Does this sound like a good idea to you?
The result would be no different than what we have now. Just because the winner has seen the key doesn't mean it's usable.
Comment has been collapsed.
yes. SC uses it. until better solution to stop abuse completely is found this is the best solution..
how about another button to reject key so that giveaway will auto-reroll ?
automatically removing entry from giveaways of won games..
why...why big thought was gone into statement in "No" option ..
you can't make fries from kumquats.
Comment has been collapsed.
Is the "Accept Key" button an addition to the current system or will it replace the GA creator's "Show Key" button?
An addition would be fine, but IMHO the GA creator should still have the option to "take a closer look" at the winners profile before making the key accessible.
Comment has been collapsed.
This is an addition to the current system. The creator still has the toggle of showing/hiding the key.
Comment has been collapsed.
That would be great actually! With steamgifts games it's easy to know if someone actually got your game even if they don't install it.
With keys they could just take it and activate the game in another account and then say the key was not working -_-
Comment has been collapsed.
Good Idea Bump™
Game | Free Key |
---|---|
Exteria |
Comment has been collapsed.
Duplicate, but thanks. ;P And he's a support member, so he should be able to implement his own suggestions. :/
Comment has been collapsed.
I said "they should be able", not that "they are able". :P
Comment has been collapsed.
you necrofile threading you
but yeah, still a good idea
how's the icrecream diet going?
Comment has been collapsed.
I wanted to make a suggestion, but I think I'll just add it here. It's an alternate mechanism. Note that I haven't won a game on SG2, and have no idea how keys are delivered, but I hope I'm on the mark.
The idea: Show only one key to the user at a time. They can mark it as 'activated' or 'bad key' and only then move on to see the key for the next game won. If a user marked a key as activated and won other keys of the same game, these giveaways could be automatically rerolled.
This can still be abused, but will reduce honest mistakes and provide a better way to track incidents of bad keys or abuse (marking 'bad key' to accept multiple wins) or highlight them automatically for support.
I think that would enforce good behaviour better than an 'accept key' button.
Comment has been collapsed.
The idea: Show only one key to the user at a time.
Implementing an "Accept Key" button would accomplish this. I don't see how you can activate the button to reveal the key for more than one giveaway at a time except by using a script, and that would be pointless since you aren't going to be looking at more than one web page at a time.
Comment has been collapsed.
Given that I have no idea how giveaways are accepted, it's possible that there's a very small difference.
However, I would assume that seeing a key could not be used automatically to disable other wins for the same game, because it's possible that the key isn't valid. So either such wins are disabled and the legitimate winner might suffer, or more than one of the same game can be legitimately clicked by the user.
On the other hand if a user needs to mark the key as activated or invalid, then marking a key as activated is a clear indication that other wins for the game can be rerolled.
Also having the ability of marking a key as invalid is useful.
This is not a huge difference, but it does make things clearer to the user, and forces the user to lie in order to cheat. The user can't claim to have just misunderstood.
Reducing misunderstanding is something that's very helpful. I know that it kind of goes against the SG philosophy of making things as obscure as possible and then berating users for not reading the FAQ, but one can hope that this attitude will change one of these days.
Comment has been collapsed.
8 Comments - Last post 33 minutes ago by Stakaniy
2 Comments - Last post 2 hours ago by Lprn
540 Comments - Last post 3 hours ago by Ledyba
15 Comments - Last post 3 hours ago by SecOps
1,763 Comments - Last post 3 hours ago by MeguminShiro
47,106 Comments - Last post 4 hours ago by kbronct
49 Comments - Last post 4 hours ago by blueflame32
791 Comments - Last post 15 minutes ago by thed4rkn1te
23 Comments - Last post 24 minutes ago by Ninglor03
17 Comments - Last post 45 minutes ago by UnknownDepth
107 Comments - Last post 1 hour ago by Yamaraus
28,239 Comments - Last post 1 hour ago by ELGADO26
711 Comments - Last post 1 hour ago by OneNonLy
3,354 Comments - Last post 1 hour ago by pizurk
Current System ---
The giveaway creator is able to input a Steam key when making the giveaway. This key may be displayed to the winner of the giveaway by toggling a button to "Show Key," or hidden from the winner by toggling it to "Hide Key."
Suggestion (from UltraTaber) ---
Add a button the the winner's page called "Accept Key" which will then display the key to the winner (assuming the creator has toggled his button to "Show Key"). This is a one-time event, independent of the creator's toggle, and once triggered, cannot be undone. Once the button is pressed, it will be known that the key has been seen and possibly used by the winner.
Benefits ---
Drawbacks ---
Comment has been collapsed.