Story: sad and disturbing, but still nice. I liked framing device revealed at the end - protagonist took poison during first lines and waits for it to take effect while retelling events leading to this tragedy. Story starts somewhat weak - at first I thought it's going to be about high school romance, wasn't expecting medieval nobles and peasants. However this also made the death of the girl and "red wedding" even more shocking - don't know if it was the writer's intent from the beginning.
Graphics: Images are nothing special - only five simple pencil drawings. I never wanted to close the program to avoid looking at them so they're good enough. Choice of font is questionable - it fits with overall pencil sketch style, but hard to read. Main menu and settings are just bad design - extremely hard to see light grey items on white background.
Sound: There aren't any. Could be better with some sad tune playing, though.
Comment has been collapsed.
I think it was intentional; To write such a plot twist at the end without creating plot holes is something hard to do,even with short stories. I agree with all your points except the music - a sad music throughout all the game would've ruined the surprise. Music throughout the whole game,if good,could've enhanced it; But this was never meant to be a full visual novel,rather a test for the writer's ability to make them; More than 3 years after release it has less than 600 downloads in total,so the fact it hasn't been revised is acceptable.
Comment has been collapsed.
Thank you, i'll be playing it soon.
I would love to see more of these kind of posts!
Comment has been collapsed.
downloaded it ~ but for now.. i really have this itch to shoot some cops in the face.. with a shotgun.. while making meth... so hopefully ill get back to it and leave some actual feedback.
Comment has been collapsed.
alright. finshed it. ive always had a thing for plot twists like that .. didnt like the beginning because i thought it would be some kind of lovey dovey romance thing i would see in anime but it got better and in general i liked it with its dark vengence/justification of love ending
one of the dislikes would have to be the font.. i just didnt prefer the font and made it just a tad difficult
oh and didnt expect it to be that short . but thx for letting try something different and nice tonight .
Comment has been collapsed.
I think that the font looks nice,but I agree that it makes it somewhat difficult to read,which is critical in a visual novel.
As for length,I think that there was space to expand the story without making it too slow,but not too much. Perhaps another 300 words or so,more than that and it would require adding stuff that isn't currently in. This is one of the shorter visual novels indeed,and I plan to do some more lengthy ones in the future.
Comment has been collapsed.
Thanks for taking the time to write all the stuff that you do, you are really dedicated.
Comment has been collapsed.
I appreciate your thanks,but the best thanks I can get is in the form of a comment saying that someone enjoyed my suggestion(as so far it seems like only 1 person did). I'm uncomfortable with being called dedicated for doing this - it isn't something that took me more than a couple of hours to write,I did it because I had tons of free time,and this is only the second post regarding visual novels I've made.
Comment has been collapsed.
The game is really short. Graphic is very minimal, just some sketch without any coloring. No music and voice acting.
SPOILER
Tragic story is okay, still some of it doesn't make sense. Why MC didn't ask for a doctor when Celeste in such pain? It's obvious something wrong with her health. Instead just by her side he should be searching for medical help. He have 40 minutes, plenty of times. Noble family should have at least a family doctor. What I mean is the event where Celeste dying is too simple.
Also the event when MC take his revenge could be elaborate more. How exactly he carry his plan, all by himself? Did he really slain everyone, all his family? Why? I mean, the only jerk is his father. Can't he just eliminate his father, took over his family and start a grand campaign to conquer the world?
Overall it's okay game, it's simple but that's to be expected.
Comment has been collapsed.
40 Minutes to Eternity revisited.
Feeling the need to update my impressions after playing newer version of this novel.
First of all, now it has music and graphics, which is great. After all, visual novels should enhance story with sound and images, not just read in silence like ordinary books. Character portarits are not on a pro level, but at least they are in color now – step forward compared with pencil scetches. Backgrounds are some stock images and there is nothing wrong with that. Music choice is quite appropriate, tracks fit the story mood well.
I liked how story was extended, new characters introduced and old received some personality and motivations - there were very little personality and motivations in early version. Now it’s clear from the beginning that this is not another modern high school romance. I liked how court intrigues were added to story in addition to class struggle. Protagonist became much more likeable, because now he kills only his father, who deserved it, instead of murdering both his own family and family of his arranged wife in early version.
But with extended script came many plot holes.
It’s said that Aidan’s father raped the queen – how he managed to do that? I thought queen supposed to live in palace with lots of guards and servants and it would be easy for her to prevent any unwelcome advances or at least have him executed afterwards.
After that Aidan’s father and Aidan himself are said to have claims on the throne. How’s that? Either their country has really weird matrimonial-raping inheritance laws or the father was the king’s relative, but there was no mention of this.
I didn’t feel any empathy to Clair and found her boring compared to mischievous Victoria. Her and Aidan’s written messages exchange started to look hilarious when I imagined how they were sitting under the rain writing long and carefully worded love letters then waiting 30 minutes for other to answer with same. There was even a line in the novel how Aidan kneeled before Claire for what felt to him like eternity while she wrote her answer – no less than two pages of text. Also, Claire belongs in Katawa Shoujo.
Aidan’s final confrontation with father was rather disappointing. If it was some other game genre, I would call it anticlimatic. The father brags that he was watching Aidan and that Aidan can’t kill him, then Aidan reveals that he learned father’s only weakness… to being shot with pistol! Bang!
In conclusion, i liked newer version much better and even found some comedy in this tragedy.
Comment has been collapsed.
I'll say again that I'm sorry for linking to the wrong version,and that it took me so much time to find out; But if you look at older comments,none of them suggested that anything was wrong..
Oh well,no point in being sad about it.
I see what you mean when you say that Claire is a shallow character,but I don't think it really has a big impact this way or the other since she's more of a support character who serves as something to progress the plot and to enhance Aidan's character. She would blend in easily with Hanako and Lily..
For the plot hole you found,I think it's explainable if you include the fact that it was never said that he raped the queen,only that he raped various other women. If you also notice that he loved her and that she "chose her husband over him" you can guess that they had a real,secret relationship that she chose to end when she got pregnant.
Imo the ending wasn't bad at all. It was unexpected,you can give it that at least; Perhaps you found the way Aidan just kind of said "I've got a gun. Whatch'a gonna do?" anticlimatic,but what exactly did you expect? That he'd put some glue on the chair beforehand,then shoot the chandelier to make it fall on him,and then make out with Victoria in front of him as he bleeds to death?
Comment has been collapsed.
33 Comments - Last post 26 minutes ago by Gamy7
4 Comments - Last post 35 minutes ago by despiesi96
40 Comments - Last post 45 minutes ago by Chris76de
1,962 Comments - Last post 2 hours ago by MeguminShiro
15 Comments - Last post 3 hours ago by dingbat
21 Comments - Last post 4 hours ago by Mitsukuni
161 Comments - Last post 7 hours ago by wigglenose
59 Comments - Last post 1 minute ago by Masafor
33 Comments - Last post 9 minutes ago by Yamaraus
45 Comments - Last post 21 minutes ago by carefree
32 Comments - Last post 22 minutes ago by dowsky
50 Comments - Last post 24 minutes ago by IgnatiusPeabodyNobel
28,507 Comments - Last post 25 minutes ago by Yamaraus
141 Comments - Last post 36 minutes ago by ConanOLion
I decided to make a weekly post about one visual novel at a time that I found to be interesting. This is intended for people who'd like to try visual novels lightly in their spare time,as well as for people who like visual novels and would like unpopular recommendations. Before this turns into a rather not so small wall of text,here it is:
40 Minutes to Eternity
Compatibility: Win,Mac,Linux.
Plot type: Linear.
Ending type: Single ending.
Length estimation: About 11000 words.
Graphics: Simple,but not ugly.
Voice acting: None.
Engine: Renpy.
Source: Lemma Soft
In a nutshell: "I feel like a product being sold".
Download(~50 MB): Win Mac Linux
When you finish playing,please comment your thoughts on it. Did you find it boring? lacking something? too short? This will allow me to give better recommendations in the future,and create a discussion about the game.
Special thanks to Rinarin for being the inspiration to this post.
FAQ:
1.What is this?
2.What do you mean by hopefully weekly?
3.What was wrong with your old thread?
4.Can I suggest a game?
Next spotlight
Comment has been collapsed.