What is your highest and lowest rated wishlist item?

Highest:
Finding Paradise (98%)

Lowest:
Call of Duty Infinite Warfare (39%)

My wishlist is in need of a clean up

Highest is Primordia. Game just jumped out at me when i saw it on a recommended list.
Lowest is Ashley: The Story Of Survival. Game just looks interesting by the art style.

Other than that, I have a few that have no reviews yet or that aren't out yet.

Highest: Foxtail - 99%
Lowest: We are Chicago - 31%

And yeah, I really wanna check out We are Chicago, despite its low score. It looks like something different. I think people misjudge it because they expect an experience this game is just not intended to deliver.

Highest is SteamWorld Dig 2 at 96%, which is actually a lower percentage than a few other games, like Gorogoa, which even has more reviews than SWD2? Uh Steam, how does this work?

Lowest game with an actual rating is Dungeon Girl at 33%, which seems a bit harsh, but I dunno.

Highest-rated overall is the Shipwrecked DLC for Don't Starve, at 96%.

Highest-rated game is Rodina, at 94%.

Lowest-rated is Tetris Ultimate, at 30%. (I just want to be able to play Tetris with my non-gamer girlfriend on our big screen TV via Steam Link, so I don't think I care too much about the low ratings).

Interesting topic.

Highest Rated Steamworld Dig 2 96%

Lowest Rated (that has enough reviews to actually be rated) [Graveyard Keeper] 67% Still, I've heard good things about the game, so it stays on my WL.

Highest rated : Kingdom Rush Frontiers
Steam puts it on top but I can see several games with over 96% positive reviews, so it probably takes the total number of reviews into account too.

Lowest rated : AereA
Probably I wishlisted it before the release, then it turned out terrible and I never bothered to remove it as always

Highest rated: The Walking Dead: The Final Season 97% positive
Lowest rated: Alone in Space 56%

Highest: [Finding Paradise]() - 98%

Lowest: No Man's Sky - 47%

The highest: Hidden Folks 98%
The lowest: I Am Alive 65%

It happens that there are other games with worse score but with fewer reviews and Steam puts them in a better position:
Red Goddess: Red Goddes Inner 42% (26 reviews)

Highest rated: OneShot, 98%
Lowest: No Man's Sky, 47%

With the Wilson score the highest rated list looks a lot better than with Steam's average. ;)

View attached image.

Highest rated: Euro Truck Simulator 2 with 97% positive reviews
Lowest: Syberia 3 with only 49% positive reviews :(

Highest: Assault Android Cactus
Lowest: JOLT: Super Robot Racer

On my HUGE wishlist, let's see.. great thread by the way :)

Most positive:

• Brigador: Up-Armored Edition. 95% positive over 944 reviews

Most negative:

• Pro Rugby Manager 2015. 19% positive over 120 reviews

For the negative part, it's been quite hard - the whole lower side of the wishlist actually hosts both games with no reviews and games with 2-5 reviews.. so I chose not to consider the "grey" ones and go for the angry "red" ones xD

Gotta say that ordering my wishlist this way I saw lots of "nella media" games (which means mixed in Italian basically, not bad but not good too xD) and few "negativo" (obvious translation xD) ones although my wishlist is reaching 5000 games and DLCs!

Highest rated: TY the Tasmanian Tiger with 93.38% positive
Lowest rated: Overgrowth with 68.99% positive

TY the Tasmanian Tiger is one of the very few series in that genre on Steam I have yet to add to my collection, they all have such good reviews but I've never come across any of them going on sale before. I'm staying patient though. I don't know much about Overgrowth, it doesn't necessarily have a negative rating though and what I've seen of it looks really interesting.

A bit of a tie with West of Loathing, Herald: An Interactive Period Drama - Book I & II, Zwei: The Ilvard Insurrection, and STEINS;GATE at 97%

At the bottom is Call of Duty®: WWII at 54%. I know it is popular to hate CoD but I'm a fanboy ever since Big Red One on PS2. I've bought the map packs and Ghost 3 times (PS3/PS4 and PC) which I know is bad but I don't care. Bought me so much joy back in the day and I look forward to them. Still on the fence on getting the next one since it is MP only and I don't have the time to commit and my backlog is a lot bigger than it once was :/.

Looks like Steam sort by verdict (Overwhelmingly Positive, Very Positive, etc.) without taking the actual percentage or number of reviews into account. I sorted the list several times and got different result each time.

Lowest rated for me are Tokyo Tattoo Girl and Dungeon Girl, which stands at around 30%+ at Mostly Negative rating, the next lowest is 70% Mixed rating.

This is pretty fun, I never thought about doing that! Let's see... Top of the List...

Cat Quest

RECENT REVIEWS: Very Positive - 96% of the 29 user reviews in the last 30 days are positive.
ALL REVIEWS: Overwhelmingly Positive - 96% of the 1,825 user reviews for this game are positive.
STEAMDB RATING: 91.41%

Clearly it's the cats. I have a few high-scoring cat-related ones XD

And the bottom of the barrel (when of course ignoring titles that are unreleased and/or have no reviews yet)

Overlord: Fellowship of Evil
ALL REVIEWS: Mostly Negative - 23% of the 381 user reviews for this game are positive.
STEAMDB RATING: 28.67%

It looks like a hot mess alright but I've enjoyed Overlord I and II many years ago, as well as the Wii one, so I always wanted to give it a try. XD

Apparently the highest rated game from my wishlist is some free short adventure The Raven Monologue, 95%. I don't remember adding it, but I should probably give it a try. The lowest one (excluding multiple with less than 10 reviews) is Black Mirror (the new one, of course), 41%.

In My WL there are several games with 98% rating.
But lowest is Sacred 3 22%

TOP 3 are witcher 3, trails of cold steel and wolf among us. Don't know how to check percentatges.
The last one is The Division and the season pass of Deus ex Manking Divided

Highest:

Airships: Conquer the Skies - 96%.

Lowest:

Australian Football Coach - 43%

I tend to wishlist games after reading previews in magazines, so I have a bunch of ‘Mixed’ games on there which apparently didn’t live up to expectations.