Deleted

FNAF is actually alright. It's Slender that I really didn't get.

What I really hate are the stupid games that are trying to be funny... I mean:
Goat Sim (Totally stupid and buggy, not funny at all)
Surgeon Sim (Fun for 15 minutes, then just stupid...)
I am bread (Nothing else to say I guess)
Garrys Mod (Looks like it might be fun but when I tried to play it... stupid and buggy!)
Rock of Ages (Not so bad but still, it tries to be funny and its not)

But also games that are not trying to be stupid but are not even fun:
The Binding of Isaac
Gone Home
Kerbal: Space Program

To The Moon.

Five Nights at Freddy's 3 (I liked the other 3, but FNaF 3 was just like your average ripoff on gamejolt)
Terraria (Honestly I don't see why people have over 50 hours in this game)
Every "Simulator" game ever (Gets milked by Pewdiepie, plus all of them are created by russians who don't know how to make games)
Minecraft (Go to the "Gaming" tab on YouTube. Tis all)
Braid (Mindnumbingly boring puzzles and the ending is why everyone likes this game anyway)

Now here's a twist:
Top 5 underrated indie games

Tiny and Big: Grandpa's Leftovers (A 3D puzzle game that is filled with humor and large enviroments scattered with collectables)
Don't Starve (This game was talked for about for a month and then everyone seemed to forget about it, such a shame)
Chucks Challenge 3D (Another 3D puzzler that was created by the man who conceived Chip's Challenge, another game you probably haven't heard of)
McPixel (An puzzler that's- oh you get it)
Bad Rats (Nah JK)

Braid
Thomas was alone
Bastion

Edit:Forgot Hotline Miami.

I did enjoy Bastion though. Fun to play but the whole "OMFGNARRATORISDABESTFEAUREEVARGAMEOFDAYEAR" was uncalled for.

Samorost 2
9.03m
Gone Home
Canabalt
McPixel

La-Mulana.

Personally, the worst game I've played on Steam.

Day Z
Rust
Goat Simulator
five 5 night series
minecraft

Every game that has the word simulator in its name.

Superbrothers: Sword and Sorcery (bad game)
Pid (not bad but still overrated)
Fez (good but overrated by critics)
Five Nights
Toki Tori, if that's indie

Swords & Sworcery : Superbrother EP... or whatever the full title is.
I can't believe how misled I was by the trailer, much less how people were fangasming over it despite being a mobile game that utterly lacks in gameplay AND any form of engrossing story. Sure some of the music is cool, but that doesn't really make the game good nor any less cripplingly pretentious. If anything I believe the game was made as an afterthought to go with the music.

Also Braid. I completed that, the entire time "waiting for it to get good". It never did.
And then the ending sucked ass.
And then I realised what the ending / game was even about, and it sucked so much ass it turned into an ass singularity.

FEZ, it's not a bad game, but with all the hype I expected more.
Binding of Isaac: I tried to like it... but even before 10h I got more and more bored.
Superbrothers: Sword & Sworcery EP: Was very boring to me.

The Binding of Isaac
zelda.look a like now is overhyped :imo:

Goat Simulator. Horrible "game"... (>_<)

The Stanley Parable

And I like existential musings, but even though I found several of the endings I finally concluded my time was better spent elsewhere.

To The Moon. The story isn't all that great to be frank :/.

Minecraft
Garry's Mod
FNAF (any of these)
Walking simulator #4625463456 (Gone Home, Dear Esther, etc)
Zombie survival crafting blah blah game (DayZ, H1Z1, etc)