Hello! I'd like to join as a reviewer. ^_^
I'd also be willing to offer my help regarding Discord server creation/management/moderation if you'd like, as I really like your idea but I'm not sure I'd have the time to play and thoroughly review games so this could be my way of further contributing to this new community.
I'm usually online unless I'm sleeping, and very active (with notifications enabled with servers I moderate) - I have my own server for FGF and also know how to code a simple bot if we ever want that in the server. I'm sure there are people who have even better knowledge/skills out there, but if no one else offers, I would like to lend my help.
Comment has been collapsed.
Hello!
I'd love to have you. I've sent you a friend request!
Another member already offered to help me out with the Discord server. But we could use a Moderator on the Group Page and in Discord as well :)
Comment has been collapsed.
I would like to join as a full member , just a question tho, can the giveaway be region locked ?
Comment has been collapsed.
Awesome!
I'll send you a friend request. Please message me with your desired role and I'll invite you in the Group :)
Region locked games are accepted, but need to made known they're region locked.
Comment has been collapsed.
SCREENSHOT OF THE MONTH section, in which ALL SteamGifts members can submit their favourite screenshot from any game. Only 3 will be selected for publication. 3rd place, 2nd place and the winner. (don't know yet where they should submit the photos)
This interests me quite a bit, but I'm curious who will be doing the selection of the top three? Will it be you alone or a vote among everyone in the group? If there's some sort of help needed in this area, I'd be interested to get onboard.
As for how to submit the shots, I think the decision on how to proceed with that relies heavily on if you want to submission to be "secret" or open. If the latter, then one easy way I can think of could be via simple thread here in SG. People will just need to give a direct link to their screenshot, and it would also allow anyone interest to like/favorite/award any cool shots they find in the submission thread.
Additionally, it might be cool to have a similar thing for Artworks. There's a lot of creativity out there, so I feel confident there could be interest in seeing (game related) artworks as well.
I'd also be interest to contribute a giveaway for the project, namely Detroit: Become Human. I figured I'd mention the game I have in mind already since you said you don't want repeats. ^^
Comment has been collapsed.
Hello and thank you for the interest!
This interests me quite a bit, but I'm curious who will be doing the selection of the top three? Will it be you alone or a vote among everyone in the group? If there's some sort of help needed in this area, I'd be interested to get onboard.
I haven't decided it, but I think that a special channel on Discord dedicated for screenshot submission could be useful. Then, a few days before the magazine is published, we take all screenshots and group upload them to IMGUR, making sure each member that submitted the screenshot is properly tagged. After that we create a monthly "Vote for the best Screenshot" post here on SG discussions board. If anyone can think of an easier way, I'll gladly listen Also, I could use any help I can get. If I can delagate some "sections" to other members, that would be great.
As for how to submit the shots, I think the decision on how to proceed with that relies heavily on if you want to submission to be "secret" or open. If the latter, then one easy way I can think of could be via simple thread here in SG. People will just need to give a direct link to their screenshot, and it would also allow anyone interest to like/favorite/award any cool shots they find in the submission thread.
That's a good suggestion as well. Skipping the Discord step. But some might find it easier to submit here, while others would prefer Discord. I guess we can do both.
Additionally, it might be cool to have a similar thing for Artworks. There's a lot of creativity out there, so I feel confident there could be interest in seeing (game related) artworks as well.
Another great suggestion that's going straight into the "suggestion box", lol. I am not even kidding. I have all the good suggestions noted already. Thing is, I am not sure how many things I can add before it starts crumbling. Some suggestions might be used further down the line, if the Magazine is popular enough :)
I'd also be interest to contribute a giveaway for the project, namely Detroit: Become Human. I figured I'd mention the game I have in mind already since you said you don't want repeats. ^^
Awesome giveaway. Excellent game! I might even say it's a strong contender for the "Cover Review"
I'll send you a friend request on Steam, then add you to the Group as a Contributor. I could further give you the role of "Moderator" if you're interested :P
Comment has been collapsed.
Then, a few days before the magazine is published, we take all screenshots and group upload them to IMGUR, making sure each member that submitted the screenshot is properly tagged. After that we create a monthly "Vote for the best Screenshot" post here on SG discussions board. If anyone can think of an easier way, I'll gladly listen Also, I could use any help I can get. If I can delagate some "sections" to other members, that would be great.
I know there are some sites that allow you to create "photo polls" where you just need to click on the photo you want to vote for from the list of options. It's a handy way, but I don't think there's anything too complicated about doing it the way you described - we've seen people do that many times before here. And if going with the IMGUR method, I could certainly help with that at least, managing the screenshots, making the poll, etc, if you'd like.
Skipping the Discord step. But some might find it easier to submit here, while others would prefer Discord. I guess we can do both.
Some people do not use Discord at all meanwhile we can confidently expect that everyone reading the magazine does use SG, so having multiple options for people to submit their screenshots could be a good idea.
Thing is, I am not sure how many things I can add before it starts crumbling. Some suggestions might be used further down the line, if the Magazine is popular enough :)
Yep, good to start smaller and expand on that if it really gets off the ground. There's certainly no rush to pack everything into the first few issues immediately. ^^
I'll send you a friend request on Steam, then add you to the Group as a Contributor. I could further give you the role of "Moderator" if you're interested :P
Accepted and sent a request to join while I was at it. And I could be interested in Moderator role as well, yes.
Comment has been collapsed.
We'd love to have you as part of the team, Noxco... Welcome aboard! :)
I know there are some sites that allow you to create "photo polls" where you just need to click on the photo you want to vote for from the list of options. It's a handy way, but I don't think there's anything too complicated about doing it the way you described - we've seen people do that many times before here. And if going with the IMGUR method, I could certainly help with that at least, managing the screenshots, making the poll, etc, if you'd like.
I've searched for some viable options, but the only websites I could find required payment for the service. I might have to look harder, but at the moment I am pretty content with the SG Post + Vote poll + IMGUR method. The screenshots submission method is what I am not happy with and I am trying to find alternatives or additional methods besides Discord.
If you have the time and patience, I would be thankful if you will be managing the screenshots and making the vote poll. It would save me a lot of time and you can probably do it better!
Some people do not use Discord at all meanwhile we can confidently expect that everyone reading the magazine does use SG, so having multiple options for people to submit their screenshots could be a good idea.
Exactly my thoughts! Now we just need to find a good method of collecting the screenshots here on SG.
Yep, good to start smaller and expand on that if it really gets off the ground. There's certainly no rush to pack everything into the first few issues immediately. ^^
I have so many ideas. Ideas for ideas I haven't even implemented yet. It's crazy, but also fun and exciting. I am really looking forward to seeing the first issue released! After we have it out, I am sure more people will join and want to be part of the whole project.
Comment has been collapsed.
I'd like to join as a reviewer, if possible. I don't know if anyone mentioned this already, but due to how the group is gonna work and the fact reviewers have a limited number of giveaways they're allowed to enter per month, it's possible a few (or a lot) of group giveaways will end up with less than 5 entries, meaning the creator gets no CV. This could potentially discourage some people from contributing, so I think it's important this point is put upfront so people are aware of it.
Comment has been collapsed.
Hello,
I'll send you a friend request so that I can then invite you in the group!
Regarding your concern. I am aware of it. I thought about it. I am hoping that we can fill those 5 entries per giveaway tbh. We might not reach that target in the first month, but I'm sure later on it will become easier. We already have 8 reviewers, 9 with you if you join and I've just created the Group a few hours ago. More will join for sure.
Comment has been collapsed.
It's going to be linked here, in an easy to read, open and download format :)
Comment has been collapsed.
I'd love to join as a full member if you'll have me!
A couple points also:
I was reading through the thread, and someone mentioned 'Steam Deck' reviews. I think that might be a nice idea for some games if the reviewer has a Steam Deck, and is willing to spend the time to find a good combo for the in-game settings, and the global settings (like global FSR, TDP Limit, etc). To allow the game to run for a playable playtime, while also not looking like a potato.
Also, would it be at all possible to submit reviews for games not given away in the group? That may be useful occasionally to get some extra reviews or fill some extra space if required.
Thanks!
Comment has been collapsed.
I'll send you a friend request! :)
Yes, games can be played on the Steam Deck as well.I don't mind. It will be mentioned in the game's info graphic if that's the case.
Comment has been collapsed.
Rain World looks really good, but I'm not confident enough in my abilities to deal with the frustratingly punishing game that it seems to be. Looking forward to reading the review of whoever has the luck to win the giveaway AND the determination necessary to push through and beat the game within the allocated deadline!
Comment has been collapsed.
Indeed it does.
I don’t expect it to be featured in the first issue, actually I might even add 1 more week to the deadline for it. I want members to give it a shot, I think it’s a great game.
Comment has been collapsed.
Hi! I'd like to join as a reviewer.
My only question is - are we expected to be ready to review a game every month, or can we skip months? I know my workload ebbs and flows, and sometimes I might not have the commitment to participate in a specific month. Another reason could be the games available for review - for instance, from the list on the main post, I think Backbone is the only one that I could confidently review this month given my interest in the game, genre, and time commitment. Do you anticipate that being a problem?
Thank you!
Comment has been collapsed.
Bump!
Added a Discord server for anyone to join + more info on "Screenshot of the Month" contest.
Comment has been collapsed.
Hello,
I'd be glad to have you but what role do you have in mind?
Comment has been collapsed.
Okay. I'll add you to the Editors team!
Thanks for joining :)
Comment has been collapsed.
You can only enter giveaways and review the games as a Reviewer or Full Member role. It's all writen in the Group Rules :)
If you want to join giveaways you can have both the Reviewer and Editor role at the same time. But please read or re-read the rules!
We have a dedicated topic opened in the Steam Group Page called "Editor's Desk". I will assign reviews to editors there once they are finished!
Comment has been collapsed.
Hello,
Just a kind reminded that you've won a Group Giveaway, and as such you need to play the game and review it before the deadline.
There are still 10 days remaining (and you can request additional 5 days if you need to). I'd hate to blacklist you, since you seem like a capable Reviewer!
Hope you can make it! :)
Comment has been collapsed.
Hi! I would like to apply for the role of reviewer as well.
As I was reading through the list of information given for that role I was specifically looking for number 13. I'm trying my best with the language but I would definitely need that.
I also have a question I haven't seen an answer for. What can a reviewer do if they can't run a game they were supposed to write about.
Comment has been collapsed.
Hello and thank you for the interest!
The reviewer should check the game's system requirements before deciding if they want to enter the giveaway. [Can You Run It][https://www.systemrequirementslab.com/cyri) is a good tool for this. If the game doesn't run from other reasons you have to address me directly and we'll find a solution together.
If you are decided to join as a Reviewr please submit a group request on the Steam Page and I'll accept it :)
Comment has been collapsed.
This is a really good idea! I like how everything is detailed.
I'd like to join as a reviewer, possibly a full member later on if I have enough games to share.
Just to clarify, I don't need to review a game unless I win it in the group, right? Asking because I have a few games I'm working through atm.
Comment has been collapsed.
Hello and thank you!
We'd love to have you! Please submit a request to join the Group and I'll accept it :)
And yes, that is correct. You can be part of the Group, but you are not required to create or enter giveaways. You enter only when you are sure you have time for it.
Comment has been collapsed.
Whoa!! To be a gaming journalist was my dream from the very first moment I've read some gaming magazine IRL!
I'd like to contribute as the REVIEWER and EDITOR (I can translate from russian and/or ukrainian, my native languages).
Also I have a couple of questions:
Thanks in a advance!!
Comment has been collapsed.
Hello and thanks for the support!
is the reviews must be ONLY for games given away here or can I review any other game too (have completed around 1300 games on many platforms by this time, so I have some material already, at least conceptually)?
Only for the Group Giveaways.
is this magazine interested ONLY in new games??
No. Actually quite the opposite. We'll review all kind of games, old, new, indies, big AAA titles, bad or good... doesn't matter.
is someone interested in the mobile gaming of the past years (Java/J2ME)? I've completed many of those (600+).
Haven't considered that yet, but if someone like yourself is interested in handling a review section specliazed on mobile games, we could add in future issues. For now we want to settle with basic reviews and take it from there.
Send a group request and I'll add you the the Members List as both Reviewer and Editor :)
Comment has been collapsed.
Aw man, I wish people talked more about java games!! Esp. the ports, they're all so interesting? At least to me, I just love the fact that there was a mobile Assassin's creed port and it was a platformer, which, I mean, makes sense, but still! Very cool! And the sims games very pretty unique. I love talking about them and I'd love to hear about them, too.
Comment has been collapsed.
Well, those weren't the actual "ports", more like "mobile versions" of the same properties, but yeah, I can understand you))
And I'm glad that there're at least someone who still likes this thing beside me^^
Comment has been collapsed.
Hi, I'd like to be a reviewer. It is very interesdting project, I wish you luck!
Comment has been collapsed.
Hi!
Please request to join the Group on the Steam Page and I'll add you to the members list :)
Comment has been collapsed.
Hi! I love this idea. I'd like to join as a reviewer, given I more or less have some experience since I started my own game review blog a while ago, but I have a question. Are the games in the giveaways the only ones that will be reviewed or, if I were to make it as a reviewer, could I sugest and submit a review of a different game?
Comment has been collapsed.
Hello and thank you for the interest!
You can request to join the group and I will add you to the Members List as a Reviewer.
And to answer your question. Yes, only the Group Giveaways will be published in the Magazine.
Comment has been collapsed.
Hello and thank you!
Request to join the Group and I will add you to the Members List as a Reviewer :)
Comment has been collapsed.
Hello and thanks!
Request to join the Group and I will add you :)
Comment has been collapsed.
Hello and thank you for the support! :)
I haven't considered a mailing list system, but if there is a demand for it, we could implement it. The magazine will be published on SG, and we'll create a separate post for each issue, where readers can comment. Then the link to that post will be added here, to the Central Hub. So this way the old and current issues will be easily available for anyone to check.
Comment has been collapsed.
30 Comments - Last post 1 hour ago by brivid0boy
450 Comments - Last post 1 hour ago by klingki
7 Comments - Last post 6 hours ago by xXSAFOXx
16,297 Comments - Last post 7 hours ago by SebastianCrenshaw
52 Comments - Last post 8 hours ago by adam1224
206 Comments - Last post 11 hours ago by Joey2741
31 Comments - Last post 12 hours ago by Pika8
282 Comments - Last post 23 minutes ago by IgotElbows
202 Comments - Last post 28 minutes ago by xkingpin
45 Comments - Last post 37 minutes ago by DarkRainX
7,979 Comments - Last post 38 minutes ago by eeev
137 Comments - Last post 51 minutes ago by TheAgonist00
46 Comments - Last post 51 minutes ago by Shanti
22 Comments - Last post 52 minutes ago by UnknownDepth
Hello and Welcome to the central hub of SteamGifts Magazine!
The SG Community's own digital monthly gaming magazine in which ANYONE can join for a chance to win a game and review it, putting down their thoughts on "digital paper" for the whole community to read! Each submitted review will be published.
Steam Group Rules and Member Roles
Please make sure you have read and understood the rules for each role before requesting to join the Group:
Reviewer - As a reviewer you can enter the Group's giveaways for a chance to win games and review them.
The Rules:
1) Before entering giveaways, make sure you check the deadline assigned to them. Enter only if you truly believe that you can play and review the game in that timeframe. The deadline varies depending on game size and length, from 3 weeks up to a maximum of 8 weeks!
In case you cannot reach the expected deadline, you can request additional days in order to finish. A maximum of 5 additional days can be requested!
Not all games will require completion in order to be reviewed. Sport games, racing games, simulators or other type of "sandbox" games can be reviewed if a minimum required number of hours is met (that number will be decided separately).
Story based games on the hand, need to be finished before submitting the review!
2) Each Reviewer can enter any group giveaway until they win a game. After that point, the Reviewer is forbidden to enter additional giveaways unless they have played, reviewed, and submitted the review from the previously won giveaway.
3) There will be two giveaway 'waves' per month. Each wave will feature up to 15 giveaways.
4) In case you win multiple giveaways, you'll have to pick the game that you want to play and review the most, and then accept to re-roll the other game/s that you've won. This way everyone has a higher winning chance and you will be able to better focus on the review.
5) You’re not a professional game reviewer. We get that. Nobody is asking you to be one, but if you took upon yourself this task, you should at least try your best. We don’t want to stress you about creating the perfect review. But on the other hand, please respect the Magazine and the Group. Each review should be at least 1-2 pages long for smaller games, and 2-6 pages for bigger titles.
One page is measured in 400 words – font Calibri – size 11
Don’t worry if English isn’t your first language. It isn’t for most of us. I will correct mistakes the best I can before publishing it. Editors will help as well.
We also encourage a lighthearted approach in writing the review. Don’t take yourself too serious! Add some personal stories to make the reader feel more empathic towards you, rant about certain aspects of the game if you feel like it, make jokes, damn.. even add memes if you want to. The point is… be original. This is YOUR review. Pretend you’re explaining the game to your childhood's best friend. The reader is that friend :)
6) Do not try to copy/paste reviews from other sources. Stealing from others isn’t cool. And if caught you’ll be blacklisted. We want the authentic YOU!
7) The only “mandatory” review format is the game scoring. At the end of the review, you’ll have to score it accordingly to the magazine’s format.
8) As you play the game, you’ll be required to take and submit at least 5 in game screenshots, with small descriptions on what you were doing or trying to capture. These screenshots will be added in the magazine.
9) Some games might be too difficult to beat. Maybe you're stuck on a level? Or maybe the game is a mess filled with bugs that stops you from finishing it. If that's the case and you REALLY tried your best, but just couldn't move past a certain point, let us know in the Group. We can find a solution together.
10) The usage of any type of AI software or tool to write reviews or paragraphs from the review is strictly forbidden. We have an AI detection tool that we use on each submitted review, and it is highly effective, accurately identifying AI-generated content 9 out of 10 times.
If you are caught with 2 or less AI-generated paragraphs, you will receive a warning and lose your Premium membership (if you have one). If you are caught with more than 2 AI-generated paragraphs, you will be banned.
11) If you win a game, you have 7 days to redeem the key/gift and mark the game as received. Falling to do so will get you blacklisted.
12) Have a positive and friendly attitude.
Contributor – As a contributor you can support the Group with game giveaways (maximum of 4 per month). A game which will be reviewed by the winner and published in the magazine.
The Rules:
1) You’ll have to ask for permission before creating a Group giveaway. Via direct messaging me or requesting it in the dedicated post "Contributor's Dropxbox" in the Group Forum. The reason behind that is mostly because we’ll need to coordinate with the other giveaways. Also, no repeats of previous games.
2) There is going to be a limit of 4 giveaways per month (for the first few issues) and then, at a later date, the limit is going to be restricted to only 2 giveaway per month. The reason for that is because I want multiple members to participate on both sides. As a reviewer and a contributor. And since we can’t have too many giveaways going on at the same time, we need to limit the amount you can contribute.
3) Contributors will have a special "Thank You" section reserved in the magazine..
4) As a contributor you need to accept the fact that there is a small chance that some of your giveaways won't get to 5 entries. That means you will not receive any contributor points on SteamGifts.
5) Have a positive and friendly attitude.
Full Member – As a FM you’ll be able to contribute games for others to participate in, and you will also have access to other members giveaways for the purpose of playing & reviewing them.
Editor - As an editor, your task is to help us "tidy up" the reviews before we publish them in the Magazine. That means correcting any grammar mistakes you can find, making sure that the reviewer's ideas are well translated and interpreted into text. This is a vital role, as it will dictate the overall quality of the reviews and Magazine.
Moderator - Forum moderators will help with certain activities on the Steam Group Page. Making sure everyone is on their best behavior :)
Okay, now onto the Magazine..
Magazine Format
So far, this is very much up for debate. Everything you’ll see listed here are my own suggestions. By the time the magazine will be completed, many things will be changed or entirely new sections will be added.
• TEAM OF THE MONTH section, in which the editors and all reviewers will be listed, alongside their games (and the page # in which the reader can find that specific review).
• GAME GIVEAWAY section for the readers. Each issue will have a page dedicated to a game that is being given away through link invitation. The game will have a small review on it’s own. The giveaway will end on the last day of the month, right before the next issue is published. There might be multiple copies of the game in the same giveaway so more readers get a chance at it.
• SPECIAL section for different kind of articles related to gaming.
• NEWS section for gaming news.
• HANDS-ON REVIEW for games contributed by developers. If any indie game developers want to advertise their game and are looking for a honest review. (This might not be available in the first issue).
• REVIEWS section.
• COVER GAME REVIEW section, is going to be the “big” or “main” review. Which shall be the longest and most detailed (also the bigger game of them all).
• SCREENSHOT OF THE MONTH section, in which ALL SteamGifts members can submit their favourite screenshot from any game. Only 3 will be selected for publication. 3rd place, 2nd place and the winner. (don't know yet where they should submit the photos)
• FREE2PLAY GAME OF THE MONTH section, in which we’ll feature a Steam game that is free to play.
• HYPE section, in which we list a few upcoming releases that we’re hyped for.
• CONTRIBUTOR “Thank You” section in which all members that contributed with games will be mentioned. Each of them having a quote underneath the game they’ve gifted.
• And more… (if you have any suggestion, please share!)
The Rating System
I decided against using a conventional 10 digits or percentage scoring method.
Instead, the rating system for each game will be the following:
Story – Based on overall storyline, sidequests, environment, characters and dialogue.
Graphics – Based on overall graphics capabilities, visual effects and how well they hold up (for older games).
Sound – Based on sound effects, music and voice acting.
Gameplay – Based on gameplay mechanics, fluidity of the game, learning curve and engine stability.
Fun Meter – Based on originality and how much you’ve enjoyed playing it.
For EACH of these categories you need to assign a number of stars.
⭐ - horrible
⭐ ⭐ - poor
⭐ ⭐ ⭐ - good
⭐ ⭐ ⭐ ⭐ - very good
⭐ ⭐ ⭐ ⭐ ⭐ - perfect
Besides the star system, we’ll also use a “VERDICT” section in which you can list up to 5 positives and 5 negatives of the game.
In the end, the reviewer will have to choose between “Approved” or “Rejected” on the “Seal of Recommendation”.
List of Reviews in Progress here
List of available Games (Wave 12 - Limited "Lost & Found" Wave):
Finished reviews can be submitted directly to staff member via Discord or Steam. Just message any of us and we'll take it from there.
How to Join the Group?
If you've read the rules and want to be part of the team, please leave a comment here with your desired role, then request to join here
Join our Discord..
if you want to say hi or submit your game screenshot for the "Screenshot of the Month" contest.
Screenshot of the Month
You have a cool, artistic or funny game screenshot that you want to share with us? Then submit it to us on Discord in the submission channel!
At the end of each month we're going to set up a vote poll for the best submission. The winner will be added in the Magazine's "Screenshot of the Month" section!
Submit your favourite screenshot on our Discord channel or on the Steam Group Page here.
Additional Info
After the first issue is released, we’ll have a monthly vote on “best review”, which will grant the winner the option to chose from 3 games. The won game can be reviewed for the next month's issue, but it is not mandatory.
Magazine Index
edit: Please comment here, or on Discord, your desired Group role before submitting a request to join. We have received many requests with no info attached. WE CANNOT ACCEPT THEM unless you specify your desired role first!
Comment has been collapsed.