Was this a good trade

Think so... kingmaker was a DLC for a free game if I'm correct? And if Yes then it's weird for him to accept such a trade

Yeah...you robbed him xD

Both games are bundled games..so i guess its okay.

Bad or good trade, it depends in if you are going to actually play what you get from a trade imo... Yesterday I traded away all the Dawn of War content from the actual HB Weekly Tier 1 and 2 for "smaller" or "cheaper" games but wich I actually want to play in a near future unlike the Dawn of War games... But in terms of "profit" yes, you did and excellent trade.

Crysis on Steam or Origin?

Considering that i've never heard o fkingmaker war of the roses vs an-AAA title....It's a good deal.I don't like origin though.

All these games were in the $1 tier back in August 2013:
Dead Space, Dead Space 3, Crysis 2 Maximum Edition, Burnout Paradise: The Ultimate Box, Medal of Honor, and Mirror's Edge
separate Origin and Steam keys (except Dead Space 3) for each game! Crazy!

Pretty reliable source: https://web.archive.org/web/20130816150710/https://www.humblebundle.com/