Should I continue making puzzles?
Took a little while but finally got it :) Haven't done a lot of puzzles here but I enjoyed this one.
Comment has been collapsed.
I've been at this for over 6 hours and I'm still stumped. I don't want to give up but geez I am having hardcore trouble with this.
Comment has been collapsed.
What I'm doing right now is literally using overlapped drawings in photoshop that map every single possible move that each piece can make, and I feel like I'm going crazy because I can force one move on black and seemingly put black into checkmate in two turns. I know the giveaway creator said it's three, and obviously people have found 3 turn solutions, but I seriously don't know what I'm doing wrong.
If you want I can add you on steam and show you what I've been trying to do over chat, I'd rather avoid doing so in public chat so I don't inadvertently give out a solution to everyone x____x
Edit: I just realized I didn't have checkmate after all, one of my pieces was being blocked by another preventing me from actually putting the King in checkmate >_<
Comment has been collapsed.
I think I'm going to have to do something similar to your overlapping since I simple don't see the move(s) I'm missing to solve it. So far I can fake checkmate him in two moves (one of the pieces is in the way) and I can stop the king from making any moves in two moves (but I lose my knight) or in three moves (and not lose anything), great succes :p I hope no one gives any hints, I want to solve it myself. At least I have 13 more days to try and solve it and otherwise hopefully get the answer when the GA's end :p
Comment has been collapsed.
Not a hint, but I'll say that the solution is kind of a "oh, DUH" kind of thing. Based on what you're saying, I'd say you're right there though.
Comment has been collapsed.
I suck so bad at chess >.< I'll keep trying but with really little hope for actually solving the puzzle :S
Have a bump anyway!
Comment has been collapsed.
Worked through and understand the puzzle (yes yes with black moving). Found ~4-5 separate check combinations that went for 2 moves, cant find a 3rd move that mates black </3 Excellent puzzle, going to take a break and mull it over a bit. Bump for hopefully solved later today
Comment has been collapsed.
The thing is, if you don't check, then black will get a free move which would most likely break everything... but so far I've been unable to find any consistent check where black doesn't get a free choice to react anyway. I'm sure the looping board is playing tricks on me :(
Comment has been collapsed.
Make sure your aren't being blocked by your own pieces - I made that same error earlier.
Comment has been collapsed.
Do we always have to force black through only one move ? Or can we give them 2+ choices and just assume they'll take the one we want ? And can we assume they'll take any other piece if possible as long as there's no direct danger ?
Comment has been collapsed.
Not going to lie, the past half hour of my guessing actually involved me making a typo in the solution box mixing me up. I was about to ask if I can message you about my solution before I realized I was making the typo. xP
Excellent job man!!
Comment has been collapsed.
Seems fun and challenging. You shouldn't give up on puzzles. Plenty people appreciate them. I don't think I could manage to solve it as I was never very good at Chess, but maybe. I might forget valid rules on how a piece can move, but I think I remember them all.
Comment has been collapsed.
I've invested several hours into finding a solution so far and I have discovered one but it is not being accepted as the answer (meaning there is a specific solution i'm not seeing??)
In my "solution" :
-mate is reached in 3
-the board is treated as looped on all edges
-all assumed moves for black are extremely reasonable (maybe not best?? but "best" seems to be relative in this sense...)
Any chance I can get some insight into why my solution is invalid? Thanks :D
EDIT: just double and triple checked my solution and there are no mistakes on my part unless I'm misunderstanding exactly what you want us to find :/
Comment has been collapsed.
I think the best I could help you out without giving anything away is that you shouldn't "assume" black's moves.
Comment has been collapsed.
But that doesn't mean my solution is invalid, perhaps I found an alternate solution not intended to be discovered?
Comment has been collapsed.
I was in the camp of multiple solutions for a while, and after I solved it was when I realized there was definitely only one solution possible.
Another thing that may help is making sure that your piece's paths aren't being blocked off by another piece. I thought I had checkmate in 2 moves for a good hour until I realized one of my pieces was being blocked.
Edit: If you want, you can add me on steam to discuss this further. I won't give you the answer, but I can help verify if you're making legal moves that are working like you want them to without potentially spoiling the rest of the chat here.
Comment has been collapsed.
Ok it turns out that I was forgetting a specific facet of the expression that people not super-familiar with chess might not know about. Should have the solution soon.
Comment has been collapsed.
154 Comments - Last post 37 minutes ago by Wok
281 Comments - Last post 39 minutes ago by Wok
8 Comments - Last post 4 hours ago by TheLimeyDragon
1,247 Comments - Last post 7 hours ago by WaxWorm
82 Comments - Last post 8 hours ago by GarlicToast
71 Comments - Last post 9 hours ago by LighteningOne
145 Comments - Last post 12 hours ago by seaman
52 Comments - Last post 9 minutes ago by Yamaraus
73 Comments - Last post 11 minutes ago by schmoan
777 Comments - Last post 14 minutes ago by Vampus
115 Comments - Last post 16 minutes ago by DemonsRift
647 Comments - Last post 19 minutes ago by DrPower
27 Comments - Last post 22 minutes ago by NewbieSA
91 Comments - Last post 24 minutes ago by idontknow23
4th Puzzlemania puzzle! Do not forget to join the group :)
30.06. UPD #1. Within the first day of the event, I received A LOT comments from many users who told me that it is possible to mate in 2 moves or there are multiple solutions for this problem. All those users were mistaken. There exists exactly one solution and there is NO mate in 2 moves. However, if you still think that the problem is not valid, feel free to comment here and contact me after that. But please check and double check your solution before doing this.
Hello, Steamgifters!
This is already the fourth Puzzlemania event! I hope you are as happy as I am :) If you missed my previous puzzles and do not have a clue what Puzzlemania is, you can check these threads: first, second, third.
The latest puzzle received mixed reviews: some people enjoyed it, others however considered it to be very vague and difficult. Lessons learned, this time the puzzle will be very straightforward. It does not mean that it will be easy, most probably not, at least for the majority of people. However, the rules will be very transparent, you will not need to guess what I was thinking about when creating this puzzle. I hope it sounds a bit motivating.
Now, towards some bad thing happened during my last puzzle. Good steamgifters and I found together three different forums where bad steamgifters asked for help with solving my puzzle. I would like to remind you that this is not acceptable and SG rules forbid this. This is an individual puzzle, so please try solving it alone. Probably people tried to cheat because I gave away Witcher 3 gift, which is a very popular AAA game. So, this time there will not be such an expensive giveaway. However, the total amount of giveaways will be 26, which is also quite nice, right?
I am also not sure if people like my puzzles at all or the only reason why they solve them is to gain access to giveaways. To investigate this issue, I attached the poll to this topic. This is a serious question for me, so there is no a potato option in the poll, sorry for that guys. It is not a 'please-praise-me' poll. If I find out that the people here do not like my puzzle, I can stop creating them and just give away the games without any efforts for both sides.
Congratulations to everybody who read my bullshit up to this point because from here the description of this puzzle officially begins! This puzzle is about the good old game of chess. Sounds boring? Do not worry, we will add an exciting rule to this game! :) Basically, try to imagine that the board is looped. To better understand it, let's take a look at the diagram attached. In normal chess white knight would only have two possible moves: Nb3 and Nc2. However, we looped the board, so now, for example such moves as Ng2 or Nh7 are also possible. By looping the board I mean that 1st horizontal is now connected to 8th one, and the A vertical is connected to H one. When you got the whole point, here is the problem: white to mate in 3 moves. Find them! The answer should contain only three white moves without numbers or spaces. Also, if you eat something or check the king, ignore the signs. So, insted of writing N:b3 or Bd4+, just write Nb3 and Bd4 accordingly. The example of the answer, so you can understand the format: Nb3Bg7Kf5. So, in this notation King = K, Bishop = B, Knight = N.
I consider this chess problem to be quite a difficult one, however almost for sure I will not prrovide any hints because it does not make sense for chess problems. You will have two weeks to find the solution yourselves. The puzzle will end on Wednesday, 13th of July. The fastest solvers will be whitelisted by me.
Please believe me that you will very satisfied and will be very proud of yourself when you solve this puzzle. So, do not leave too fast and give it a try! :)
Good luck and have fun!
The list of the giveaways (points needed to enter everything: 400):
Hall of Fame
The following early solvers have been whitelisted! Congratulations!
Yukulele53
Eohor
Henryblah
sumyy
ValyrianSteel
Nordhbane
CalculonJones
Caeler
dead1ne
The solution
The solution briefly:
So, the answer is: Bh8Nh3Be8.
The solution explained:
Conclusions
Thank you all who participated in this event! The poll results clearly indicates that the majority (76 out of 114 votes, more than two thirds) likes my puzzles, so I will not give up creating them! I do not know yet when I will be able to make the next Puzzlemania event, I hope it will be before September. I already have some ideas, but they are still too vague.
As I promised, I did not provide hints during this event and still we have 48 solvers out of 159 players, which is more than 30%. Therefore, I consider this puzzle was too easy for steamgifters, so brace yourselves, the difficulty of the next event will be higher.
Comment has been collapsed.