Thanks for your reply. No one is obliged to contribute and I am very happy, if I can generate something, you are interested to read. Have fun and stay healthy!
Comment has been collapsed.
i really like this, also one of the first true user project, here around...
imo, your curation should reflect your Group theme, and should be in English. i know that's lotta work, but it would certainly be a very unique curation...
meanwhile... my congrats!
edit: voted for Apotheon
Comment has been collapsed.
Thank you for your kind remarks and opinion. I thought about making the Curator lines in English and the proper reviews in German, but that's a bit disparate, too. About the theme of the curator, sometimes I want to review (and play) games, that have nothing to say about from my group's perspective, but are cool and underrated, so I want to leave a review. Stay safe and thanks again.
Comment has been collapsed.
Life can be hard sometimes ;-). But thanks for your effort!
Comment has been collapsed.
Thanks for your interest. But beware, I'm only an expert on some specific subject in archaeology, everything else is just apllying methods and thinking ;-). Hope to get you interested and maybe sometimes in the future the tropes of archaeology do get fewer in games...but does that minder the quality, hmm....
Comment has been collapsed.
I would be interested in a archeological analysis of games as well, although my German is not the greatest. I am curious what's your take on games like Horizon Zero Dawn or Far Cry Primal or even something like Ancestors or Heaven's Vault. I did read a few of your reviews, but they didn't feel that historical specific to me.
Comment has been collapsed.
Thank you for your interest and comment in Steam, too! Glad, you liked the text. Heaven's Vault is very very good at showing, how to uncover unknown languages and cultures, whereas Ancestors tries to be historically correct for the weaponry and clothes. Horizon Zero Dawn and especially Far Cry Primal are a bit of a best of archaeology clichés put together ;-).
Regarding my reviews you are absolutely right, most of them have no relation to archaeology or historical thinking - I like to play unkown games and write a nice review. But my takes on specific games in the group discussion will remain in English, so that you can enjoy them without to much of this difficult language ;-). Thanks again and have a safe week!
Comment has been collapsed.
For Far Cry Primal I assumed it was mostly baseless historical fiction with cherry picked examples to create compelling gameplay. As for Horizon Zero Dawn I am not so sure. I didn't feel like a real society, more like a fantasy one, maybe it's just me. Keep up the great work.:)
Comment has been collapsed.
To be honest, I have not played Horizon Zero Dawn, just read some reviews about it; so nothing profound about its society from my side. Thanks again for your commentary.
Comment has been collapsed.
Thanks for your interest; maybe archaeology in games is just boring? Who know ... ;-)
Comment has been collapsed.
Interesting concept - hopefully it doesn't turn out like the movies, where everyone thinks you went into archaeology because of Indiana Bloody Jones - grrrrrrrr - no we did not and he's a glorified grave robber - and don't get me started on Tomb Raider - the name says it all in the end :P
yes I started out my life as one of the dirt diggers - :) props for trying something :)
Comment has been collapsed.
Ha, there is a fellow sufferer! Love those talks with others, when they say: "Oh, as a kid I wanted to be an archaeologist, too"...And me: Nodding and smiling. By the way, I try to not discuss the AAA titles, where we all know, that Lara and others destroy everything of value, äh, do others know that? Hopefully. Thanks for your comment and stay safe these times!
Comment has been collapsed.
Like the Indiana Jones movies, I'm sure it won't bear much resemblance to real life, but eventually I think you'll have to address the Tomb Raider games! :)
Maybe Assassin's Creed as well?
Edit: Had a read over the majority of the Dear Esther piece. Great stuff! Haven't actually played the game, but the detail in your findings and extrapolations certainly makes me more interested in exploring the island myself. Thank you for the deep interpretations; whether coincidental or entirely intentional on the part of the developers, you make interesting cases for the latter!
Comment has been collapsed.
Thanks for your comment, interest and read. I try to avoid games like Tomb Raider and Assassins Creed, 'cause there are whole sites with those games and their historical relationship. Although Tomb Raider is all about looting and destroying, I have to admit that the last two Assassins creeds do take care of history and ethic presentation of the past. Stay safe!
Comment has been collapsed.
As a long time museum professional, I gotta say absolutely love the idea for a group and serious props to you for trying something different. :) Read the entire Dear Esther article, very nice.
Comment has been collapsed.
Thank you so much for your interest and time! Nice to see some historical interested people here.
Comment has been collapsed.
As I am language challenged, how do I translate from German to English? Help?
Comment has been collapsed.
Update New essay about The Talos Principle appeared with two giveaways, one for The Talos Principle, one for Dear Esther. Furthermore for better readability I started a new blog with both essays, and for better up-to-dateness a twitter account (with no tweets until now). Take your time, read, have fun and follow what you want. Links for giveaways and everything else is updated in the description above.
Comment has been collapsed.
Oh, what I totally forgot: We are at 97 members now...reaching 100 will result in a celebration giveaway!
Comment has been collapsed.
Damn, this seems the risk of not-so-ambitious aims ;-).
I have the feeling that games like Treasure Hunter will let me freak out...but maybe when I'm in the mood.
Thank you for your comment, Zarddin!
Comment has been collapsed.
I thought it was a group of people playing really old games
Comment has been collapsed.
As promised a small celebrational giveaway for reaching 100 members, thank you all:
Comment has been collapsed.
Time flies and I forgot to post here some updates:
There are two new contributions, but without giveaways this time. Why? These games can't be bought outside of Steam and I don't want to exclude people living in other regions from my giveaways. If there is a solution to this problem, tell me. The giveaways will go live, when a keystore starts to sell them. Until then...have a good read:
The Hand of Glory - Distorted outlooks
Mutropolis — Egyptian Mixed Arts
Comment has been collapsed.
Update: After a hiatus of two years, I found some time to continue this project. This time with the game "The Excavation of Hob's barrow" by Cloak and Dagger games.
Have a read on my blog or in my Steam group.
And then, a new giveaway appears (as part of the fantastic Community train)!
Comment has been collapsed.
Found this one through the new giveaway and this is such an interesting concept!! I'm sad that I will probably be too busy for a while to sit down and properly read your essays but I do wan't to eventually get through them, congratulations on the idea and thank you for sharing!
Comment has been collapsed.
19 Comments - Last post 2 minutes ago by LuckyLastLaugh
421 Comments - Last post 29 minutes ago by Mihaela
153 Comments - Last post 1 hour ago by S4NSKAR
2 Comments - Last post 1 hour ago by lostsoul67
169 Comments - Last post 2 hours ago by fackia777
47,166 Comments - Last post 7 hours ago by Axelflox
56 Comments - Last post 7 hours ago by Axelflox
4 Comments - Last post 1 minute ago by Masafor
2,578 Comments - Last post 2 minutes ago by Psyman
212 Comments - Last post 15 minutes ago by tetsuya074
83 Comments - Last post 21 minutes ago by dalma
32 Comments - Last post 39 minutes ago by SmokyMonki
31 Comments - Last post 44 minutes ago by Mhol1071
49 Comments - Last post 47 minutes ago by cyriak
Hey all,
I would like to introduce you to a project of mine that will grow with the participation and discussion of a larger community. It is a Steam group called "The Archaeologist plays", where I, as a trained archaeologist, will explore archaeology and archaeologists in games, but also look at games from the perspective of an archaeologist or historian in a non-academic way, but accurately and thoroughly: The Archaeologist plays.
My first essay revolved around certain aspects of Dear Esther, the game that founded the genre of First Person Exploration games or as we all know them better "Walking Simulators": A comparison of the model island, a small island in the Outer Hebrides, Boreray, with the fictional one of the game, and an attempt to analyse some objects with a double meaning.
Case #1: Dear Esther – An Island and a Coin
My second essay tackles The Talos Principle, especially World hub A, the Roman hub. Here I looked for Croteam's inspiration in the ancient cities of Ostia, Rome and Pompeii; furthermore, I wondered why Croteam erased genitals from an Etruscan wall painting and placed statues and objects in completely unlogical contexts.
Case #2: The Talos Principle – An excursion to the past with ruinous contexts
My third essay deals with two topics of the Point and Click Game The Hand of Glory, a highly distorted view of the colosseum in Rome and a nebulous statement about the origin of winds.
Case #3: The Hand of Glory - Distorted outlooks
My fourth essay assumes that the developers of Mutropolis, another classical Point and Click-adventure, had a serious academic background in Egyptian archaeology before creating the game, and that they chose to present a wild mix of cultural references and remains to entertain, but not to distract from the plot.
Case #4: Mutropolis — Egyptian Mixed Arts
The latest blog looks at historical patterns of the game The Excavation of Hob's Barrow, especially why there is a female excavator when the historically attested one was a man: Case #5: The Excavation of Hob’s Barrow — The V.R. of Alternate History.
I would be more than glad, if some of you would read the text out of interest, and even more happy if some would join the group for future discussion. For better readability and images I have started my own blog at wordpress and transferred (and improved) the essays: The Archaeologist plays.... And for some quick research results for the future, there is also a Twitter account: The Archaeologist plays...
If you are afraid of being overloaded with such long information, you are wrong: I am doing this for fun and I do not plan to pull out content like this every week, maybe every 3 or 4 months. And there will be space for casual discussions about archaeology and games.
Furthermore, for every case I present in the community forum, the game in question will be given away here on Steamgifts (see below for the link to the giveaway).
Finally, for all German-speaking users or those who want to test out their German skills: I also have a Curator page attached to the group (of course ;-)), where I mainly review adventures, especially Point and click-Adventures, Platformers and small Indie-games with potential. You are all welcome to follow me! Why I write in German: It's just that I have the feeling that I can describe games more precisely and faster than in English - and often these games have no or only a few reviews in German: Curator-Page.
Well, that's it for now, thanks you all for reading and maybe there is some interest for my group here on Steamgifts.
Archive-Giveaways: Dear Esther LE [closed].
The Talos Principle [closed]
Dear Esther LE [closed]
Active Giveaway: The Excavation of Hob's Barrow
Comment has been collapsed.