Five Nights at Freddys or Among the Sleep or Outlast?

Outlast.

among the sleep and outlast. five nights at Freddy is almost all jumpscare, but among the sleep and outlast will give you the eerie scenario to immerse you in the fear :P

or maybe this is a different kind of scary you'll like :3

Outlast, but you can grab Five Nights At Freddy's too. It was in a bundle, so you may find a good price for that :)

I think I'd go for Among the Sleep, for what I've seen.

System Shock 2. If not, Outlast. Five Nights at Freddy's is novel, but it's crap. Among the Sleep isn't really very good.

I'd go with five nights at freddy's. You can still probably get it for like 1 Tod or .5 tf2 key.

Outlast.

FNAF is all jumpscare and no tension. Among The Sleep is too damn short to justify the price tag.

There's a free game similar to Among The Sleep, though.

Bad Rats is scary as hell!

outlast and its dlc whistleblower. dlc is even better than the base game.

Outlast. If you are looking for a long one, FN@F is really short but hard to master.

Go to some creepy building at midnight. You'll get the same (or even better) thing for free (make sure that there are some homeless people too, so they could scare you).

Outlast and Cry of Fear (full of jump scares and its free on Steam).

If you like horrors, you must play all of them!

I haven't played it, but five nights at Freddy's looked pretty boring, so I would probably go outlast.

I'll defend Freddy here a bit. Yes, it's jump scares all the way through... except it's not just that. It has one of the best build ups for scares. That game is also an asshole, and it's the only one that got me by surprise so much, that after 14 minutes or so I refused to play it any more. When I showed it to my friend, his reaction was similar too. So yeah, not sure about the other two (although Outlast becomes rather stale after the beginning, judging by some time I spent on it while at a friends'), but don't just ditch this one because of the jumpscares.

Outlast ! Great game