what? I've read the books but have absolutely no idea what you're on about...
Comment has been collapsed.
ohh...hm ye well, I don't know how to answer this without spoiling the shit out of the books..so I'm just going to
Comment has been collapsed.
The books do better in most instances - it's like LotR, epic movies but compared to books it's nothing, because when you read the books you create your own world - and all that goes away when someone forces a particular view/look on you.
Comment has been collapsed.
I wouldn't say IT'S NOTHING, compared to the books. That's just some fancy shit so called fancy people like to say. LOTR is great. Both the movies and the books. Same goes for GoT. I wouldn't say that one is better than the other (specially with GoT)
Comment has been collapsed.
The small difference. LOTR, from books to big screen. Roughly 9 hours, thats equal to an average of 3~ hours a book.
GOT = 4 seasons x 10 episodes each x ~1 hour each , but actually there are 4 seasons for 3 books, thats an average of 13.33 hours per book.
It is true that you can create your own world by reading books and you can only grasp the tip in a movie, but GOT had his time to show that world to you. I think that the airing time of the show itself is about the time invested in reading 2 books of LOTR.
Comment has been collapsed.
I don't think we can say anything else without further spoilers
Comment has been collapsed.
No, i meant, what do you think about the fight itself
As an example, the red wedding, well, it took us all by surprise, whether in the books or the show, it was totally unexpected.
This fight though, i doubt it surprised anyone (maybe just on how bad the result was). He was asking for it when he didnt finished the job, i mean, its even cliche in most horror movies, not surprising at all. I think it was lame. Specially the credits part.
You are not fooling anyone Mr. Martin.
Comment has been collapsed.
+1. Oh and great puzzle man. Don't have photoshop though, so I'm stuck.
Comment has been collapsed.
Yes. I had a feeling in the gut that something real bad could happen, but with the exception of Ned's beheading (which is understandable, joffrey was a douche), the surprises were very small. Nothing really big was happening in the show in term of surprises until the red wedding. That took us all with the guard down.
Comment has been collapsed.
Honestly its far from being an original story, and the books are badly written, not to mention a succession of seriously sloooow chapters in the 3rd or 4th book.
The only thing it really has for itself is that a lot of main characters die.
I'm reading three months in the southern states atm in a different style ( a journal ), and i enjoy every page of it more than any volume of GoT. Except that first slave rebellion with the dragon melting the eyes, that was seriously good.
Otherwise you're better off reading something else.
Comment has been collapsed.
Awesome gif, saved it and waiting to re-use it.
And yeah... Reading churchill's 2 volumes biography of marloborough and a few other books atm, all non fiction and theoretically "dry" subjects and yet...yeah. Just a thousand times better written, every single one of them.
At best i would consider his writing style average amateur, But that's just me :-)
Now if you want a serious debate on the subject, feel free to pm me to avoid spoiling for others, i love debating about books, and who knows, you may change my mind :-)
Comment has been collapsed.
Yup, Martin stole ancient hellenic and roman texts, some stuff from middle ages like siege of Constantinople and greek fire, War of the Roses (when, oh look at the coincidence, writers started using detailed and brutal descriptions of war, pillages, rapes and all that for the first time, just like Martin is being the first naturalist among the bunch of romanticistic fantasy writers)... Oh, and Dany, her travels, gathering huge army from various sources in the middle of enemy territory? People should read Anabasis from Xenophon.
OK, everyone has sources, but he's a bad writer. If he was writing like that anywhere outside of US, no one would ever hear of him.
All that said, I like to watch the show. I guess I'm getting old.
Comment has been collapsed.
Oberyn was a cool guy, I didn't expect it till he started to act like a douche dancing with his weapon around, yelling at mountain to say his sisters name. I was quite shocked when mountain smashed his head, lol.
Sad that most interesting characters always die sooner or later, but I guess that's what makes these series so great.
Comment has been collapsed.
I thought it was a great interesting execution, though I wanted him to survive.
Comment has been collapsed.
I'm not watching any more episodes since i learned today that GoT is just a thin veiled charade for promoting rape culture, misandry and misogyny. I'm just going to go on twitter right now to express my disgust with wide array of activism inducing HASHTAGS
Comment has been collapsed.
Oh come on, they had to make that scene, i mean She is a hottie.
But this is different, many characters are lust demons, like tyrion in earlier seasons, oberyn martell, Theon, Bron, etc. They just want sex.
Grey worm did not intended to rape missandei, he loves her, you can see that in the show, he even learn the word "precious" because she is important to him (and looks like the opossite as well, they might have a sex scene, he apologized. Its quite the same relationship that jorah the andal has with Daenerys, he loves her, and of course he gets horny if he see her naked, but i bet you that he would not rape/harm her love.
Talking about misogyny. There are more misogyny today than the one reflected in the show*, you can see that by the amount of memes. The fact that most people dont say it out loud, does not necessarily mean that it doesnt exist at all.
Comment has been collapsed.
The show has really fucked up what the books were about. Also, Eunuchs are almost entirely asexual.
Comment has been collapsed.
The books were about the gruesome horror of reality, and how the people in charge are there because they've given up their humanity. The show is about how many tits they can shove in to draw in viewers. Sex scenes' graphic nature makes them very different in writing than visually, but the directors seem to fail to understand or purposely attempt to change the meaning to A Song of Ice and Fire.
Comment has been collapsed.
How exactly the top guys, especially Lannisters and their lackeys in the show didn't gave up humanity? O_o I am sorry, the fact you tuned out the sex scenes in the book doesn't mean they're not there. In fact, no spoilers, but had you read book 5, you'd knew show has nothing on books so far.
Comment has been collapsed.
Sex on TV is not sex in a book. That's why internet porn is so big now, and pornographic books have mostly been phased out. I read the A Dance with Dragons. The sex scenes were entirely normal. In the show, however, the rape scene with Cersei and Jaime killed both of their characters. Jaime became an ass who took whatever he wanted. He used to have a degree of ethics. He did what was right for he and Cersei, and in the books, that continued, but not in the show. And Cersei became a weak, powerless puppet. That is nothing like the mad queen I know from ASOF.
Comment has been collapsed.
There are these great websites for that. TV, however, is not a good place to vent sexual frustration.
Comment has been collapsed.
It was not what i expected. I expected him to win so you know who could get away free. However I'm like... WHAT! I know I know, I'll start the books after this season ends, I only just started S1 a month or two ago.
Comment has been collapsed.
I was expecting it to be a draw for a second, with both characters mortally wounded, but it looks like The Mountain is going to be considered the winner (no idea if he is mortally wounded or not though).
So I guess that means that Golden boy is going to have to break him out of the capital. At least that is my guess.
Also: "Smash the Beatles, Smash Them! Cuh! Cuh! Cuh!"
Comment has been collapsed.
I thought the same thing that it would be a draw. I mean would they really kill off tyrion? Then I realized they probably would.
On the other hand it could still be a draw and possibly a rematch? Maybe Jaime offering to fight for tyrion while the throne hires bronn? Maybe jorah comes into play here too. I haven't read the books and I'm just spit balling some of my guesses.
Comment has been collapsed.
I'm not going to read your posts since I don't want any spoilers but the last 10 minutes of the latest episode was fucking E-P-I-C. For those 10 minutes alone it was worth watching 4 seasons.
Comment has been collapsed.
I felt shame, sad and almost surprise.
Then i got dissapointed.
Then i saw a certain pic about player 1 and 2 that they are good friends in reality, and i remembered that i'ts just a serial, haha.
Now, i'm worried for one of my favourite characters. Let's see what happens to him. :(
Comment has been collapsed.
Actually i do. Was browsing trough a backstory and somehow i ended up reading what was going to happen (they didnt mentioned this fight though), i just couldnt stop reading.
I think that the next episode is what happens next with tyrion, and closing the season with stannis. i think its a nice ending.
Comment has been collapsed.
I had been spoiled with the result of this combat like 2 weeks before the episode, but frankly it didn't change a thing. No matter how much you know about the events that will happen, the showmakers always succeed to catch you off-guard. The fight was freakin' amazing though. I was wondering just before watching the episode why would they call Oberyn the Red Viper, but seeing him fight I instantly understood ^^
Comment has been collapsed.
Really?
When some one dont kill the enemy, and he is lying down, there is like 80% chance that they will retaliate with good chances of success due to the other one standing is distracted.
When oberyn removed the lance from the mountain and he said him that he could not die yet, i was afraid this would happen, i certainly hoped it didnt, but at the end, well, you saw it.
Also not a fan with the music less titles, they tried to revive the shock of the red wedding (that did surprised me), but it didnt worked, at least for me.
Comment has been collapsed.
My heart was pounding for at least 15mins after I finished watching the last episode.
Comment has been collapsed.
hahahaha. yeah, i thought he was only losing the eyes, never expected it that way.
But.... i dont really get disturbed with this kind of visual, im used to it by watching too much gore, that is probably why it was so lame for me. I knew the moment he removed the lance from the mountain that he was going to retaliate and kill oberyn, i just didnt knew how.
At the end, i was not shocked not by the visuals, not by his death.
Comment has been collapsed.
Im honestly contemplating stopping watching this show (I read only the first book)
After much thought Ive come to the conclusion that this show is VERY depressing and the good guys rarely win. Yes its refreshing to not see the good guys ALWAYS win .. But you need a good balance. And I think this show is very depressing.
Comment has been collapsed.
From what I can see, the bad guys always win. To the point you knew damn well what was going to happen at the end of that last episode.
If you would like to side message me (on steam) and point up to this point how the good guys are winning anything go ahead. (No spoilers past this ep please)
Comment has been collapsed.
As far as i can tell, the show genre is Drama. If you dont want to get depressed, watch a comedy show.
Its not getting any better after the first book. In fact, you are just getting started.
BTW. Who are the bad guys? Can you really tell from reading just 1 book?
Comment has been collapsed.
From what i saw, he either was stabbed in the chest or in the belly, and looking how deep the cut was, probably destroyed the spine if it was on the belly, or the lungs.
Few seconds later, he totally went hulk smash little men's head.
So yeah, at the end, he is badly wounded, but i bet he will get up like if it was nothing. However, knowing oberyin as the red viper, probably those blades were poisoned. Dont know this for sure, but that was my train of thought before the fight, oberyn will scratch the mountain, then the mountain will grab him and destroy him, then die poisoned.
Comment has been collapsed.
Do you want spoilers?
Because thats how you get spoilers.
In the books the blades were poisoned, not sure about the show, anyways you will see the rest.
Did they show Dorne in the tv show and did they show Doran Martell? I won't spoil anything more ,sorry if this bothered you i'll remove it if it did
Comment has been collapsed.
Even more reason for oberyn's death to be more lame if the blades were poisoned.
There was no reason at all for the mountain to have that much strenght after being stabbed AND poisoned.
And no, the only martell at the moment is/was Oberyn.
I assume Dorne will step up now (yeah, dont spoil XD), but they have not showed it, just have many references.
Comment has been collapsed.
About that scene...
Did he ever figured out why Orson smashed all those beetles? Any further explanation abb this in the books?
Or that was something about his (Tyrion) own nature of being obsessed by knowledge and all, and an analogy about the world (Orson) smashing weak things (beetles/Tyrion) nature...?
Comment has been collapsed.
I kind of expected it not to end that way with the mountain on his back, but I definitely didn't expect it to end the way it did.
Edit: What book does this event happen in? I'm just curious as to how far the series is through the story.
Comment has been collapsed.
This is really hard to say for me since im not that far into the books. But i guess starting book 4.
But short story. first half of the 3rd book is 3rd season.
Second half of 3rd book, + elements from the 4th and 5th book are in this 4th season.
My personal guess is that the third book was over 1-2 episodes ago, and we started the book "a feast of crows" while the daenarys part is from the 5th book "dance with dragons "
Comment has been collapsed.
100-200 pages after the middle of the third book. They're mixing story with 4th and even 5th and still didn't show what's going on the Wall (the same time). That's a bit weird I think.
EDIT: The whole Theon plot during the third season is from the Dance with Dragons (5th book)...
Comment has been collapsed.
82 Comments - Last post 3 hours ago by WaxWorm
56 Comments - Last post 6 hours ago by Carenard
1,811 Comments - Last post 6 hours ago by ngoclong19
72 Comments - Last post 8 hours ago by Reidor
545 Comments - Last post 10 hours ago by UltraMaster
41 Comments - Last post 10 hours ago by ViToos
1,520 Comments - Last post 11 hours ago by ayuinaba
17 Comments - Last post 10 minutes ago by someonequeer
92 Comments - Last post 28 minutes ago by Axelflox
72 Comments - Last post 30 minutes ago by eeev
9,531 Comments - Last post 1 hour ago by NoYeti
52 Comments - Last post 1 hour ago by xkingpin
28,266 Comments - Last post 1 hour ago by PastelLicuado
182 Comments - Last post 1 hour ago by Aerctaure
So. im reading the books, but im only halfway the second one.
I was hoping "player 1" to win, which basically happened, but after the "victory dance" they announced "player 2" to come back, i mean you could see it miles away, i have seen this shit way too many times, any horror movie, you name it, not restricted to the genre though, but yeah, too predictable. I think it was a very lame execution of a comeback.
What do you guys think?
Please, no spoilers of what happens next.
Comment has been collapsed.