My Bioshock one giveaway dillema

You have to give it.

You have to, he/she won it. They get what they won, if you don't you'll be forced to deal with a 'not received' mark on your profile. I personally don't care what you do, just prepare to deal with the consequences. Plus are you REALLY going to get all freaked out and nervous over giving a game you paid one damn dollar for?

Others pretty much already answered your question: it's not a valid reason NOT to give the game to the winner if he is VAC banned.

If it bothers you that much, you can ask the mods to approve a special rule for your next giveaway.
Please note that only private GAs and GAs in private groups can have a special rule and that it's not 100% safe to say that you will get your rule approved by a mod.

Of course, if a "not-received" on your profile doesn't bother you, you could also decide not to deliver the game, but I wouldn't recommend that option.

Personally, I wouldnt give it. I value my own opinion and belief more than few letters on a profile. Its not like it means anything anyway.

Next time you make a giveaway and you don't want vac banned players entering your giveaway just make a private giveaway and ask support to approve your special rule then you can reroll based on the rule that was approved by support in your private giveaway.

I would just like to point that the VAC system is not infallible and has targeted innocent people before. As such it is not grounds to automatically deny a won gift.

He can be serial killer and you still have to give him the game, otherwise he'll mark it as not received.

U have made a giveaway to give a game, why isnt he eligible to have it? we are talking about doing a good deed and give a present not about having prejudices

You kinda have to or it will say a non-recieved game on your profile. Just because he has a VAC ban dosen't mean dosen't mean that you can judge someone like that. Sometimes people just make tiny mistakes in their life and it leads to that; and like everything in this world, has flaws, so it might of just screwed up. Plus he has already payed for the consequences of his actions, why make the person suffer more? Remember that everyone in the world is human and we can only take so much.

you kinda have to, its not an acceptable reason to reroll on a public giveaway. next time do a group or private with the rule "no vac bans" contact support about setting that up.

magne (0 seconds ago)
dont give he will probably mark it as not recieved anyways

dont give he will probably mark it as not recieved anyways

he made a mistake (god knows how long ago). just forgive him and give his gift. second chances are good things.

The best thing you can probably do is contact the SG staff.
Ask them what you should do, and if there is enough reason to do so, they can reroll the winner for you.

Well I decided to re-roll as I felt this was the best option although to many but not all this may seem like a dick move but i think it was for the best.