Should a member be suspended just cause he checked the "gift received" optioned?

Better question: what do you do if someone said they didn't receive it even after they activated the game on their account? I submitted a support ticket, but it was never answered.

The gifter can't force anyone to do anything. Why would the person check the gift as received if it wasn't?

How do you force somebody to do something over the internet?

Well I think that it's quite a serious issue. If I were asked I'd definitely suspend him if there's enough evidence. I think that threatening someone to mark a game as received when you haven't gifted it is way worse than many other acts that imply a ban.

If we look at it, the gifter did not only not gift the game, but also threatened/convinced the other person therefore cheating towards Contribution Value. I see there more than one and two possible causes of suspension IMHO.

Ok. I've realised I got the question wrong. I should read more carefully. The winner of the game should be suspended if there is enough evidence that the game was gifted, that he received it and that he has not it anymore.

yeah the first thing that would happen if someone doesnt sent me a gift but wants me to mark it as received: Screenshot,then "Reported to support,goodbye",then blocked on steam.

"My dad works for Steam and owns SteamGifts so you better mark received or I'll get you banned!"
Was that how he "forced" them?

Yes, he should be banned for being a stupid as hell and letting someone bully them into doing something over the internet.

When that happened to me (the guy wasn't a scammer, actually nice, had the game in his inventory too) I just said I won't do it 'til he gives me the game. I got the game.

I have a better question which also shows how stupid this question is; Should you say you received the gift if you did not receive the gift?

Yes, IMHO. It allows fake "gifters" to get away with cheating the system, and is simply collaboration in a scam.

If you didn't get the game, don't tick the box. Nobody can "force" you to do so.

I can't think of a single situation where doing so would make sense...

Harsh, but that's my opinion :)

If he didn't receive it, then he should just mark it as not received, can't be that hard.

A lot of ToS/rules, etc usually state that if you break any rule, either unintentionally or intentionally it'll still be considered an infraction of the ToS/rules. I think this is usually done because in a lot of cases you can't truly tell whether someone had intent or not, other than their word about it. Even so, if the guy who was "forced" to mark receive signed up for the site in any capacity it's partially his fault for not reading the FAQ. (As an aside, all large sites, relatively speaking, that have user content have some sort of rules. So IF they claimed they didn't know there was a FAQ, then that's a pretty piss poor excuse)