Walking Dead - What would you have done if you were Carol?

As harsh as it sounds, she needed to be put down. Without the right medication, and there's no real way they could have got the right ones for her, it was only a matter of time until she did it again. She was already prepared to do Lil Asskicker

Instead of waiting to talk to Tyreese about the situation, the girl should have been shot in the face the second she handed the gun over. No talking would have been involved.

They could just leave her behind without killing her.

I actually wanted her to live so when the gang meets up somewhere or the terminus, carl would've killed Lizzie once he learned that she tried to kill judith.

Same stuff, Lizzie was crazy.

Probably the same thing there was really nothing else they could do.

I also loved the moment at the start of the episode when she was playing with the walker, I thought it was a flashback, and that was her mother back at the early days.

Would've killed her the second I saw what she did to her sister, before she even had the chance to pull the gun... she was too fucked up in the head for any other resolution.

I would have ate them all.

Wait.. why is that always my first thought?

I would definitely have killed her. There's no going back from what she did, and I'm not sleeping knowing she's close by. It was a surprising episode, and on the whole, not bad. Now please kill the singing girl before the end of the season and I will worship the series.