Which Tomb Raider?

If you like the series, and similar games like Prince of Persia, try Underworld. If you like something different, go with the Guardian of Light. I don't know, never been interested in TR series (except Guardian of light, which had really nice camera angle).

Lara Croft and the Guardian of Light!

TR: Anniversary is a very good game, challenging and well worth the money. Legend is only alright, not too gone on it. Still in the process of playing Underworld, didn't get off to a good start by beginning with a water level. Never played Guardian of Light.

i'd say legend. aniversary is just a remake of the first game (not saying its bad, just saying you might already have played it... sorta)

Personally, it has to be Anniversary for me. I played the shit out of the original for PSx and seeing it revamped like that was amazing. :)

Anniversary or Legend. Anniversary is the HD remake of the TR1. Legend is a great start to a new storyline. Underworld is just the end. (:

As a fan of TR franchise, I couldn't finish Underworld, it's so boring.. :(

Anniversary IMO. Nice remake, but still feels fresh. Legend's okay, but feels too... action-y rather than exploration-based. Plus Lara has annoying people yapping at her all the time. Underworld is decent, but they cut boss battles and added health regen, making it feel too easy. Haven't played Guardian of Light yet, but it's absolutely nothing like a regular Tomb Raider game from what I've seen.

you are not making it easier by recommending me differents games all of you :P I think I'll go for Anniversary and Legend. Don't want the Guardian of the light because of goddamn DLCs which will cost me another £2. And water levels in Underworld... not for me.

I have to say Tomb Raider: Anniversary, as it is pretty much a remake of the first game, and I'm a fan of the older games in the franchise.

Underworld

well, I was going to make a new thread but unlike many before me, I am aware of the search function on steamgifts.

Since the Tomb Raider games are on sale, I figure I'll pick one up. Which one should I get?

most responses below recommend Anniversary or Legend, but it's been 5 months and that's plenty of time for others
to have picked up and played the game to give their opinion.

Legend!! Underworld just bored as hell. The number of enemy is too small, which is suck.