Since I'm checking Cubic bundle keys, here are some other dupes I've found.
Legendary Cubic Bundle dupes:
Vanguard Princess
Castle
Aztaka
October Cubic Bundle dupes:
Bullet Candy
Dodge
Astro Emporia
Rainy Cubic Bundle dupes:
Madballs in Babo: Invasion
Lightfish
Memories of a Vagabond
Neon Cubic Bundle dupes:
Hyposphere
Beasts Battle
Wasteland Angel
April Cubic Bundle dupes:
Helena The 3rd
Red Bit Ninja
Volstead
Samsa and the Knights of Light
Caveman Craig
Spring Cubic Bundle dupes:
Red Lake
Caribbean Odyssey
Dungeons Are Random
May Cubic Bundle dupes:
The Prism
Rooks Keep
Space Station Alpha
One Way To Exit
Puzzle Galaxies
Abstract Cubic Bundle dupes:
Abandoned
BeatBlasters III
Hoven the Sages Spinel
Summer Cubic Bundle dupes:
Dark Matter
Alter World
Z.I.O.N.
June Cubic Bundle dupes:
Whispering Willows
Of Carrots And Blood
Incredible Dracula: Chasing Love Collectors Edition
Hot Cubic Bundle dupes:
Obulis
Tank Universal
Sacra Terra: Angelic Night
Ultimate Cubic Bundle dupes:
Darkout
Pixel Puzzles 2: Birds
Goblin Defenders: Steel‘n’ Wood
Long Dozen Bundle dupes:
See No Evil
The Rebel
Star Project
At this point I'm thinking all Cubic bundle keys have either been revoked or stolen.
Comment has been collapsed.
I'll try the rest of my keys from those bundles soon and edit in any results, was basically just doing a few from each to try and find something that works.
So far all my unredeemed keys from Cubic bundles older than the Long Dozen Bundle (November 2016) dont work.
After checking those I was able to redeem some unused keys from the Vacation Bundle and August Cubic Bundle 2 so anything from bundles newer than the Vacation Bundle (July 2017) might be ok.
It's possible that their website was hacked and had a bunch of keys stolen, I wouldn't be surprised if some accounts were compromised in that 8 month period and they either didn't know or didn't say anything.
Comment has been collapsed.
octave in IndieGala Humpday #30 have also been stolen
Comment has been collapsed.
CyberPunk 3776 key invalidated in Indiegala Friday special #16
Comment has been collapsed.
Remnants Of The Arcane
https://steamcommunity.com/games/498390/announcements/detail/1593639552724500699
Comment has been collapsed.
Magma Chamber from Every Monday #110 said duplicate I only just revealed it
Comment has been collapsed.
In Game Adventure: Legend of Monsters IndieGala Humpday #45 key just revealed and it says used so either just 1 bad key or all invalidated
Comment has been collapsed.
NEO-NOW from IndieGala Indiezone bundle, key just revealed and is a dupe
Comment has been collapsed.
I looked into this a little while ago when a GA of mine for NEO-NOW (IndieGala Hump Day 26) was a duplicate key. Apparently the IndieGala keys went bad a long time ago, and were replaced quickly. However, it was so long ago that they don't have replacements any more, so if the original (bad) key wasn't replaced back then, it's almost certainly bad now. It was on sale for 49 cents, though, as it is now, so I just bought a new one for the GA winner.
Comment has been collapsed.
D/Generation from Ballistic Finale just revealed and is a dupe
Comment has been collapsed.
Armored Kitty from Indie Armored Bundle (Indie Gala). My key didn't worked and there is this thread on steam forums: https://steamcommunity.com/app/713530/discussions/0/1640915206450517279/
Comment has been collapsed.
https://www.steamgifts.com/go/comment/Sk6x3cW
As I said in comment from my link above. My key for Square Head Zombies - FPS Game from this bundle https://www.steamgifts.com/discussion/Fc2sY/gogobundle-go-go-bundle-mega-17 was a duplicate.
Comment has been collapsed.
News for Octave. Should be also valid for Little Kite (I've just checked an unused key from Otaku Bundle #17 and it's a dupe) and maybe Repentant, both from the same developer. I don't know if he also revoked the Steam keys for the OST of Little Kite.
Hey. Sorry for the late reply.
These bundles were held several years ago. Unused keys were not returned to me, and could be sold on unofficial sites, so now, after a few years, all keys have been revoked. If you bought a bundle and still have not activated the game - please write me a private message, or on Twitter.
Comment has been collapsed.
Just activated Repentant from Indiegala Friday Special #73 and one of two keys I had for Little Kite from Hump Day 45.
The other key for Little Kite did not work though nor did the keys for Octave so I messaged the dev on Twitter, now just have to wait and see.
Comment has been collapsed.
Unused keys invalidated.
One way to exit from May Cubic Bundle
Existentia from IndieGala - The Chroma Bundle
Comment has been collapsed.
Existentia keys have been revoked from other bundles, too. I checked a couple of unrevealed ones I had from DIG Super Bundle 77 and they were dupes.
I had one spare key for from the Beasts Battle from the NEON CUBIC Bundle and it worked fine.
GROOVY keys from GameBundle.com's The Motley GameBundle are dupes too.
Comment has been collapsed.
This is seriously shit and scary so many revocations. I have not purchased a bundle in 2 years. Thank God.
Comment has been collapsed.
CRASHBOT from Bunch Keys Bundle #22, tried 3 keys today and they were all duplicates
Harmless Skeleton from Bunch Keys Bundle #19, tried 1 key and it was duplicate
JDM Tuner Racing from BundleStars Born 2 Race 4 is a duplicate
Super Meat Shooter from Bunch Keys Bundle 12 is a duplicate
Comment has been collapsed.
i lost like around 500 games yesterday, how its possible? (not sure about yesterday, but steam did massive ban. so probaby yesterday
Comment has been collapsed.
Today, Steam has revoked my key from "StaudSoft's Synthetic World" game
https://store.steampowered.com/app/343320/StaudSofts_Synthetic_World_Beta/
Comment has been collapsed.
https://steamcommunity.com/games/343320/announcements/detail/1708483156052289596
TLDR: says keys were stolen, revoked all unused keys and some keys that were never on sale (those are the ones getting removed from libraries). You may ask the dev for a replacement.
See also: http://indiegamestand.com/ - info about stolen keys TLDR: They lost money, they lost servers, they don't know what happened to keys and said the only solution for developers is to revoke the keys.
Comment has been collapsed.
Some more invalidated/duped keys:
Destination Dungeon: Crypts of Warthallow from Go Go Bundle Mega #16, 5/5 keys were dupe
Digit Daze from Go Go Bundle Mega #16, 2/5 keys were dupe
H.I.S.T.O.R.Y T.O.R.C.H.K.A 2 from Indiegala Indie Magic, 1/1 key was dupe
Drop The Bomb from Go Go Bundle Limited #81, 1/1 key was dupe
Comment has been collapsed.
Drop The Bomb from IndieGala - Friday Special #67
Comment has been collapsed.
leftover key for A Salem Witch Trial - murder mystery bought from OTAKU BUNDLE #23 are duplicate error on activating.
Comment has been collapsed.
I'm not sure if this counts as a revocation, but all unclaimed keys (because they were "temporarily exhausted") for macdows 95 are now gone for good since Humble Bundle removed the game from the JUNE 2019 Monthly Bundle purchase page.
Comment has been collapsed.
Its not an Alone situation, Ethereal and roombo are on the same boat, looks like they are cleaning the house from those originals
Comment has been collapsed.
I can confirm that a Roombo key/gift link is definitely no longer available for January 2019 Humble Monthly owners, but still available as DRM free download.
Comment has been collapsed.
Only a week ago I asked support when I could finally get my key for Ethereal and Roombo... got told to have patience. Week later: they just remove them from account. Something tells me... they can't just do that.
Comment has been collapsed.
IMO this (and evidently the other humble originals removed) is a revocation of some kind: Customers were told at some point, whether upon a monthly's go-live or after the fact, that they were entitled to a key without any stipulation of "while supplies last" but then Humble revoked the ability to redeem the keys.
I'd be curious to hear Lilly's thoughts on this. "keys ran out" is definitely accurate for macdows 95, but I don't know if there is a more accurate label for the other originals with keys that were in monthlies - Perhaps "limited time key offer", given that Humble pulled the plug on many or all key offerings for Humble Originals in monthlies?
Comment has been collapsed.
Its not a good move from them and i can tell you that, i had a revelead Key for roombo and didnt activate it for resons of waiting for the game to go out of the black list that Steam dont count it for their achievements.. and that Key is also gone, something that i have revelead for myself, they just removed everything about originals from their pages/links
Comment has been collapsed.
I'm pretty sure that this isn't a decision by HB but by the developer not wanting to give his game away for free anymore on Steam. Macdows 95 Steam store page has the developer's name as the Publisher and not HB. Not sure if that's always been the case.
As far as Roomba and Ethereal goes.. Roomba is now published under the developer, Samurai Punk and Ethereal's publisher is now Nonsense Arts.
Comment has been collapsed.
Well there's now a renewed promise recently from the Roomba dev to request keys, so IMO all this is not necessarily an issue with change of publisher, nor did the Ethereal's dev note mention that. Additionally, barter lists at least two of these (Macdows 95 and Ethereal) as having run out of keys in comparable time frames (7 weeks ago).
So I posted an FYI to to /r/gamedeals, and now I think the list of removed/ran out of keys from HB has grown into this:
Macdows 95 (in June 2019 monthly)
Ethereal (in Sept 2018 monthly)
Roombo: First Blood (in January 2019 monthly)
A Short Hike (in April 2019 monthly, per reddit)
Fortune-499 (in Feb 2018 monthly, per reddit)
All are ID'd in barter as having run out of keys, and many are verified as no longer visible in key/purchases pages.
It would not surprise me if Humble did not notify some or all these devs of keys running out, and is tired of waiting for keys and/or getting a bunch of support tickets, so therefore they started removing the games from key/purchase pages.
Comment has been collapsed.
Support came back with:
Hello there,
I sincerely apologize for any frustration that the wait of receiving your key may have caused. While I am happy to have some new information on the situation, I'm afraid that it won't be what we were hoping.
First, I'd like to recap the situation. The game you are writing in about was a Humble Original, offered in one of the month's in our Humble Monthly. The game was provided only as a DRM-free build on the download page for that month and is still available there today. A few months after that Month's content was revealed, the developer released their Humble Original on Steam. After some internal discussion, we thought it would be a nice bonus for subscribers to also get one of these Steam keys, which we quickly implemented.
We unfortunately underestimated the popularity of these keys and quickly ran out. We have been working for the past weeks to try and secure more keys for those who were unable to get one, but we have been unable to do so. At this point in time, we are sorry to say that we will not be able to provide a Steam key for these games. I know that this is not at all what we wanted to happen and I am very sorry for this outcome.
Again, the game is still available via DRM-free download in your library and all of the content that you've paid for is still available. These keys were meant to be a free bonus, which we have not been able to completely fill. We are truly sorry for the frustration and inconvenience that this has caused. If there are any other questions or concerns, please let me know. Otherwise I hope you have a happy holiday season!
Comment has been collapsed.
Not surprised really, felt like an automated response to me.
I wasn't happy and made that clear, they escalated it to a higher level support now.
Comment has been collapsed.
Ugh, well I think I'm going to create a comment to the post "[Humble Bundle] List of Humble Originals that got Steam Keys 💙", since this whole topic seems more relevant over there than this key revocations thread...
Comment has been collapsed.
Just the unused keys?
Have you tried both Go Go Bundle Limited #78 and Go Go Bundle #49?
Comment has been collapsed.
Pixel Painter (aka Battle of the painters) from Indiegala Postal Party bundle - unclaimed keys turned out duplicated :(
Comment has been collapsed.
Same for:
Otaku Bundle #5
Go Go Bundle Limited #15
Cubic Bundle One Dollar Bundle #2
I couldn't test DIG Super Bundle 113 but I guess the keys from that one have been revoked too.
Other bundled games from the same developer (Music Racer, Joy Pony and Behind The Door) seem to work fine.
Comment has been collapsed.
31 Comments - Last post 1 hour ago by slurredprey
54 Comments - Last post 2 hours ago by sensualshakti
450 Comments - Last post 5 hours ago by klingki
7 Comments - Last post 9 hours ago by xXSAFOXx
16,297 Comments - Last post 11 hours ago by SebastianCrenshaw
206 Comments - Last post 15 hours ago by Joey2741
31 Comments - Last post 16 hours ago by Pika8
172 Comments - Last post 10 minutes ago by Fitz10024
54 Comments - Last post 11 minutes ago by MarvashMagalli
7,980 Comments - Last post 11 minutes ago by greddo
70 Comments - Last post 54 minutes ago by Tucs
44 Comments - Last post 1 hour ago by Tucs
690 Comments - Last post 1 hour ago by Fitz10024
128 Comments - Last post 1 hour ago by Swordoffury
Lists to use:
Unused Keys Revoked: https://barter.vg/notices/513
Revoked (Dev): https://barter.vg/notices/362
Revoked (DMCA): https://barter.vg/notices/361
Duplicates: https://barter.vg/notices/372
If you want this information for one game specifically, you can find it under the "Notices" section for the Barter entry of that game.
(Example: https://barter.vg/i/42708/ then scroll down to "Notices": you'll see the red notice "Revoked (Dev) ⌫"; mouseovering it will give you some more info)
Thanks to everyone who reported their key revocations here. Please continue reporting them here. You folks are awesome!
Due to character limit, time constraints and having to manually create the chart rows, it's very difficult to keep a list on revocations on SteamGifts. Since I am the one managing these notices on Barter anyway, I thought it would be convenient to centralize the reports from SteamGifts and trade offers into one place and Barter proved to be a good solution for that because of its bundles and game database.
The below lists will not be updated on SG any more, but all your reports will be reflected on Barter, so please continue reporting them.
Previous links, for reference:
A list of games completely revoked from your library after activation
A list of games whose unredeemed keys were revoked (the big chart that was previously in this thread was moved here)
More games with invalidated keys can be found here.
Comment has been collapsed.