What Game Should I Play Next?

Bastion or The Stanley Parable
EDIT: I'd choose Stanley Parable.
Dunno why I replied to my own comment instead of editing this one... I'm tired ._.

• Witcher 2
• Mount & Blade: With Fire and Sword
• Oblivion
• MKX
• Shadow of Mordor
• Insurgency
• Killing Floor 2

Personally I'd play a few rounds of The Binding of Isaac. :)

Broforce or Victoria 2.

Deponia Doomsday
Broken Age
The Witcher 2
Hotline Miami 2: Wrong Number
Trine 2

The Banner Saga. Has unique flavor and not very long.

Bad Company 2, Dragon Age Origins, Men of War 2, Wasteland 2, Shadowrun, Banner Saga, Witcher, Total War, Stanley Parable, Elder Scrolls... you actually have a lot of good games IMO, so it's kinda hard to pinpoint one in particular.

Quite a few good games... what about Evoland 2 (afaik not linked to 1st), Pony Island or Broforce

Don't Starve, it has the potential to be played for hundred of hours!
Same goes for The Binding of Isaac: Rebirth.
Two more suggestions from me would be The Swapper and Rogue Legacy.

Mass Effect 2 is awesome (still good, played it recently), a good time to get into the game in anticipation of the next part releasing soon, get this to improve the fov : https://hamstergene.github.io/post/fixing-mass-effect-fov/

Dragon Age, Wasteland 2 and Grim Dawn are also great.

Oxenfree, The Banner Saga and The Witcher 1-2.

Hmmm....quite a few sequels without the original game.

Do you have a game pad for your PC?

Bastion
Castle Crashers

No?

Age of Empires.

In no particular order, I'd go with one of these, but you might like something else:

Trine 2
Dead Space 2
Victor Vran
Middle-earth: Shadow of Mordor
Mass Effect 2
The Stanley Parable
The Incredible Adventures of Van Helsing: Final Cut
The Witcher 2: Assassins of Kings Enhanced Edition
Dragon Age: Origins

Pony Island, obviously!

Bad Rats, of course!

I dont wanna waste my time with going through your library but im gonna suggest Unravel. its an ea acess which is free for a week on origin.

you didn't pass the 400 hours in fallout 4 so you can keep playing it 💜

victor vran and van helsing if you like diablo/torchlight
witcher 1 and 2, then get 3
oblivion and skyrim
shadowrun dragonfall and hong kong

party hard for next weekend. you wont need that much time.
and finish the swapper. it's weird but awesome. just like me! or so i was told...

http://pickaga.me/

The Binding of Isaac: Rebirth or Wasteland 2DC.
...
...
How come you haven't tried Grim Dawn? :O It's great <3

Yikes, my most played game rests with 0 hours in your library. Play Crusader Kings 2!

if you have a controller i found mortal kombat x (or xl) to be quite fun. it ran like crap for everyone before the XL update, so that's why it's poorly rated, but it's actually quite good now.

Bastion or Oxenfree if you like story games

1. Chroma Squad: Playing it myself right now. It's quite good and if you grew up with Power Rangers and such shows on tv it really manages to trigger the nostalgia factor.
2. Mass Effect 2: Second part of a great trilogy. If you don't have the first one on some other platform(drm-free, origin etc) I suggest you get it and start playing the whole trilogy. Great worldbuilding, amazing cast of characters, immersive story. 100% in my top5 franchises
3. The Banner Saga. Simple enough SRPG with amazing artwork and an interesting story.