Best Indie game

All the references!

Limbo looks nice, but its a bad game.

I really like both of these games, but the support is so lacking...

Eufloria especially. One of the achievements in-game is completely impossible, and they know it, and haven't fixed it in over a year. Visit their forums, it's so disheartening. Such a promising company once upon a time.

I was really into Terraria for a while. The devs talked big and were actually delivering on their promises, and it seemed like that would go on forever. A lot of them were active on Reddit and talked about the game and the company and it was an interesting glimpse inside the industry. Then most of the team left for other projects and the whole thing got shelved (long before the big promises were delivered).

Both are still worth playing, although Eufloria is buggy as hell on newer computers.

I played every single one of those except Machinarium, awesome! I approve of this list.

This is the best list.

Edit: Of them all, I only hadn't played Flywrench. I looked it up. Not colorblind friendly. :-(

Edit again: I really want to highlight some of these.

Braid is brilliant. It's not terribly difficult (compared to other games), but you do have to think, and you might have to restart a level now and again as the rules change. I love it. I remember it going on sale and buying up copies for everyone I knew, haha. If you haven't played it yet, do it! It's fairly short, too.

Spacechem has come up in three separate conversations the past few days. I'm glad that more people are playing it. Pure logic puzzle. He also made The Codex of Alchemical Engineering which you can play for free right now in your browser. Go play it! And if you like it, buy Spacechem. It goes on sale all the time. I think he'd rather have people play it than make money off it.

Cave Story is an indie classic. The original is still free to download and play (and so is Knytt), and in my opinion the fan English translations are superior to the "Official" version. Bear in mind that Cave Story+ on Steam is a different developer (same as with the Wii version). Look up how to get the Tow Rope though, otherwise you'll have a sad later. :-(

TO THE MOON, YES GODDAMIT

Love both of these, too!