What do you recommend?

you'll never guess my answer...

Grab both of them!

Infinite is overrated, generic trash.
TRAAAAAAAAAAAAASH

Shadow of Mordor is a lore destroyer but at least it's more fun.

Haven't played Shadow of Mordor but Bioshock games are fun enough :)

Tried both but neither were for me. I voted for Bioshock though cause even though the gameplay did not appeal to me(not a fan of FPS in general), from the little I played it seems to have some incredible lore in it, the worldbuilding of it is fantastic. Shadow of Mordor imo has nothing new to offer besides the Nemesis system.

Bioshock Infinite is a fun enough to play very good written shooter, shadow of mordor is an interesting game, the nemesis system is clever my only problem is that like dark souls you have to die to see it work, but uses the batman arkham combat system, witch is a relatively easy system to master, and in my case worked against the game, because i just didnt die, went trough 50% of the game without seeing what everybody was making a fuzz about.

so +1 for Bioshock :P

Since I have played neither game, I figure my opinion is totally useless. So here it goes!

Bioshock Infinite looks really pretty. I loved the 1st game and thought the 2nd was decent but not as good. This game looks pretty. Tags on Steam include FPS and Action.

Shadows also looks pretty. Overall, other Middle Earth games have been hit and miss, but this one has been highly rated. Tags on Steam include RPG and Open World.

I flipped a coin, played a game of Rosh ambo, and consulted the spirits. Then I remembered my two favorite types of games are RPG and Open World. So I would go with Shadows.

39 | 39
This is going nowhere.

Story/setting: Bioshock Infinite
Gameplay: Shadow of Mordor

Same as jbondguy. I loved to play Infinite, but after all, it's a dull game compared tho the previous 2. There's A LOT of lame missions like go over there and then return, and not much sense of accomplishing something. But it's a beautiful game, impressive scenario. The story is very good (the ending is great!), but it's not like you can do much other than just follow the missions.
Shadow of Mordor is the exact opposite: Basically no story, just killikg. BUT you can spend hours killing orcs. The stealth missions are really fun.

I'd recommend both, but in your case I'd go for Mordor.

I should not have voted, because I have not played Mordor, but I voted for Bioshock Infinite. I loved the game (better than the previous two), and the relation between the main characters... And it has some great great great lines.

both are great, get bioshock infinite first

Bioshock triple pack is still missing the must-have DLC's for Infinite. :/

I say Mordor, as I dislike buying incomplete packages, but you probably get more gaming time out of the Bioshock pack. Bioshock is also a game you should have played at some point in your gamer life :D

Ive never played Mordor but I seriously recommend Infinite and all its games. If this pack comes with all the DLC for Infinite then that's even better because the DLC is AMAZING