Just as the giveaways are subject to guidelines that have to be followed, the forums should be, too, as they are a major part of the community. Which brings me to main point 1:

As this is an international community that commonly uses the English language, I believe that it should be obligatory to speak English in the forums. I will elaborate in the following points.

  • A - English is one of the most easy to learn languages and is taught around the world. It is not called a world language for nothing.
  • B - Users refusing to use English isolate themselves from the majority of this community. Thus, I believe they shall be no part of said community. I also find it indirectly offensive.
  • B.1 - Users unable to speak/write English should not be using sites that are primarily on English in the first place.
  • B.2 - Not being able to speak/write English (or claiming not to be) is no excuse to do as one pleases. See point A.
  • C - Foreign languages are often abused to shroud illegal activities or to insult people who do not speak the language. Like talking behind their backs, just that it's right in front of their eyes. Weak, man. Very weak.

Mind you that I am not being racist or anything, and I do not condemn foreigners, as I am a foreigner myself. English is not my first language/mother language either.


Addendum:

Consciously or not, by using their mother language, users are constructing a sub-community within the community. Whether they expect it to co-exist peacefully with the main community; If history has taught us anything, then that that isn't gonna work. Not without bloodshed.
Regardless of my opinion, the sub-communities would have to be moderated, or they could be trading invites or something, right on this site (although that example in particular doesn't make sense). And that would require at least one mod for every prominent language. For now that is only Russian, but soon, others will follow, like Spanish and Polish.


Suggested course of Action:

  • Upon registration, make users check a flag that they are able and willing to follow guidelines.
  • My main point 2: Implementing a general strike system. General, meaning that it is applied to any offense, not only breaking Forum guidelines. Details follow.

The strike system

I was thinking up a 3 strike system that works like this:

1st strike: 0 or more penalties
2nd strike: 1 or more penalties
3rd strike: Ban

Most penalties are time limited. The penalties and their time limits should be chosen by the mod performing the strike, depending on the offense and it's gravity. Alternatively, the time limit could default to a week. These penalties could include:

  • Block from commenting/posting in the forums. Applicable to users breaking forum guidelines, e.g. making a thread entirely in Russian.
  • Block from creating giveaways. Applicable to users creating fake giveaways or spamming loads of suspicious giveaways in a short time.
  • Point creation disabled. Applicable to users creating giveaways in a way they generate more points than they should, e.g. making 25 separate giveaways for the same game, instead of one giveaway with 25 copies. May overlap with the prior penalty.
  • Invite generation disabled, currently open invites put on hold (not usable until penalty is lifted). Applicable to users under suspicion of selling invites, or users who invited someone who sells invites or performs other major offenses. May or may not count towards the 3 strike limit, as the user may not be aware of the actions of their invitee.
  • Ban. No time limit. Applicable to users caught selling invites or similar offenses.

Of course, mods can clear penalties and remove the strike if the user successfully clears the suspicion on him in some way.


Not to forget my main point 3: People are not wearing enough hats!
Criticism, insults, opinions, thoughts, spam and death threats follow now.

13 years ago*

Comment has been collapsed.

There, its out of my system. I stood up at 2 AM to write this because it wouldn't let me sleep if I didn't write this posthaste.

PS: It's alive! IT'S ALIVE!!!

13 years ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

You sum up what I feel about foreign languanges in this website.

13 years ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

Wir haben eine kleine problem! Ich will auf Deutsche sprechen.

Okay, I don't really know German very well.

13 years ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

WHAT DID YOU SAY ABOUT MY MOTHER?
jk ;D
█▄▄ ███ █▄▄ █▄█▄█ █▄█ ▀█▀

13 years ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

WTF

13 years ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

I'm gonna slide in before any fires start and say I like the strike system idea. Given, the mods might already have something of the sort for determining bans and such, but it'd be nice to have a public version.

And now for rage:

13 years ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

And, part two, I'd just like to say that you haven't really given any reasons to support banning other languages. The site would gain nothing and lose something, and your talk about "shrouding illegal activity" doesn't correspond to anything I've seen on the forums. Hell, I can't remember the last time I saw someone use a language other than English on here. Point(s) B is pretty much just your opinion, Point C doesn't really come into play, and Point A is an unsubstantiated claim that, again, gives no good reason to require English.

13 years ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

Just curious, but if you can't remember the last time someone spoke in a language besides english on here then what actual difference would it make if english was declared the primary/only allowed language?

13 years ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

That's my point. It wouldn't make any difference, so why bother adding needless limitations?

13 years ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

added an addendum about that

13 years ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

"English is one of the most easy to learn languages . . ."

Yeah, I'd like to see that source. Not everyone picks up languages easily, or were taught English consistently in schools. Use of English should be encouraged, but those that do not (and possibly are not able to) speak English should not be discriminated against. It is also unfair to assume that people speaking their first language do so to insult people and talk about them behind their backs.

That said, I like the strike system.

13 years ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

The language issue could be solved with a subsection on the forum for non-English speakers. There wouldn't be as much support for them, but it could be a community managed section.

13 years ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

Doesn't something like a sub-section for a certain language split the community a bit akin to point B where "refusing to use English isolates...from the majority of this community" and what the Addendum that states:
"Whether they expect it to co-exist peacefully with the main community; If history has taught us anything, then that that isn't gonna work. Not without bloodshed."
Point B.1 appears to be unfair however.

For the sake of not double posting:
I haven't seen a sort of language issue with the forums. If anything the use of languages other than English shouldn't be punished. It's hard enough for non-fluent speakers to get their points across I imagine.
Since this is a forum, you have all the time to highlight and copy paste into a translator to get an idea (but not exact) of what someone is saying in case they use their mother tongue to say something they can not express in English.

So far the only repercussion of not using English is people either ignoring the post or having a rough idea of what is being said. Let's leave it at that.

And to avoid any conflicts that may require subsections for different languages the community needs English speakers members not to be snooty about common mistakes from non-fluent speakers and non-fluent speakers not be crash with the use of their language (i.e insulting people in a language they don't understand).

13 years ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

English is one of the easiest languages to learn, are you kidding me? It's pretty concise grammatically, compared to most languages.

13 years ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

Just because it was easy for some to learn does not mean it is easy for everyone. I've heard the exact opposite from more people than I've had tell me it's easy to pick up - ease and ability in terms of learning second/third/etc. languages is not universal.

13 years ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

its nothing near as gramatically complex as any european language i know of. how many genders does english use? just one. french, spanish, german, etc. they all use at least 3. just one example. ever tried looking into japanese? they have 12 ways of counting. that means 12 different words for every number.

13 years ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

It might not be the easiest, but it's definitely one of the easier languages to learn.
Why would it be discriminating? The whole site is in English and there is no way to change the language, so why should the community suddenly start using different languages? Quite the contrary! I think it's kinda rude to join an English speaking community and only talk in my native tongue.

13 years ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

English is actually one of the most difficult languages to learn. It's a world language, however, due to the large number of non-native English-speaking countries that teach it at a very young age. We (Native English Speakers) have a lot of words that sound the same, but are spelled differently...lots that are the same word with multiple meanings...I could go on and on. IF we truly want a universal language, that's easy (quite literally) to learn, then I'd recommend Esperanto. =P

13 years ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

Interesting. I like the idea of a strike system, but imo I don't think that we need to enforce a rule to speak only English.

13 years ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

Personally I have to agree with this. Either Steamgifts needs to adopt a primary language and require it to be spoken by all of its members, or there will need to be separate instances of the same forum for every spoken language.

In the second case, we would then also have to look at the right to put added provisions into giveaways (One recent example would be where you have to have one of the games of the bundle in order to enter and receive the gift. Why? Because what is to stop someone from adding provisions similar to that in a language that the majority of Steamgifts can not speak? It would wind up creating giveaways people would not enter if they had known they could not possibly win, but since they do not speak the language they are essentially cheated out of their points for entering and being excluded.

Edit: Just thought, if new forums are created specifically for other languages, then steamgifts would also be required to have mods who can speak multiple languages. No clue how that would effect anything though.

13 years ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

I don't like the idea of provisions for giveaways. If the giver doesn't want to let everyone enter, they should make it private. Or there could be some sort of mark separating them from the general giveaways.

13 years ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

Yeah I'm not too keen on making exclusive public giveaways either, but people have done it already and undoubtedly will again.

13 years ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

It seems kind of silly to worry about all these hypothetical situations where people /might/ try to take advantage of their minority status. There is a thing called Google Translate, and it works plenty well enough to enable moderation and/or comprehension of conditions.

13 years ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

You could use Google Translate as an argument for making there be only one language used as well. It's not really a good point to make for either side. After all, if someone can't speak language Z then they can just type in their own language and translate it into language Z, grammar be damned.

13 years ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

Yes, but it's a matter of convenience. I imagine most non-English speakers would prefer to post in their own language than go to the trouble of translating it into a language they don't understand, whereas an English speaker seeing a fully non-English thread isn't likely to be terribly concerned. Again, given the very small numbers of non-English posts, it's not like we'd miss much by allowing them, whereas the inconvenience might preclude some of those few non-English users from bothering to post at all.

13 years ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

I have seen someone translate the entire FAQ into russian, which is fine in itself. but it was posted on a thread that has nothing to do with either the FAQ itself, or russian users. so i replied "wrong thread". the answer to that came in russian...

13 years ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

"English is one of the most easy to learn languages"

.... HA!

I'v heard quite the Opposite, that its one of the hardest. I don't know where you got your information, but I'm Pretty sure its wrong.

13 years ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

I also thought it was common knowledge that English was hard... But maybe he just meant it's one of the easiest to find opportunities to learn (internet, movies, classes, etc).

13 years ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

yes, that plays into it. but the grammar is very easy as well. quoting my answer from above:

it's nothing near as gramatically complex as any european language i know of. how many genders does english use? just one. french, spanish, german, etc. they all use at least 3. just one example. ever tried looking into japanese? they have 12 ways of counting. that means 12 different words for every number.

13 years ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

the only thing in english that takes some getting used to is the pronunciation. personally, I don't like that in american english, most vowels are pronounced differently than in any other language I know, including british english for the most part.

13 years ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

But that's just local dialects, it's not like everybody in the US pronounces vowels the same way. I'm from Germany as well and I'm pretty sure, that I'm pronouncing German words completely different than you.

13 years ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

you got a point there.

13 years ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

One of the less rich grammars I've learn, and I've learn 5 languages and several other languages' grammar are my acquaintances.

13 years ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

Well, there are grammatical mistakes in your post, so...

13 years ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

Honestly, then you've just heard wrong. It is definitely one of the easier languages and to be honest I couldn't think of a single language that is harder to learn.

13 years ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

The ease of learning languages depends on the cultural background of the person. Despite the inner complexities (alphabet or no alphabet, phonetic hint or no phonetic hint) of the language, there are babies learning them and toddlers speaking them.
What really makes a language hard to learn is a different alphabet (as in Japanese, Greek, Arabic, and Russian) or reading order.

Really there's no objective fact about what language is hard to learn.

13 years ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

Added a penalty limiting invite creation/distribution. Also see the addendum about foreign languages

13 years ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

Since the primary cause of this site it language independent I find this thread and it's suggestion a minor thing to look after. There are many functionality issues that can be dealt with first.

13 years ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

I always thought English was one of the harder languages to learn? maybe I am crazy. I still cant figure out if I is before or after E. And I'm an American. Would hate to see someone who is ESL figure that out. Then again if they know 2 languages they are pry smarter than me anyway.

I like the strike idea though.

13 years ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

Seems like almost everyone saying that English is hard to learn comes from the US. Maybe there's a connection? =P

13 years ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

Maybe there is

13 years ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

:)

13 years ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

I can never tell if you're joking or not...

13 years ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

One Major problem though. As everyone knows the official language of Steamgifts is Swahili, not English.

13 years ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

Also, on the rest of the point, mainly the 3 strikes system.

3 strikes works only in Baseball. And even then, without trying other systems in baseball we can't be certain it's the best system. Usually banpoints work best whereby a person can receive banpoints at the discretion of the mod to the extent that a mod feels appropriate and when the banpoints reach a threshold the person is flagged for review and potential banning by a higher up.

Because most of all it'd be really stupid to kick some shit from the site entirely for doing a few stupid thigns here and there. And even if the bans cleared on their own after a set point it would still be overly simplified, because everything equals 1 strike. Yes, some things could be warnings, but what it would come down to would be like this:

Strike Don't enter for games you have
Strike Don't trade games you win
Strike Only one SG account allowed per person, so if you have two steam accounts, you still only get one SG account.
Strike Don't enter for anyone other than yourself
Warning Don't use the site as a way around regional pricing
Strike Do NOT sell/trade invites
Warning Always thank submitters
Strike Do not submit exploited games/keys (Dark Messiah of Might & Magic Multiplayer, Eets, etc)
Strike Do not submit Steam accounts.
Warning Please make sure the people YOU invite follow these rules

Now, as you notice, some of these seem either too low or too high of a penalty, and obviously if someone keeps up with doing the same thing, he should be punished more than if someone were to... Submit an exploited game and enter a giveaway for a game he wants his friend to play with him (but not win it). That right there is anywhere from 2 to 4 strikes. And all he did was not read the rules the second he joined. His first thoughts were "I wonder what I can do here to help Others." Why ban someone for coming to the site and wanting to help people?

In an ideal situation he'd receive a few banpoints with a note as to the reason for them, and based solely on the judgment of the mod. Or maybe even just a warning if the mod were feeling especially nice. These banpoints would likely eventually expire, or maybe even be worked off over time by being a productive member of the forums that other members notice and flag as a good member for something he does. Like if they notice a really good suggestion by him they might "+1" that post and when a certain amount of posts are +1'ed by unique members, it removes banpoints.

Although truly, the best way is to handle each member on an individual basis dealing with each case differently.

13 years ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

There are great many forums that require English to be used. Posts that are not in English, as well as in-game communication/messages/PMs, are regarded as an offense and a warning ticket is issued. It results, essentially, in non-English speakers to just "be silent" or communicate in such fractured sentences (a la google-translator) that it's almost laughable.

13 years ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

seeing the first 20 or so comments of a new giveaway entirely in russian gives me a headache

13 years ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

Closed 13 years ago by BlueLegion.