Gifting steam games not from steam

So it is better to pull the answer out from your arse, making up your own rules, even when a mod says the site is for steam games as of now? How very insightful and knowledgeable you are! (Sarcasm, in-case this buzzes over you) I said the clue was in the name because it should point as to a hint of what the site is for. Did I say that is for every site? No. I did however say it is for this one, which is currently true.

Since you're lumping two different people as one, let me clarify something, I never did say it had to be bought from the steam store, did I? Actually neither of us stated it had to be bought on steam, only that it had to be a redeemable steam key. Many people show sales from various sites for steam keys on the forum, which is fine and dandy and even very helpful.

Also nothing wrong with it, when the site is for -steam- games. If you want to do it differently in private amongst friends, that's your business, but the public giveaways adhere to a different set of rules, not the ones the little voices in your head tell you are true.

If you're whole point of insulting people was to point out the difference of public vs private giveaways, you could have at least attempted to be civil, instead of making a general ass of yourself by learning to word things differently. Somewhere in the effect of "While these things are true for Public giveaways for private..." and so on. Or even if we were completely off the mark, wording things in a more polite manner is still achievable. It really isn't that hard. ;)

It depends actually. Not all Witcher 2 keys are redeemable, just retail generally. If you buy it from D2D or GoG, it won't work on Steam.

What about Minecraft?