This is EXACTLY why we don't call out fake on giveaways.

A lot of these giveaways that are called out for being 'fake' are from new users who don't speak English and don't know how the site works. SteamGifts is only presented in English, but only around 1/3 of the users are from an English speaking country. Google Translate doesn't always do the best job at translating our pages. It's very easy to come to the wrong conclusion about how the site works.

I have already seen a not received giveaway with as a description: "key"...

because some people are suspicious and apparently more willing to believe the noob is both an idiot and trying to rip them off somehow(make them waste 60 free points I guess?(points that those same people complain of having too many and always being stuck at 300 anyway))
than to risk those 60(on what is at best an almost sure loss anyway even when real) and believe he is actually giving away stuff(cause its not like there aren't people here who've given thousands, and even if there are they don't start out as noob gifters they pop fully formed with $31 already sent and confirmed). so they rifle through his steam account and post multiple questions about its legitimacy. Breaking the rules as well as making the site look bad and alienating potential gifters in order to "do a public service and warn others"

But somehow copying and pasting the steam store description, or typing "thanks for entering" "key" "my first gift" advertising your youtube channel or mashing on the keyboard to meet a character min("asdfasfpkjashdfpkadsf") will alleviate this?

Yeah, there´s nothing wrong with simply asking the creator whether he understamds he created a lottery to give it away. There´s no acusation in that part. Plus, the user will actually fel ´seen´ by the fact that users noted he´s new on the site. Completely the opposite of those 4 or 5 characters )depending on whether it includes "!" or not).

You'll never get it.

try looking at the possible results of calling something fake:

if you're right: basically nothing happens.
you didn't enter anyway right? so none of your points are even at risk, the creator almost never checks back and reads your comments, most of the entrants don't either, (and for those who do: if it was so obvious they could come to their own conclusion easily enough without aid) ect.

if you're wrong: maybe basically nothing still happens, maybe you chase away a new gifter that was giving quality enough games for you to worry. nobody calls out "bundle trash"(a term I dispute anyway(somebody obviously wants them) but thats irrelevant here) for being fake afterall

Mostly basically nothing happens, so mostly its a waste of time and thats best case.
so given that why would you even bother to call something fake? if you win and guess right nothing happens if you lose you lose. why play that game? just quietly report and move on instead of barking in the comments

Oh, my God! A few people might lose the valueless points they got for free by entering a giveaway they wouldn't have won anyway unless you warn them by being an asshole to a new user! What a tragedy! Oh, wait. No. They won't even see it because they either don't even look at descriptions or anything else, let alone comments, or they're taking their chances anyway, so there's literally no reason whatsoever for ever harassing submitters at all. Especially since they don't even affect you at all. Well, except for getting more of those free points you use to enter giveaways. Hmm, I guess maybe you should shut up and thank them instead.

in most communities online, the ideal is that you're always innocent until guilty, but crowd mobbing results in being called guilty unless you prove innocence. it's one of those things i need to look more into since it's prevalent everywhere.

Except in certain military prisons outside the country.... Right?

This is EXACTLY why there needs to be a description rule/requirement, at least for new users. Why would someone want to create a giveaway without description? I know it happens a lot but I never understood why..

At SG, we have a separate set of site rules.

Just nitpicking, but they lose a probable chance of winning a game instead of a possible chance. In the end it doesn't really matter, since the result is the same (no game), but e.g. a giveaway entered and not won is another level of loss than a 'fake' giveaway not entered, when it wasn't as 'fake' as it seemed.
Caveat: From an emotional point of view, even if the hard facts seem to indicate otherwise.

here

The game isn't what matters, it's the gifter's reaction and how the community made him feel. That should NEVER happen.

It's also possible to buy steam keys from other websites so it would never appear in their inventory anyway. Some people are the dumbs.

This solves people leaving the site because people call their giveaways fake how?

I have a better suggestion: Let's change steamgifts so that it works the way some confused newbies think. That is, let's make it so when you create a giveaway, instead of having to give the games to the winners, they give the game to you.

This solves all of our problems. CV works as before, in that when a giveaway you created is finished, you get CV. But now that the creator of a giveaway receives the gift, high CV is a mark of greed rather than generosity, so people won't fight over it. And contributor giveaways will only allow you to "enter" for the change to give away a game, so they won't cause a problem either.

In fact, an even better model: Let's make it so both the giveaway creator and the winner get games. Everyone wins! Also, cg should get a copy of each game, too, to thank him for creating the site. In fact, let's just have everyone who signs up for steamgifts instantly and automatically win a copy of every game on Steam!

Read this.

Yeah, had that idea as well, make a new steam account, put enough bundle junk value to join steamgifts, then make the call of duty/whatever giveaway. But once people figured out what you'd done, you'd probably get banned for having multiple accounts. So better just to keep it a fantasy. :)

this!