Dishonored or Oblivion

many more hours of gameplay from Oblivion - tough choice tho

Dishonored. Oblivion does have hundreds and hundreds of hours but the quality of those is much lower. Dishonored offers a very tight set of gameplay mechanics.

If you're talking about vanilla game only, Dishonored. If you plan on modding a lot, then Oblivion.

Anyone that says Oblivion is of lesser quality probably only played Skyrim.. With a few graphics mods Oblivion shits on Dishonored.. Dishonored is good but it definitely doesn't have 100s of hours of playtime.

I REALLY felt Dishonered was too easy to have fun with :(

Oblivion Obliviously

If you happen to like Oblivion, you'll get much more out of it than Dishonored. Not all people like Oblivion, though. I'd recommend to try Dishonored now that it's free until tomorrow.

Dishonored

I got bored with Oblivion very quickly, once I got to the part where you have to close some portals, and it's basically the same mission about 8 times I think, so painfully long that I just cheated and flew trough the map. I liked Dishonored a lot more, but it does have much less playtime.

Oblivion is really good, but since you already have Skyrim, which is different but overall quite better then Oblivion, go for Dishonored.
And Since you like Stealth games, you won't be disappointed.

Spaghetti or pumpkin pie?
How can you even try comparing those 2 games ?

To be honest, I prefer Dishonored, but it depends on your personal preferences. I think that Dishonored is much more thrilling, has more action, better weapons, better enemies, and a lot better graphics.

Play Dishonored for free this weekend, then you'll know...

For me Oblivion >= Skyrim
It has the best guilds ever, mainly the Dark Brotherhood, its just epic!

Dishonored is on a free weekend now so I gave it a try, and I say buy Dishonored.
Seems to be a pretty decent game, I'm enjoying it very much so far :)

Dishonored definitely.

Remember, Oblivion has some Deluxe and Super Deluxe editions - one has most DLCs, while other has all DLCs. And you can't buy those additional DLCs alone. But AFAIK they are not that important.

dishonored

Skryim is better than Oblivion and if you enjoy Hitman and Splinter Cell, you should enjoy Dishonoured.

Dishonored.

If the choice is between Oblivion and not Oblivion, then go for not Oblivion (in this case Dishonored). This TES veteran still holds grudge towards Oblivion due to its general lack of quality content, horrible writing and voice acting that would make an elementary school project look good. (Well actually, the voice actors are not "that" bad, but hearing exactly the same voice on so many NPCs, and sometimes hearing them in two vastly different tones depending on what dialogue choice is a real immersion breaker).

Though if the choice can be expanded to Morrowind, go for Morrowind (and remember to mod it).

Oblivion.

Oblivion will give you more hours of fun, but if you have played Skyrim, try Dishonored (to change the type of game).

Oblivion. of course oblivion.