by MeguminShiro
10 Comments - Last post 5 minutes ago by RCSWE
26,765 Comments - Last post 15 minutes ago by ManOman
2,470 Comments - Last post 42 minutes ago by JMM72
188 Comments - Last post 1 hour ago by Matty777
102 Comments - Last post 1 hour ago by FranckCastle
6,795 Comments - Last post 1 hour ago by ngoclong19
76 Comments - Last post 1 hour ago by NymCast
So a lot of people are taking advantage of those alpha keys and well...we all know how this goes but this could be a first where a triple a game ends up in a bundle list before it's even released as a full game.
So before I start sweeping for people calling out fakes and such and handing out suspensions for such behavior please be ready for how this may get handled and warn your fellow users to edit or delete the comments that incriminate them as soon as you can.
I'm not deleting any alpha giveaways for now as there are full copies being given away among the alpha ones. The way this may get handled is that those who abused the keys might get zero contribution. If you see someone giving away an absurd amount of copies then this may lead to a suspension for exploiting a game and inappropriate behavior.
To the abusers, good luck out there.
To the users that follow the rules, thank you for your help and understanding. Much mew.
EDIT: The giveaways may be removed temporarily soon as may the cv but the winners will be fine here so long as they aren't breaking any rules such as trading wins away and such. This is a very delicate matter so thanks for your patience.
I'm also aware some of you were lucky enough to login without seeing the OpenID error. This will be resolved soon enough as we await the site admin's awakening from his hibernation.
Comment has been collapsed.