Should HiB 6 games considered "bundle games" if given away on sg??

I agree, they can't be abused in the same manner previous keys were abused.

Edit: In other words, logic escapes me at 3AM in the morning. Read: movac's post.

I don't think HiB games should be considered "bundle games" unless they were a beat the average individual key (like Dustforce). But it's not up to me. ;)

My Vessel is wortheless... Don't see much inflation for other than the BTA onces...

Keys are personal use only. It's illegal to give them away. Therefor you get one key.

I pay 1$, giveaway Torchlight, give someone the full key, are they going to care that much? I get 20$ contributor for 1$, it makes sense for them to be treated the same way as the other bundles for this reason.

I think you are stupid for complaining that you bought games from steam at a higher price and now complain they are too cheap and can not be given separately. You buy the bundles to help the developers and for charity . So don`t be a retard and complain about cheap games for charity.

Well i don't consider it a real bundle. Rather a game package that comes with 1 activation key.

I had 3 of them 6 games and felt a bit stupid that i basically "wasted" 3 games instead being able to give them away.
But on the other hand, it took me only 10$, i can't really complain about that price for 6 games for Steam -AND- DRM free -AND- Soundtrack.

While movac wrote why they are considered to be bundle games, I just wonder if pre-bundle giveaways are treated as such. Like, making all pre-bundle giveaways to be completely different game than post-bundle (and pre-bundle games wouldn't be possible to choose from menu)?

i have actually had previously purchased through steam games pop into my inventory when activating a humble key that included that very game, so that's sort of like what they're trying to prevent here. i could care less about contributor value though so it doesn't matter much to me, but i see where people could feel like their not-actually-having-anything-to-do-with-a-bundle gift is less appreciated because the game they decided to buy and give away got included in a bundle.

i've learned my lesson to giveaway everything i plan on giving away before a bundle comes out with it :P

P.S if fortix gets it a bundle, what do you think would happen, like if Fortix went in IG9, the bundle would be $1, fortix is $1 :P

A mod should put up a sticky thread or something giving us the info. Thnaks

Tey ARE BUNDLE GAMES the Epiphony of BUNDLE. they are BUNDLED INTO ONE KEY. and anyway giving out seperate keys are AGAINST HumbleBundle TOS unlike groupees or indie gala. and against this site where if it is against a bundles TOS it is against this sites TOS read the rules dipshit

I think it should be implemented for the games which was created after bundles. Imagine you buy one of the games way before bundle and gave it away and you got correct contrubitor points, but later they change it to lower points, i dont think its fair. Though the way i suggest requires really important tracking of bundles etc.

yeah so true

If anything, this proves that contributor value is flawed. But instead of fixing it, let's make rules that prevent people from giving away bundles, yeah, that's a great idea.

This has already been said, but I have to say it again. I still think they should have reduced contributor value. People will buy the bundle for $1 and then give it away under just one of the listed bundle games on steamgifts. So they grab the contributor value after all. It's still far too exploitable.

Because people have abused that already. The idea was to not include the individual games at the start, if they don't have individual keys, HOWEVER lots of people made giveaways for one of the games in the bundle (usually the most expensive) and gave the winner the bundle key (which includes that game along with all the rest they got for 1$).

So, there is your answer why we can't have nice things.

just throwing this out there..

whats wrong with labeling the giveaway as torchlight.. and giving the HB6 key. the winner gets torchlight (plus all other games)

(if this was answered above.. sorry)

I didn't get why the Swedish Bundle was going for so much (and I guess still is). That was a Steam-created Bundle though, right? I think all bundles should be treated the same. Let whatever the games inside sale for on Steam set the number of points.

Edit: I understand that this could be abused but still feel like there need to be a balance among indie-based game bundles.

torchlight should be. they rest shouldnt

Fact: Bundle cost 1u$s - ∞

More Facts: Nobody (over steam gifts at least =P) will pay more that 10$

Another fact: There is people that get the bundle for 1 $ and then they make a giveaway for the most valuable game of the bundle = profit

Its a shame but true =/ so i think that they must be considered bundle games

Ok, will buy and make a lot of giveways xD

just make all giveways for those games, made after bundle release worth 1$ problem solved

If i win TL and someone give me HIB6 - i willn't mark as recived. I want normal key\gift ^_^