Horror games

The only horror games that have truly scared me were the cancelled Project PT, and the first Resident Evil game for Playstation, but that one only scared me because someone broke into my house while i was fighting the last boss at the rooftop. I havent touched that game again since then

I take everything head on kill anything that move into blow in smithereens lol

most horror games i play at 2 3 times the game speed, not a fan of the genre
no such thing as a jump scare when its so fast you have no idea wtf happened and the audio doesnt always match up OR its twice/thrice as fast
played both state of decays at normal speed as i actually enjoyed them

Ive only actually only played 2 horror games. Fobia and Monstrum. I won them both from SG. Monstrum was Trash in every way possible, i dont know how else to describe it.
Fobia, on the other hand was fantastic. I dont recall what all i liked about it...But I do remember the atmosphere they'd build up, the lore, narrative...it all swooped me in. It did have its flaws, but i still found the time played to be a worthwhile experience.

Edit:
huh interesting. Looks like i played it almost exactly an year ago! And I played Monstrum a month prior, looks like I really hated it. Maybe the transition between these games, made my experience of Fobia even sweeter.