The best game they've never played...

Good story? BioShock 2, Spec Ops: The Line (one of the best story and emotion-wise games you can find!), Tomb Raider 2013, Fallout 3.

Also sorry to dissapoint you, but MP3 story and climate sucks compared to MP1 and 2. MP3 is not noir anymore - it's just generic shooter with nice graphics.

Did not played, but shivah is a nice option. Its from the develop. of the Blackwell series and those are nice.

Just Cause 2. It's actually a good game, especially now with multiplayer, you should try it :)

I've played that actually. I don't know why it's not counted. I think it's because it's a DLC

Go play Deus Ex you naughty person!

Darksiders, HL2, HL.

GTA series, Borderlands 2

Dead Space

Torn between Galactic Civilization II, Company of Heroes and Dawn of War.

Probably Company of Heroes is the best out of those 3.

Bad Rats ;)
Burnout Paradise (not sure if works with Windows 7 very well, just a warning) Half 2 episode 1/2. Not too familiar with most your games.
Hope you start feeling happier soon.

I've always loved the original Ys I & II games. The combat is unconventional for that type of RPG, but I've always found the game quite charming.

Oooohh... play World of Goo!!! That game is a fantastic little puzzle/physics game. Its quirky, funny, and a lot of fun.

Also can I just point out how embarrassingly bad it is that I can't run Hotline Miami? Lol.

It's straight-up heresy that you haven't booted up Bioshock Infinite yet

Deus Ex HR

Half Life 2 Episode 2.

A couple good ones... but I'll go with Mafia II. With games like Sleeping Dogs and Max Payne 3 near the top of your list in terms of playtime, seems like it's third person shooting and pseudo-open world might be up your alley. Great story too, if you're into a good tale about organized crime.

Titan Quest is a fantastic ARPG, although I'd say that it requires the expansion (Immortal Throne), plus the fanpatch and TQVault (to store your goodies).

Also, the original Max Payne games are great, but you've probably played them somewhere else.

You have committed heresy for not playing Company of Heroes.

I did it so they I could have suggestions for myself separately.
Now go and play Darwinia.

Fortix, of course!

Portal and Portal 2.

Skyrim, New Vegas, Spec Ops(!!!!!!), you really have a ton of great unplayed games ;)
Skyrim and New Vegas are awesome if you like to immerse yourself in the atmosphere, and Spec Ops... Well, it's really not a game you think it is =) But it gives you a ton of emotions when you play through it, and even messes with your mind in the process =)

Was already planning on starting Deus Ex this weekend :)

SAINTS ROW IV!

GTA, Fallout, DeusEx, Darksiders, Bioshock

Aww, you still haven't got around to playing that copy of Thief DS you won. Or Thief II, for that matter. Step up yer game, mate: there's a new classic born for every lukewarm game you finish. )

Men of War: Assault Squad

but, i aggre, risen is good RPG :D