;_;
So I blacklisted this guy who didn't thank me after receiving the gift from my giveaway
anyway u can report him for fake feedback bcs its trade feedback no random feedback
Comment has been collapsed.
Is "thank you" rlly that important?
It would be nice if he say thx for game but if no, no problem
Comment has been collapsed.
Yes, it is important. I give games rarely since I don't have much money. And when someone just takes them without a word (in that case, without even a bump on the thread before), I blacklist them. Blacklist is not a big deal in the end, right? Just like thanks :)))))
Comment has been collapsed.
Yes its nice if someone say thank u for smth that he got for free, its sure thing. But maybe big problems (like now) with -rep etc for it) Yes bl isnt any deal, its not important.
Comment has been collapsed.
Totally important!!! I support that ideology (better known as common sense)
Comment has been collapsed.
yeah thank you it's important when you give free things. it's the less the other person can do. anyone that don't say thx when receive help/free things don't deserve nothing in that life.
Comment has been collapsed.
I saying thx if i win smth, idk if its important but its minimal that u can do for it. Its okay. But by point of view its not case to blacklisting. (blacklisting isnt important here, here is so much blacklisting without reason so its completly okay.)
Comment has been collapsed.
Yes it is.
I don't care if someone wins from me but doesn't thank to me. But it's important that the person who wins something must appreciate the gift. And the only way to show that is thanking the giveaway creator unless I'm not a God.
Comment has been collapsed.
Yeah I agree. Without saying anything it seems like they take the game as if it was a gleam raffle or something, just to farm it and leave.
Comment has been collapsed.
+1 not saying thanks is the #1 reason for getting on my blacklist!
If you're on the street and you see a beggar/musician/human statue and you give him money and he just ignores you, how would you react/feel? Just because it's on the internet doesn't mean the simpelest of all courtesy rules don't apply all of a sudden!
I was taught by my parents to say thank you when somebody gave something to me, be it a gift or a slice of meat at the butchers. So guess what I'm thinking about all these people who don't say thanks...
Comment has been collapsed.
One particularly sad thing is that I have been complimented in my grandmother's church because I say thank you when appropriate. I shouldn't be complimented on something so simple. If I am, that means that many people aren't doing it (which they have confirmed), and that's really depressing.
Comment has been collapsed.
Yes it's important. It's the least they can do when they get a game for free. You already don't have to do anything for the game (except maybe if it was hidden in a puzzle or something), so taking ten seconds of your time to thank the person that gave it to you is not that hard to do.
Comment has been collapsed.
That's actually a huge problem. Think of the people that are actively trading. There are people that -rep traders for no reason at all and there's no way to remove the negative feedback. :/
Comment has been collapsed.
At leats he left the "blacklist" comment for me lol
Comment has been collapsed.
Thing is that people will see a -rep comment. What if you were an active trader and people would stop trusting you because of that? Every trader's living in fear because of this shit.
Comment has been collapsed.
i honestly dont care tbh, i have 1 fake rep on my profile and the reason i put was obvious xD
Comment has been collapsed.
You have 2 -rep though, so you mean that one of them isn't fake? :P
Comment has been collapsed.
top 1 isnt, thou i dont deny that the "user" who placed it got temp banned twice and support has yet to read my ticket's xD
which includes abuse of trade feedback and use of on alt ( the 2nd -rep )
Comment has been collapsed.
It makes me a bit edgy, though nothing I'd lose sleep over.
Here's an idea I've daydreamed about: a weighted number for your trade feedback that takes into account who feedback comes from. Right now every positive feedback is +1 and every negative is -1. My idea is to give each user a number that would determine how much their feedback counts. Do you have no trade experience, low feedback numbers, or a very new account? Then your feedback counts fairly little. Do you have lots of good feedback? Then your ratings count a lot.
What do you think? Would that be an improvement?
Comment has been collapsed.
That would be a bit unfair.
A new trader gets scammed, his feedback doesn't matter.
An experienced trader gets offended, his feedback matters so he starts -rep people that offeded him.
Comment has been collapsed.
You might be right. I wonder if there isn't something workable in the vicinity of this idea though...
My thought was mostly this: unfair feedback is often reciprocated. People are therefore least likely to give it if they have more too loose (a good established reputation, say), and people who do give it are likely to have a blotchy trade record themselves. Have you often seen experienced traders with great records be petty like that? I feel like it doesn't happen very often.
Comment has been collapsed.
If a user gets suspended permanently, will the -rep get automatically removed?
Comment has been collapsed.
Cant you get it taken down as it isnt valid tradefeedback
Comment has been collapsed.
Well I didn't know it was possible since I never trade
Comment has been collapsed.
I mean what is to stop you from going onto his and leaving negative feedback too now, and it looks like he does trade sometimes
Comment has been collapsed.
I don't wanna go down to his level of stupidity, I guess. :|
Comment has been collapsed.
Terrible idea. Misuse of Trade Feedback = 5 days Suspension
Comment has been collapsed.
Because he can also get punished for it. Rules are rules and just because someone broke rules and hinders you, doesn't mean you can just go and break the same rule...
Comment has been collapsed.
Yeah, you can report it as I did, but it takes about a year before they get to it as the support ticket line is way too long.
Comment has been collapsed.
I'm gonna do it anyway, thanks for the info, didn't know it was possible :)
Comment has been collapsed.
Currently there is a scammer roaming the trade section and adding people. Anyone who accepts his invite gets a negative rep. My steam profile has also been marked by him offering me a game. I await my destiny.
Comment has been collapsed.
Those group/region/whitelist giveaways also just look shady as hell.
Comment has been collapsed.
Yeah that was another reason for BL...I usually let that "no thanks" thing go if a person at least gives to the community. But in this case everything seems shady :D
Comment has been collapsed.
meh, he well get blacklist wave so im pretty sure he would take his precious time finding all of us blacklisters xD
Comment has been collapsed.
Oh my, what an amazing person. Steamgifts never seems to experience a shortage of such "entertaining" people. :D
Comment has been collapsed.
I got a guy commenting on my profile, giving me minus rep and stuff a few weeks back because he didn't like the fact that I'd excluded him from my event even though he was actively horrible and had ruined multiple previous events. So yeah, I feel your pain.
Comment has been collapsed.
The Guidelines are pretty clear:
Trade feedback should only be used to describe your personal trading experience with a user. It should not be used (i) to post negative comments when you disagree with someone's offer, (ii) for revenge or retaliation when someone leaves you negative feedback, or (iii) for unrelated comments or trading experiences not directly involving you.
Report him and try to get the feedback removed. If he keeps doing it, in theory he'll be permabanned eventually.
Comment has been collapsed.
Blacllisting someone for not getting a thanks for a shared game is totally okay. It's your own blacklist and you can individually decide who and why to blacklist!
I would report him due to Misleading Trade Feedback. Sadly this will just lead to a 5 days ban.
Comment has been collapsed.
Oh c'mon, this must be a prank or some social experiment, it can't be real :|
Comment has been collapsed.
thanks, now he has 1 more blacklists...unfurl. the girl of the pic is you? that eyes ♥.♥
pd: random people is random :p.
Comment has been collapsed.
Yes, that's me. A bit enhanced with those godly Instagram filters but yeah :D thanks :D
Comment has been collapsed.
wah :C... well my gf has blue eyes/green depend of the day xD :p. but light blue,no that blue like yours :p.
give me your eyessss
Comment has been collapsed.
Here where I live blue eyes are so common that some girls don't even think it's pretty and put on colored contact lenses to make them brown or green :D
Comment has been collapsed.
XDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD take my wl :p.
Comment has been collapsed.
People are strange indeed. :D Thanks. <3'ed you too :)
Comment has been collapsed.
I love the wierd reasons users blacklist on this site. This one must be top 5.
I got blacklisted not long ago because a user asked for help. I looked up the answer and posted search results that included about 16 threads about the subject. Noticed I got blacklisted and the reason was because I didnt directly answered him mysef.
Comment has been collapsed.
well... since u dont trade then it's fine ... right?
Comment has been collapsed.
I don't really care, I just detest stupidity and that move was plain stupid :| And as some people pointed out, he does the same on people's who actively trade profiles...so it's not that fine, eh?
Comment has been collapsed.
She might always decide to trade later on. And with (0,-1) it will be an issue. More so, if she blacklists somebody who also leaves fake rep for it (this guy isn't the only one).
Comment has been collapsed.
Well now that jerk and rule breaker (misuse of trade feedback) got blacklist from me too, and I'm sure will get blacklists from some other people who read your thread. And if you report him he will get banned as well.
Support > Create a new Ticket
Category: User Report
Reason: Misuse of trade feedback
While most support tickets take long to resolve, or never get resolved I think the ones for misuse of giveaway and trade feedback usually get resolved relatively quickly, within a day or two.
Comment has been collapsed.
misuse of trade feedback usually get resolved relatively quickly, within a day or two.
Nah. Those take years XD
Comment has been collapsed.
i still have mine pending from like 5 months ago lol
Comment has been collapsed.
Ouch. One would think that obvious misuse of trade feedback such as in OP's case would get resolved quickly. They should get more support staff, we have plenty of trustworthy people who wouldn't mind doing it.
Comment has been collapsed.
ill just wait... if my ticket is still pending after 1-3 years might is well open a thread complaining about staff shortage xD
we technically have over 50+++ that are trust worthy and capable of handling something simple is support tickets.
then we have like around 6 active ( just active ) staff that maintain a website used by around 600k users a month...
Comment has been collapsed.
It seems like it already got fixed. Anyway, after reading this thread, I put you on my Whitelist. Enjoy your stay!
Comment has been collapsed.
Thanks <3 glad it worked THIS fast...support probably got a flood of reports :D
Comment has been collapsed.
I commented in an old GA of the user, mentioning they did break the rules.
I don't think support done anything, as the user is not suspended.
Often commenting is quicker than reports ;)
Comment has been collapsed.
Oh. Thank you then. I prefer him suspended though :D rule breakers tend to repeat their habits :)
Comment has been collapsed.
I can agree on that, but with support being over-worked that might take quite long.
The user still has left some negative feedback on at least one other user's profile here, as mentioned somewhere above.
Comment has been collapsed.
So he's probably just avoiding the fire and not actually fixing stuff :/ well, dramatically saying, his day will come :D
Comment has been collapsed.
I agree - the negative feedback sucks.
However, I think it is really not very easy to please blacklisters.
- If you don't write "thanks", you may be blacklisted for not saying thanks.
- If you write "thanks", you may be blacklisted because it was not laborious enough.
- If you write something longer - more labourious, you may be blacklisted because it was too boring or anoying.
- If you write anything and you wrote the same also in previous GA, you may be blacklisted for not being original enough.
- If you write anything, you may be blacklisted because the giver don't allow anyone to win twice.
I myself always thank when I won but I am never sure if it will be good enough for the GA giver. All this BL thing is really ridiculous for me. That's why i use only whitelist.
Comment has been collapsed.
:D you're right, there are some users that can't be pleased :D I'm not that picky though :)
Comment has been collapsed.
Black listed for making a ga for a game that i already own
Comment has been collapsed.
some people are idiots. I'm glad your problem was dealt with so quickly, though.
Comment has been collapsed.
It seems he just deleted it himself since someone commented about his rule breaking in his old ga. Well, better than nothing. He'll get suspended some day tho
Comment has been collapsed.
Thanks! I needed an excuse to make the GA too though :D
Comment has been collapsed.
I have feeling that this will make you new friendson SG :D
Comment has been collapsed.
It looks like i missed it :)
Anyway, i am happy that your issue has been solved quickly.
Comment has been collapsed.
So I blacklisted this guy who didn't thank me after receiving the gift from my giveaway. And couple of days later he gave me -1 trade feedback here on SG with the comment "blacklist". I don't really care since I don't trade but...why. It's not even related...some people's reasoning is floating out there somewhere, I guess.
EDIT: It seems to be all good now. I'm surprised it was this fast :o Thank you all for making SG a bit better by reporting the guy :)
EDIT Nr. 2: It seems he just deleted it himself since someone commented about his rule breaking in his old GA. Avoiding fire, I guess.
Comment has been collapsed.