Mark of the Ninja or Dead Island GOTY?

i'd say Dead Island :)

Dead Island

mark of the ninja for sure.

Dead Island is an overrated p.o.s. Get Mark of the Ninja instead.

I've played both, but Dead Island I've only played on console. I enjoyed Dead Island more than Mark of the Ninja, simply because it's a longer game and it's very fun to play with friends, imo. Also- zombies.

Mark of the Ninja

Dead Island is only decent, but it's long and entertaining and has co-op, so I would recommend that.

I found Dead Island to be very meh.. Mark of the Ninja on the other hand was amazing

Played both, Mark of the Ninja any day of the week.

Mark of the Ninja all the way. Dead Island is at best a mediocre game.

Unless you're looking for a co-op game with some friends, then ninja all the way. Ninja is a really awesome and tight single player experience.

The only good thing about Dead Island is...zombies. Zombies that scale to your level, so upgrading your weapons and level is completely pointless. The missions are more or less the same as well, you run around and kill zombies, then you kill more of them. The game is incredibly boring imo. Keep playing L4D2 instead, same gore, same zombies, but much better gameplay (if played multiplayer).

Mark of the Ninja is great, I can only recommend it.

singleplayer: mark of the ninja
coop: dead island

Mark The Ninja, it's awesome

dead island

mark of the ninja

I can't really fault Mark of the Ninja for what it's meant to be. It's really, really fun. I haven't played Dead Island but I think I'll get it in the sale, had my eye on it for awhile..

Mark of the Ninja, worth every penny!

Dead Island...

A stealth platformer or zombie survival RPG.

It's really your preference but if you're looking to play co-op, get Dead Island.

I bought Mark of the Ninja, thanks to everyone.