Just wanna bump this thread and thank you for the work!
Thanks to this thread, now whenever I wanna create a GA from past Indie Gala bundles, I can always check based on the bundle name to see if any of the games will not work. Saves me some future delete GA trouble.
Today I was revealing keys from Indie Gala - Indie Mosaic Bundle. And holy, luckily I checked this thread first, or else I am gonna disappoint 4 peoples with 4 GA deletion.
Comment has been collapsed.
just a kind of related news: i've been asking myself, for months, why Otakumaker SARL was still at Steam (as publisher) and where the -possible- money would go.
it's gone, now. all games have only the developer link (see pic below). curious about the dev?
Comment has been collapsed.
KORABLIK from Indiegala - Monday Motivation #25
https://steamcommunity.com/app/562760/discussions/0/1693795812289687163
https://steamcommunity.com/app/562760/discussions/0/1644290549105131388
Overhell from Groupees - Build a Bundle #26
https://steamcommunity.com/app/477980/discussions/0/1697175413689001604
Both from the same publisher, !Lim studio.
I tried 5 unused keys of KORABLIK, 4 dupes, 1 ok, and doesn't have a spare key for Overhell so cannot check.
Comment has been collapsed.
My old Steam key for "Taimumari" no longer works.
From a very old "Hardcore Cubic Bundle".
I have to buy a new key to gift my winner...
Comment has been collapsed.
Sorry for the late reply, if you don't want to buy a copy I'm sure it should be easy to trade for it either here on steamtrades, barter or lestrades. The game was bundled many times and there's an excess of copies and not that many demand.
Comment has been collapsed.
Huh? Why are you apologizing for? LOL
I posted here let OP add into the list.
Comment has been collapsed.
Robot Warriors keys from Go Go Bundle #29 and Go Go Bundle Mega #13 are invalid (in addition to Bunch Keys #30 already mentioned in the chart)
Comment has been collapsed.
SWEATER? OK! from Go Go Bundle Mega #21 keys are invalidated
Not sure about the soundtrack. If somebody has SWEATER? OK! and not the soundtrack, reply and I'll give you a key to try if you'll report back to us.
Comment has been collapsed.
Keys from IG's Rhythmic Story Bundle are unaffected, I just redeemed my key without problems.
Comment has been collapsed.
Hey Paul if you still haven't found anyone to test your key, I have the game but not the soundtrack althought with that kind of game I always wonder why they bother to sell a soundtrack...
Comment has been collapsed.
Sugar Box from Indie Gala Monday Motivation Bundle #40
Comment has been collapsed.
The Uncertain: Last Quiet Day - https://store.steampowered.com/app/406970/
from Hump Day Bundle #62, two dupe keys.
Comment has been collapsed.
Wow, this surprises me - I thought they were real-people devs.
Comment has been collapsed.
They are indeed legit devs and the dupes were already reported even back then when the bundle was live (just look at the comments), so IG just had a batch of bad keys for whatever reasons.
I tested an old key from another source and it was valid & working, so it's not a revocation issue. ;)
Comment has been collapsed.
Great, I'm so glad to hear this. Thanks for the info. I got mine from Hump Day 36, and didn't hear about any later problems.
Comment has been collapsed.
Truth Of Falchion - https://store.steampowered.com/app/820310/
from go go bundle 55, 5 dupe keys
Comment has been collapsed.
Won a two copy giveaway of Blind Men (https://store.steampowered.com/app/657290/), and the keys we were given turned out be duped. Giveaway creator mentioned they were from the IndieGala Kawaii Anime Bundle last year.
Comment has been collapsed.
I just discovered all the keys for Marble Duel from HeroCraft Bundle #1 - 16 December to 26 January 2018 are now duped. The others games from this bundle seems to be ok but I did not tested all of them.
Comment has been collapsed.
I can confirm this. All duped. The other games are fine, though.
Comment has been collapsed.
Dungeon Creepster from Go Go Bundle Mega #16 revocked . Can anyone confirm ?
Comment has been collapsed.
If I recall correctly, that was one of the games given away massively on GameJunkie, with warning that there may be dupes. So it's possible the dev just gave away the same keys.
Comment has been collapsed.
Update for the BORIS the Mutant Bear with a Gun report.
The dev emailed me a new key so anyone that needs a replacement can try emailing ducat@borisgame.com
Note, some patience may be required, it did take about 10 days for him to email me back.
Comment has been collapsed.
Not really the revocation though, but Syder Arcade from Humble Flash Bundle: Shmups keys are invalid (not duped, but invalid, don't be confused). Will soon get the answer from HB support
Comment has been collapsed.
There was a problem with the Syder Arcade Humble keys. I contacted the dev about it a year or so ago, and he directed me to Humble Support, which provided a working key even though it was a while after the fact.
Comment has been collapsed.
My Maze Run VR keys from Otaku Bundle #12 are duped.
Comment has been collapsed.
@Steam: http://store.steampowered.com/app/681550/Maze_Run_VR/
@SG: https://www.steamgifts.com/discussion/KEymE/otakubundle-otaku-bundle-12
just tried, same here.
more rotten keys:
- Maze Run VR 97FI0--M5Q7W 2018-02-13 20:09 Otaku Bundle #12 - 11 January to 16 February 2018
- Maze Run VR H8XFF--MK6CX 2018-02-13 20:09 Otaku Bundle #12 - 11 January to 16 February 2018
- Maze Run VR 06CKK--MM8Z6 2018-02-13 20:09 Otaku Bundle #12 - 11 January to 16 February 2018
- Maze Run VR INVXJ--TKT3R 2018-02-13 20:09 Otaku Bundle #12 - 11 January to 16 February 2018
central parts::
- 62W6K
- 7VTDE
- KA7QE
- DCZYK
Comment has been collapsed.
Safety Driving Simulator: Car keys were revocked . Can anyone confirm ?
Comment has been collapsed.
I had 1 unused key each for Gump Runner and Pic Guesser from Cubic Bundle August 2 (2017) and both a dupe now.
Comment has been collapsed.
Same here, I had four spare keys and I can confirm that both keys for each game are dupes now.
EDIT:
Pic Guesser- https://steamcommunity.com/app/625950/discussions/0/3166519278495805337/
Gump Runner- https://steamcommunity.com/app/606050/discussions/0/3175526477753634558/
Comment has been collapsed.
Hope this isn't too much spam... :)
Yep, too much spam. :( Error. Comments are limited to 10,000 characters or less.
In preparation for a planned visit to Venus Islands, I had the opportunity to use a bunch of my old leftover bundle keys...
From a pile of 5000 keys, about 15% were bad. :( Not sure if this means key-revoking is a popular event with "developers" nowadays, or maybe I should stop buying garbage bundles from dodgy bundle sites...
I see several of these key revocations have already been reported, but not all of them. Yay.
Anyway, one bad key could be a fluke, maybe I forgot to mark it used, gave it to someone or whatever. But I'd suggest not trying to make any giveaways for any of your leftovers that were bad for me multiple times...
123 Slaughter Me Street (Go Go Bundle 47) - 4/6 BAD
A Salem Witch Trial - Murder Mystery (Daily Indie Game Store) - 2/2 BAD
Adrenaline Adventure (Go Go Bundle limited 78) - 5/5 BAD
Archangel (Go Go Bundle limited 16) - 5/7 BAD
Archery Blast (Daily Indie Game Store, Go Go Bundle mega 18) - 13/13 BAD
Battle of Painters (Cubic Bundle one dollar 2, Daily Indie Game Super Bundle 113, Go Go Bundle limited 15, OtakuMaker Bundle 5) - 35/35 BAD
Beer and Skittls VR (Daily Indie Game Store) - 2/4 BAD
Beerman (Go Go Bundle mega 6) - 2/4 BAD
BitRay (Steamground Store) - 4/4 BAD
BitRay2 (Indie Gala Friday 52, Steamground Store) - 4/4 BAD
Bitcoin Farm (Go Go Bundle mega 18) - 9/9 BAD
Brick Breaker Ultimate (Go Go Bundle mega 18) - 10/10 BAD
Call Of The Mighty Warriors (Go Go Bundle mega 4) - 11/13 BAD
Christmas Mission (Bunch Keys Bundle 14, Steamground Store) - 5/5 BAD
Christmas Race (Go Go Bundle mega 18) - 10/10 BAD
Clergyman (Daily Indie Game Store) - 4/6 BAD
Clumsy Chef (Daily Indie Game Store) - 4/6 BAD
Copter and Sky (Daily Indie Game Super Bundle 113) - 3/5 BAD
CosmoLands | Space-Adventure (Steamground Store) - 3/3 BAD
Crazy Road (Daily Indie Game Store) - 2/4 BAD
Cube Land Arena (Go Go Bundle mega 4) - 12/14 BAD
Cubicity (Daily Indie Game Store, Go Go Bundle mega 6) - 17/19 BAD
Cunning Fox (Daily Indie Game Store) - 5/7 BAD
Cute Hedgehog (Daily Indie Game Store) - 4/6 BAD
Dark Maze (Bunch Keys Bundle new year frenzy) - 6/8 BAD
Death penalty: Beginning (Daily Indie Game Store) - 6/6 BAD
Demon Horde Master (Daily Indie Game Store) - 18/20 BAD
Dice unique rules (Daily Indie Game Store) - 23/25 BAD
Dojini (Daily Indie Game Store) - 2/2 BAD
Enigmatis: The Ghosts of Maple Creek (Indie Gala Bundle artifex mundi 7) - 3/4 BAD
Escape from pyramid (Daily Indie Game Store) - 8/10 BAD
Etaria | Survival Adventure (Steamground Store) - 3/3 BAD
Favorite Miner (Daily Indie Game Store) - 6/8 BAD
Flying Bacon:Ukrainian Air Force (Daily Indie Game Store, Go Go Bundle limited 58) - 14/14 BAD
Galactic Battles (Bunch Keys Bundle 14) - 2/4 BAD
Gelu (Daily Indie Game Store) - 2/4 BAD
George's Memories Ep.1 (Daily Indie Game Store) - 2/2 BAD
Ghoulboy - Dark Sword of Goblin (Go Go Bundle 56) - 6/6 BAD
Golf 2D (Go Go Bundle mega 18) - 10/10 BAD
Gravity Ball (Go Go Bundle mega 18) - 10/10 BAD
Guinea-Pig (Bunch Keys Bundle 14, Steamground Store) - 5/5 BAD
H0ST (Daily Indie Game Store) - 2/3 BAD
Hammer 2 (Go Go Bundle mega 11, Go Go Bundle mega 18) - 11/11 BAD
Happy New Year Clicker (Daily Indie Game Store) - 4/4 BAD
Happy Santa (Daily Indie Game Store) - 5/7 BAD
Haters, kill them all! (Daily Indie Game Store) - 4/4 BAD
Heavy Destinies (Indie Gala Bundle indie game lover) - 2/4 BAD
It`s Chicken! (Daily Indie Game Store) - 8/10 BAD
iterform (Daily Indie Game Store) - 2/2 BAD
...
Comment has been collapsed.
...
JAILBREAK (Bunch Keys Bundle 14) - 2/4 BAD
johns.game (Daily Indie Game Store) - 4/4 BAD
Kabitis (Daily Indie Game Store) - 3/5 BAD
Land of Puzzles: Battles (Daily Indie Game Store) - 2/2 BAD
Land of Puzzles: Castles (Daily Indie Game Store) - 2/2 BAD
Land of Puzzles: Knights (Daily Indie Game Store) - 2/2 BAD
Little Kite (OtakuMaker Bundle 17) - 4/4 BAD
Lucky Panda (Daily Indie Game Store) - 3/5 BAD
Luvocious (OtakuMaker Bundle 24) - 4/4 BAD
Maze Run VR (Daily Indie Game Store) - 4/4 BAD
Mortar Howl (Steamground Store) - 5/5 BAD
Mortificatio (Go Go Bundle limited 77) - 6/6 BAD
Neon Sun (Daily Indie Game Store) - 4/4 BAD
Operation Desert Road (Go Go Bundle mega 18) - 10/10 BAD
Outrunner (Steamground Store) - 4/4 BAD
PIGMENTUM (Daily Indie Game Store, Steamground Store) - 5/5 BAD
Paint Skills (Go Go Bundle mega 14) - 2/4 BAD
Piggy Poggy Pog (Daily Indie Game Store) - 5/7 BAD
Pirates Deck (Daily Indie Game Store) - 4/4 BAD
PooSky (Go Go Bundle limited 50) - 2/2 BAD
Psi Project (Bunch Keys Bundle 14, Steamground Store) - 13/15 BAD
Psi Project: Legacy (Daily Indie Game Store) - 8/10 BAD
ROMBY (Go Go Bundle 46) - 2/4 BAD
Race (Daily Indie Game Store, Go Go Bundle mega 18) - 12/12 BAD
Remaining in a dream (Cubic Bundle weekend 5, Steamground Store) - 6/6 BAD
Restoration (Go Go Bundle 45) - 2/2 BAD
Reveal (Bunch Keys Bundle 45) - 3/5 BAD
RiotZ (Steamground Store) - 3/3 BAD
SAMOLIOTIK (Daily Indie Game Store, Steamground Store) - 5/5 BAD
SWEATER? OK! (Go Go Bundle mega 21) - 6/6 BAD
Save the Lamb (Daily Indie Game Store) - 13/15 BAD
Shoot Paint (Steamground Store) - 4/4 BAD
Smart Mummy (Bunch Keys Bundle 14) - 4/5 BAD
SnakEscape (Go Go Bundle mega 20) - 2/2 BAD
Solar System (Go Go Bundle mega 18) - 9/9 BAD
Soldier of Failure (Steamground Store) - 3/5 BAD
Soldier of Failure 2 (Daily Indie Game Store) - 3/5 BAD
Soldier of Failure: Operation Zombie (Daily Indie Game Store) - 15/17 BAD
Space Rocket (Daily Indie Game Store, Go Go Bundle mega 18) - 13/13 BAD
Space Way (Go Go Bundle mega 18) - 10/10 BAD
SpaceRoads (Daily Indie Game Store) - 23/25 BAD
StarFringe: Adversus (Daily Indie Game Store) - 4/4 BAD
Survival Tycoon (Daily Indie Game Store) - 2/4 BAD
TOXIC PLUMBING (Bunch Keys Bundle 14) - 5/5 BAD
TWIN BROS (Go Go Bundle mega 5) - 3/5 BAD
The Agony (Daily Indie Game Store) - 4/4 BAD
The Evil Party (Daily Indie Game Store) - 4/5 BAD
The Last Vampire (Bunch Keys Bundle 14) - 6/6 BAD
Unstoppable Hamster (Bunch Keys Bundle 14) - 2/4 BAD
Volstead (Daily Indie Game Store, Go Go Bundle mega 1) - 14/14 BAD
Walls in Dead (Daily Indie Game Store) - 8/10 BAD
Werewolf Life (Bunch Keys Bundle 14) - 4/5 BAD
Word Killer: Revolution (Daily Indie Game Super Bundle 99, Go Go Bundle mega 1) - 6/8 BAD
Word Killer: Zorgilonian Chronicles (Daily Indie Game Super Bundle 99, Go Go Bundle mega 1) - 9/11 BAD
Zombie Zoeds (Daily Indie Game Store) - 2/2 BAD
Oh, hey, this would be the usual place to dump a giveaway, except This game plans to unlock in approximately 3 days... :( Create giveaway = nope. :( Oh well, maybe you can guess what's coming... https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=V7EfnYwpmOE :)
Comment has been collapsed.
Hewwo.
At least an overall number of keys you tested per game would be helpful to put this in some form of context. 14 bad keys sounds like a lot, but 1 bad key is one out of how many? 1 out of 2? 1 out of 20?
As in, did you have working keys of these games too? Were keys from other bundles than those named the working ones?
(Did you activate keys until one worked, or did you try to supply 20-50 accounts with copies, so that you would have multiple successful activations too?)
For DIG Store keys, they might be copies resold from other places like Go Go Bundle for some games (The Tower - Fantogame or SpaceRoads), but I guess not for things like The Tower Of Elements that first appeared in a DIG Greenlight bundle.
Comment has been collapsed.
Ahh, you're right, hmm... That would take a bit of work, but I will have a think and see if I can come up with something... :)
Comment has been collapsed.
Ok, cleaned things up a bit, only listing the games where I had multiple bad keys now...
Don't think one bad key says much, maybe the developer resold some, maybe I forgot to mark it, maybe the bundle site screwed up, who knows? :)
Comment has been collapsed.
Thanks for the gigantic list! I am not sure yet how to incorporate this in the post, since I am also restricted by the character limit. As the thread is right now, I'm approaching max.
Time is another problem :D
For now, as a reference, it's extremely valuable!
Comment has been collapsed.
R.I.P. to those keys.
Thanks for the massive list!
Comment has been collapsed.
Well, it kinda eliminates any possibility of a Ziggurat Part 2... :( But really, what else would I have done with these keys? :)
Anyway, if a low-confidence metric game gets revoked in the forest, does anyone even care? :)
Comment has been collapsed.
Some more data points or different bundles for some of the new ones on your list:
Archery Blast (Go Go Bundle Mega #18) - 4/4 BAD
Clumsy Chef (BunchKeys Bundle #19) - 1/1 BAD
Favorite Miner (BunchKeys Bundle #19) - 1/1 BAD
Flying Bacon:Ukrainian Air Force (Go Go Bundle Limited #30 and Go Go Bundle Limited #58) - 4/4 BAD
Galactic Battles (Bunch Keys Bundle #14) - 1/1 BAD
H0ST (Go Go Bundle #40) - 1/1 BAD
Little Kite (Otaku Bundle #11 and Otaku Bundle #17) - 7/7 BAD
PIGMENTUM (Go Go Bundle Mega #5) - 3/3 BAD
Piggy Poggy Pog (Bunch Keys Bundle #14) - 1/1 BAD
Psi Project (Bunch Keys Bundle #14) - 1/1 GOOD
Psi Project 2 (Bunch Keys Bundle #14) - 1/1 BAD
Reveal (Bunch Keys Bundle #37) - 1/1 GOOD
Save The Lamb (Bunch Keys Bundle #14) - 1/2 BAD
Soldier of Failure (Bunch Keys Bundle #14) - 1/1 BAD
Soldier of Failure 2 (Bunch Keys Bundle #14) - 1/1 BAD
Soldier of Failure: Operation Zombie (Bunch Keys Bundle #14) - 2/2 BAD
StarFringe: Adversus (GMG May 2017 Bundle) - 1/1 BAD
The Agony (Go Go Bundle Mega #5) - 1/1 BAD
The Last Vampire (Bunch Keys Bundle #14) - 1/1 BAD
Walls In Dead (Bunch Keys Bundle #22) - 1/1 GOOD
Luvocious from Bunchkeys Bundle #23 was still good
If somebody has Flying Bacon and not the DLC, I have some keys you can try to see if those are duped now, too.
If somebody has Little Kite and not the DLC, I have some keys you can try to see if those are duped now, too.
Comment has been collapsed.
I still have a few dozen untested Clumsy Chef keys, plus about 18000 other random possibly working bundle leftovers, but there's not much chance I'll be visiting visit São Paulo or Istanbul or whatever other interesting Steam places there might be to justify testing them... :)
And I never did see those mystical Venus Islands, saw so many bad keys instead I kinda forgot the original point of this whole mess... :)
Comment has been collapsed.
BitRay keys have been used on DupedOrNot for a long time, so that's probably why they're duped. SAMOLIOTIK was also used in mass giveaways.
Comment has been collapsed.
I feel dumb, never heard of DupedOrNot... So it's some kind of giveaway thing? Guess I didn't miss anything... :)
I wonder if developers can see which keys weren't redeemed yet, and give them away later just to troll us...
Comment has been collapsed.
Don't feel dumb! It's a site where you do tasks for a key that may be used or not - they're shady af, but I've gotten working keys for Bitray from them.
Comment has been collapsed.
Yeah, the only stuff I'm going to do for a key is click on the buy button. :) Life's too short... :)
Comment has been collapsed.
Bye-Bye, Wacky Planet from Parallel Worlds Bundle (Cubic Bundle) turned out to be duped. I only had one key, so I can't check if it's widespread.
Hoven the Sages Spinel is also duped, from Abstract Cubic Bundle. Same as before, I could only check one key.
Edit: On the May Cubic Bundle, The Prism & Rooks Keep are duped as well.
Comment has been collapsed.
I can confirm that Hoven the Sages Spinel, Rooks Keep, and The Prism from the Cubic bundles are duped.
Keys from Groupees for The Prism (Be Mine: Limited Edtion) and Hoven the Sages Spinel (Casual Bundle #6) work, so the Cubic bundle keys might be the only ones affected.
Comment has been collapsed.
SEXXXNATOR: Adult Sandbox RPG
from giveaway.su has been revoked less than 2 days after the giveaway
Comment has been collapsed.
Well, we don't know the reason. Maybe g.su did not pay them. Maybe the keys were stolen and sold to g.su. Or whatever.
Comment has been collapsed.
Not only that but if it was free and you paid nothing for it then what are you reporting exactly? Yea I understand that it stinks and is an unfortunate situation but when you actually pay for something it gives you certain 'rights' that you don't get when it's free.
Comment has been collapsed.
I disagree. If you were given ownership of something than it's yours and not for someone else to revoke or do as they desire [including taking back].
I did not own this game beforehand so this doesn't affect me in the slightest. But devs/companies should do business with honor and honesty. This is bad commercial practice. They should be reported otherwise they will keep doing it.
Comment has been collapsed.
Also Hentai Petting Simulator from same dev.
https://store.steampowered.com/app/1125250/Hentai_Petting_Simulator/
Comment has been collapsed.
Bought SEXXXNATOR: Adult Sandbox RPG + Sex City + Hentai Petting Simulator from one of those russian stores and the keys were revoked too, so it's not (only) related to giveaway su.
Comment has been collapsed.
Skull Rush from the IndieGala - Indie Rocket is showing as a Duplicate when just tryed to redeem it.
SecondSpeed from IndieGala - Monday Motivation #24 also redeeming as a Duplicate.
Comment has been collapsed.
The Note unused keys from Indie Gala Eerie Monday were revoked..
Comment has been collapsed.
I can confirm that the following keys from Otaku bundles were revoked:
- Little Kite (dev provided a new working key)
- Ghoulboy - Dark Sword of Goblin (dev provided a new working key)
- Firewood (dev provided a new working key)
- Inexistence (dev refuses to give new key)
- Math Combat Challenge
I see that Little Kite is not on the list yet.
Comment has been collapsed.
Summer Rush: all of my keys (and from Indiegala as well) are duped.
The Far Kingdoms: Age of Solitaire was also reported as duped by my friend
Heaven & Hell - duped too
all from the same publisher
Comment has been collapsed.
Do you know where his key for The Far Kingdoms: Age of Solitaire was from? (IndieGala or Groupees?)
Comment has been collapsed.
Summer Rush and Far Kingdoms were dupes for me too plus 3 additional games from that bundle (Cursed Kingdom)
Comment has been collapsed.
According to this comment, Octave keys from Groupees - Bundle of the Damned 6 have been revoked. I have checked mine (I had a spare from that bundle, never revealed) and it also it's a duplicate.
Comment has been collapsed.
Also checked a key from the Remute's Retrofuturism Flashback Bundle and it's also a duplicate. Great. Created a discussion on Steam about it.
Comment has been collapsed.
Lists to use:
Unused Keys Revoked: https://barter.vg/notices/513
Revoked (Dev): https://barter.vg/notices/362
Revoked (DMCA): https://barter.vg/notices/361
Duplicates: https://barter.vg/notices/372
If you want this information for one game specifically, you can find it under the "Notices" section for the Barter entry of that game.
(Example: https://barter.vg/i/42708/ then scroll down to "Notices": you'll see the red notice "Revoked (Dev) ⌫"; mouseovering it will give you some more info)
Thanks to everyone who reported their key revocations here. Please continue reporting them here. You folks are awesome!
Due to character limit, time constraints and having to manually create the chart rows, it's very difficult to keep a list on revocations on SteamGifts. Since I am the one managing these notices on Barter anyway, I thought it would be convenient to centralize the reports from SteamGifts and trade offers into one place and Barter proved to be a good solution for that because of its bundles and game database.
The below lists will not be updated on SG any more, but all your reports will be reflected on Barter, so please continue reporting them.
Previous links, for reference:
A list of games completely revoked from your library after activation
A list of games whose unredeemed keys were revoked (the big chart that was previously in this thread was moved here)
More games with invalidated keys can be found here.
Comment has been collapsed.