What is your highest and lowest rated wishlist item?

Highest - 98% - Factorio

Lowest - 47% - No Man's Sky

Over 90% of the games on my list have mostly positive or better scores.

The topspot on my wishlist is shared by three games with a 98% rating (Factorio, Finding Paradise, OneShot), but the lowest spot is definitely Black Viper: Sophia's Fate with only 8%. There are very few HOGs I don't want to have and eventually play, and the negative reviews could not scare me away from adding this one.

Highest - 98% OneShot (thank goodness there was a 98, because there were several 97s and I didn't feel like listing them all)

Lowest - 68% Xenon Valkyrie

I have quite a few 98% rated games: Celeste, Opus Magnum, OneShot, West of Loathing, Nekopara Vol 3, Finding Paradise, The Legend of Heroes: Trails in the Sky SC.

Lowest rated is Monster Hunter World at an awful 49%.

West of Loathing is at 98% overwhelmingly positive.
Final Fantasy Type-0 is at 58% mixed

One of my two unrated games is at 100% with 47 reviews, but it's also the 6th release in a visual novel that's been split up into parts. Nobody who hated the first five is buying chapter 6 of Higurashi When They Cry. So I'm not counting that one.

Interesting
Game Dev Tycoon at 95% is my highest
Kingdom Rush Origins is the lowest at 0% ;) (It's Magic 2015 Duels of the Planeswalkers at 45%)
As for personal wants, Death Road to Canada is my most wanted (Not including Origins just cause it's not out even though I already know I want it more) and the lowest on the list is tabletop sim

OK, I will play! :D

Highest... Oh, surprisingly, it is not The Witcher 3.. The highest is...
Fault - Milestone Two Side: Above (99%)

Lowest...
Card Dungeon (50%).... Huh, is it that bad? ;)

Cheers!

Lowest: Monster Hunter: World - 50% (which i'm really surprised by since I've heard great things)
Highest: Fault - milestone two side:above - 99%

I hadn't noticed until now, but the number of reviews or some other algorithm seems to come into play in sorting by review score. Some games with a lower percentage of positive reviews are ranked higher on the list, and vice versa. Anyways, I'm just going to go by the Steam sorting.

Highest: Shovel Knight: Treasure Trove
Lowest: Wolfenstein II: The New Colossus

Skipping unrated games:

• Highest item: The Witcher 3 expansion pass is my highest rated item at 99%. By all accounts, it's excellent, but I'm slow at getting into TW3, and there's no sense picking up the DLC until I am further into the base game. Had I the chance to do it again, I'd have waited and got the GotY edition for the price I paid for the base game.

• Lowest item: Total War: ROME II - Blood & Gore DLC is my lowest rated item at 37%. The general opinion is that a strategy game called "Total War" is generally aimed at relatively mature gamers to begin with, but SEGA split the DLC out to obtain a Teen rating, which makes it more widely accessible without further modification in all countries. In other words, it should be a standard part of the game, but not only is it split out as DLC, they charge $3 to restore the game to what it should have been - $1 would have been sufficient, if they simply needed to make it a separate product for the better rating.

• Highest Rated (98%) The Binding of Isaac, Hotline Miami, Finding Paradise, VA-11 Hall-A Cyberpunk Bartender Action, Celeste, Angels with Scaly Wings.
• Lowest Rated (48%) Super Bomberman R

Highest: Celeste (98%)
Lowest: Final Fantasy XIII-2 (61%)

Hi: Finding Paradise
Lo: InnerSpace

I had a handful of games all sitting at 98%, but the first one ended up being Crystalline. Huh!

the lowest is.... Sacrament at 29%. Yeesh. Might need to do some wishlist pruning...

Highest: 98% => https://store.steampowered.com/app/341800/Keep_Talking_and_Nobody_Explodes/
Lowest: 33% => https://store.steampowered.com/app/293720/Dark_Raid/

Highest: Papers, Please - The Short Film - 99%
Yes, I know, it's free and it's not even a game, then what? I keep it in wishlist as reminder that I should watch it, and the thread says "item" after all.

Lowest: Super Bomberman R
They says online is broken, but if local multiplayer works, then yes.

top: walking dead 4
bottom: far cry 5

now i notice i have a lot of unreleased games in my wishlist. 🤔

CrossCode at the top with 97
and Civ 6 with 67 at bottom

Highest: Long Gone Days and 1bitHeart (96%)
Lowest: Jurassic World Evolution (70%)