I have experienced both sides of the issue first-hand, and have had to deal with the fallout on both sides. You have been with us long enough to have heard not only why the current rules are the way they are but also the weaknesses of the argument you present. For those who are new, however, I will reiterate what has so often been said. The issue of "questionable giveaways" has multiple facets to consider, and the current rules are the best compromise we have found thus far. If you feel you have a better solution, you are able to create a Suggestions thread and debate the matter.