indie bundle games list I guess you added all of them in the list.
IGN Prime keys since they were exploited. How to solve: Only count 1 copy of them and make the rest not counted, everyone who shared multiple copies most likely exploited the site.
Polish Magazine keys.
Some keys given away for free like shadowgrounds games from summerseal.com
Ravaged beta keys which can be obtained for free from their fb and site and lots of users shared those as full game keys giving 25$ value each. Actually one of the users who wrote here shared 13 copies... and probably other beta keys I can't think of right now
Also please remove value from reported abuser's account just suspending a few days is like rewarding them.
Please give users chance to prove their games are legit and not from bundles with some proof of purchase.
Comment has been collapsed.
Thanks for mentioning it, I know it's another well-known problem. But it's not abused as much as bundle keys and not related bundle key thread. Anyway it can only be solved by monitoring suspicious giveaways, since it's an obvious abuse attempt i think it needs bigger punishment as well.
Comment has been collapsed.
"Sharing non exixted keys to friends to rise contributor value, that can't be checked by SG moderators."
Wat? Yes, it can. We perma-ban for it all the fucking time.
Comment has been collapsed.
You can talk about it without calling people out, you know.
Comment has been collapsed.
It's almost always obvious when it's a boosting attempt rather than a legit giveaway. Even if we do get it wrong (only seen that once so far), we can just ask for a screenshot of their library. If the account is private, the admin can also see their synced library, so we can use that as well.
Comment has been collapsed.
"Please give users chance to prove their games are legit and not from bundles with some proof of purchase."
This can't really be done because support are only volunteers and this would bring in an insane amount of new tickets and they are already flooded enough.
Comment has been collapsed.
Any sort of check that can be performed manually to insure that a user possesses a non-bundle copy (which would mean that it's in their Steam inventory) can also be done automatically.
This means that a user would need to briefly make their Steam profile and inventory public, but it would be a completely optional step. If the user wants to do this then they get full contributor credit. If not then they don't. This step doesn't even need to occur when the giveaway is created; it could happen at any time while the giveaway is still active.
A user could potentially buy something like a single gift-able copy of Rig'n'Roll off Steam, and use it to create a giveaway (as he can prove he has a non-bundle copy in his Steam inventory). After the giveaway ends, he then gives the winner a bundle key and still receives full contributor credit.
However, in the grand scheme of things, this isn't all that bad. Even though he tricked the system into allowing him to give away a bundle key for it's full contributor value, it was still backed by a store-bought copy. When he confirmed that he owned a copy in his inventory, the unique ID for that gift was also recorded. If he were to try to give away a second Rig'n'Roll bundle key using the same gift in his inventory, the system would recognize that this gift was used to confirm a giveaway already and refuse it. If he wants to giveaway the Steam-bought copy now, he won't receive full credit.
Comment has been collapsed.
I've decided to hang onto this information, the majority of my corrections weren't posted by anyone else and clearly never planned on being used.
Most indie bundle wikis and websites even have incorrect information, but best of luck fixing that list up!
Comment has been collapsed.
"We're trying to build a list of games that could possibly be abused on our site"
The list of games that are on the bundle list but cannot be abused:
Delve Deeper -- buying a bundle for 5$ just to give this game away is a joke
Time Gentlemen Please! and Ben There Dan That! Special Edition Double Pack -- same here, the game costs 1$ on steam sale
Killing Floor -- buying this one from bemine2 costs 6$, summer sale price 5$, was even for 3$ this Feb
Botanicula -- no single key
Machinarium -- no single key
Samorost2 -- no single key
Anomaly: Warzone Earth -- no single key
EDGE -- no single key
Osmos -- no single key
Avadon: The Black Fortress -no single key
Cogs -- no single key
Snuggle Truck -- no single key
Swords and Soldiers HD -- BTA key, price higher than on steam sale
Zen Bound 2 -- no single key
Trine - no single key
Aquaria -- no single key, getting HiB with this key is hard as hell
Lugaru HD - no single key, getting HiB with this key is hard as hell
Penumbra Overture - no single key, getting HiB with this key is hard as hell
Braid - no single key
Revenge of the Titans - no single key
And Yet It Moves- no single key
Atom Zombie Smasher - no single key
Crayon Physics Deluxe - no single key
VVVVVV - no single key
BITTRIP RUNNER - no single key
Cave Story+ - BTA key, price higher than on steam sale, getting HiB with this key is hard as hell
Jamestown - no single key
NightSky - no single key
Shank - no single key
Super Meat Boy - no single key
Amnesia: The Dark Descent - no single key
Bastion - BTA key, price higher than on steam sale
LIMBO - no single key
Lone Survivor - no single key
Psychonauts - no single key
Superbrothers: Sword & Sworcery EP - no single key
Darwinia - no single key
DEFCON - no single key
Dungeons of Dredmor - BTA game, steam store price was low as 1.24$ getting HiB with this key is hard as hell
Multiwinia - no single key
Uplink - no single key
Blocks That Matter - no single key
The Binding of Isaac - no single key
Gratuitous Space Battles - only multiplayer key as i've been told
Comment has been collapsed.
Don't forget the ship... it was never really free and wasn't exploitable either.
For those who don't remember. People who bought it got 2 gift copies and people who activated it those got their own gifts to give. I think it totaled up to 11 copies per purchase.
As for exploiting it, the extra copies were locked behind activations so there was no way for 1 person to get more than a couple.
Disclaimer: Why yes, it is my only contribution... I'm such a horrible person.
Comment has been collapsed.
i would also whitelist hard reset, but its my own preference as i dont see many giveaways with that game and many people have it on their withslist (im one of them :P )
and now i think it won't be givean away becouse of being on this bundle list
Comment has been collapsed.
Why do you say that? You can still easily submit these games and receive full value for them. They only begin to lower in value if you post an unusually high number. For example, if you're a regular contributor, you can post a copy of Shadowgrounds, The Ship, etc, and not be affected. However, if you post 50 copies of Shadowgrounds, your value will be lowered.
Comment has been collapsed.
Hey cg, I don't mean to bother you, but I had a question regarding which keys would be included?
Will anything that's been given away in key form be added? We've had Faerie Solitaire given away here, GPU manufacturers bundle game keys all the time, giving out keys from KickStarters seems popular, will all of these be excluded too?
I've gone through your list and pointed out every mistake or tidbit of information that should be noted and would gladly continue, just need clarification as to what you're looking for.
Comment has been collapsed.
Well calling out users isnt allowed so I cant link some guys with 5 to 30 copies of ign prime keys here.. And there was a way to exploit ign prime membership esp for russians, dunno if it's still working but they already had enough keys from there i think...
So is it wrong to assume %98 of users who have more than 1 ign prime membership got it by exploiting the site?
Comment has been collapsed.
The Binding of Isaac is the last game on the "bundles game list". But If I make one giveaway of The Binding of Isaac soundtrack, The Binding of Isaac with Soundtrack, or The Binding of Isaac Complete (available for sale during the summer sale) it will count to contributor or bundle value?
Comment has been collapsed.
Non-bundle I guess. Unless a bundle includes them.
Comment has been collapsed.
Do full bundles (like the indie gala giveaways) count as normal giveaways since they are already discounted, or do they fall into this 20% bundle key thing?
Comment has been collapsed.
Looks like they do count towards normal giveaways.
Comment has been collapsed.
I think Bastion specifically should be excluded. It was a BtA game (in fact, it was the only BtA game) and the average was almost nine bucks, which is more than it goes on sale for on Steam.
Also, you should remove the games from Humble Bundles that used the one-key-multiple-game policy, at least those games affected by said policy. I don't see why those should be discounted when the games didn't get individual keys.
Edit: zolwiciel already made a list of games that didn't come with individual keys. Obviously, trying to use HIB keys for giveaways of individual games should be and/or is against the rules, but...
Comment has been collapsed.
How about make the value of the railworks 3 all american bundle be that which the Russian buyers actually, paid, which was like, 3 USD instead of the 72 USD it is 'worth'? During the summer sale people were giving away hundreds of those, I highly doubt that was done with the legitimate desire to give a game to someone else...all that did was artificially inflate the contribution value of a small group of people. I foresee an unfortunate increase in minimum contribution required to enter quite a few giveaways from people who look at the average contribution value. The game was $7.19 USD in the US during the sale, and what, ~$2.50 - 3.50 in Russia?
Comment has been collapsed.
This is what I read:
I have an idea: devalue any game that I don't like that has gone on sale with the reasoning that if I don't like it, nobody does, despite the fact that people entered giveaways for it, which must mean that people were only giving away games to get contributor status!
If you don't see the lack of logic in there, I'm afraid you're beyond my help.
Comment has been collapsed.
If you don't see that Railworks flood was started only because it could cheaply "skyrocket" your contribution status, then I'm afraid you are beyond my help.
Also you should notice that author of idea is talking about lowering contribution points and not adding it to bundle list, which would be nothing else than justice.
Comment has been collapsed.
Ok, but the point is, that there have been dozens, or hundreds of games that have dropped to 90% (or more) off. Do we lower the contribution points for all of these? Or just the ones you don't like? Yes, obviously a lot of people only bought the railworks game to boost their contribution status. But ... so what? They're buying games to give to other people, and last I checked, that was the point of this site.
Comment has been collapsed.
Then Saints Row 3 Franchise Pack should be only worth 12$
Comment has been collapsed.
There's only one key on the new IndieGala7 for these 2 games, so people are making giveaways of Death to Spies: Gold correctly, but it needs to be added to http://www.steamgifts.com/bundles/list and http://www.steamgifts.com/create, and treated as a bundle game too.
Comment has been collapsed.
Saints Row: The Third - Special Ops Vehicle Pack
Free Key Giveaway - see here: http://www.steamgifts.com/forum/hOI3t/saints-row-3rd-spec-ops-dlc-free-over
Comment has been collapsed.
[Added, thank you] As already suggested by InsomniaNY: Saints Row: The Third - Special Ops Vehicle Pack, due to a giveaway by Amazon. Of course, some people abused it and got more than one key.
Comment has been collapsed.
FYI - I was creating a giveaway for some of my extra IG happy hour keys and noticed that Theatre of War: Africa 1943 doesn't have an asterisk beside it.
Also Death to Spies in IG is 2 keys in one, so Death to Spies Gold (which is what the key essentially is) should probably have an asterisk on it too?
Should probably fix it.
Comment has been collapsed.
http://code.reddit.com/wiki/help/faqs/playitforward
If you scroll down, they have a list of alot/most of the bundles with dates and games.
Comment has been collapsed.
Indie Royale - The Gone Fishin' Bundle:
SOL: Exodus
All Zombies Must Die!
Cubemen
Comment has been collapsed.
[Added, thank you] Death to Spies: Gold is missing from "Indie Gala 7".
cg, please give us some moderators as soon as possible.
Comment has been collapsed.
Groupees Be Mine Bundle 4 groupees.com/bm4
Green Light Bundle http://www.thegreenlightbundle.com/
Comment has been collapsed.
You're right, they're not. But according to the FAQ keys for these games will be added to each purchase should these games succeed in Steam Green Light. So it's just something to keep in mind for now.
And BM4 has 4 steam games in it, which, as we all know, now constitute 90% of newly-created giveaways.
Comment has been collapsed.
Some of the games should get off that list sometime, as the bundles are not for sale anymore (e.g. Toki Tori in Humble Android bundle) IMHO
Comment has been collapsed.
1,796 Comments - Last post 55 minutes ago by BlazeHaze
22 Comments - Last post 1 hour ago by Chris76de
493 Comments - Last post 2 hours ago by sallachim
205 Comments - Last post 2 hours ago by carlica
381 Comments - Last post 2 hours ago by OsManiaC
54 Comments - Last post 3 hours ago by sensualshakti
1,015 Comments - Last post 3 hours ago by sensualshakti
29 Comments - Last post 5 minutes ago by FateOfOne
50 Comments - Last post 29 minutes ago by cheeki7
43 Comments - Last post 29 minutes ago by 9389998
20 Comments - Last post 32 minutes ago by UnknownDepth
1,867 Comments - Last post 1 hour ago by MeguminShiro
797 Comments - Last post 1 hour ago by MayoSlice
8 Comments - Last post 1 hour ago by cheeki7
Thanks to a little team work in the chat, we categorized all the popular bundles, their start date, and corresponding games. If you have a second, and feel like helping out, review the list and let us know if we're missing anything. Keep in mind, it's only including Steam games. We're trying to build a list of games that could possibly be abused on our site, and at the same time, a method to better determine contributor values. Thanks!
http://www.steamgifts.com/bundles/list
Comment has been collapsed.