Idk if we can discuss this but...

there was a big long thread all about this recently...basically the gist of its contents was: mods can handle any actual problems, the report button exists so publicly accusing is unnecessary and its rude/offputting to new users(who happen to be bringing shiny nice gifts) who can get the wrong impression of the community as being hostile and suspicious "so do I really want to be a part of this group afterall"
(and less importantly that it's just guessing anyway and is often enough wrong, with no real benefit or effect when correct to balance possibly alienating gifters when falsely accused.)

What the heck are you even trying to say in this post?

I believe you're free to express your doubt, but plain calling out is unacceptable. The rule is simple: Everybody is innocent until caught. I don't see why you can't understand that.