Hey, i started ding giveaways here less than two days ago. The reason i wanted to do giveaways is because i'm sorta wealthy and want to make someone's day by giving them an awesome game they may not be able to get since they dont have enough money or something like that. I really love the feeling of making someone happy that way. The "problem" came when someone won my giveaway, and he had more than 200 steam games (havent played over half of them) and won A LOT of giveaways in here. That sorta feels like giving $100 to bill gates. And it dosent make it any better when the giveaway has more that 3 pages of tankful commenters, plenty with a little story about how much they want this game and why. Im just pretty annoyed, since it feels like my thoughtful move is a big waste.

I would like to hear your thoughts about this.

10 years ago*

Comment has been collapsed.

Well you are assuming just because people have high game count, they are wealthy and don't need free games but you have to consider somethings. Situations can change, someone might have had a steady job and he used to buy a lot of games but now what if he doesn't? Also with the new addition of bundles, it's not all that difficult to rack up game count. As for not playing, they might not have the time to play every game they own. Your situation is subjective, since you are the one giving the games away, it depends on what you feel but I feel it's unfair if someone wins a giveaway and don't get the game.

As others have suggested, you can create private groups with restrictions, such as how many games they can own, how much % they must play etc. There are groups like this (for example a group for the unlucky only takes people who never won, and kick the member after their first win etc).

Ultimately, since you are the one giving away the games, you can decide what type of people you want to win your game. But I don't think you can put that type of restriction on public giveaways (you need the support's permission for that). But you can make a group for it and/or make private giveaway and re roll if the winner doesn't meet the requirements.

10 years ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

1: your logicmakes no sense, if they have say like... 200 games im sure theres A LOT of games they can play before they "need" more.

10 years ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

OK here is the thing the way I see it:

You make giving a game here sound like charity where you feel those who 'need' the game should get it. I see it as giving a gift. On special occasions for friends and family, would you think he/she has enough money to buy something, no need for me to do buy them anything? The site is all about giving games to strangers.

Your analogy with Bill Gates doesn't work here because, he is an exception and doesn't represent the majority. Unless you can tell me a sizable portion of SG is as rich as Bill Gates.

Having a lot of games on steam used to mean they can afford them but with the bundles now that's no longer a factor considering we must have had hundreds of bundles where you can get 5+ games by paying $1.

But ultimately as the creator of giveaways all this rests with you. You are free to decide who gets your games, you can set up a steam group with any rules you wish and actively recruit people who you feel fall into that category and make giveaways for them. You just can't change your mind after a person won or put that kind of rule on public giveaways.

10 years ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

If you want to give games to people who "need" them try childsplaycharity.org

10 years ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

Lots of people have already responded with lots of good information. I'll just try to summarize it in brief.

1) Private and group giveaways allow you to restrict entry in any manner you wish, subject to mod approval.
2) Public giveaways are open to everyone, even the guy who doesn't want the game but enters anyway.
3) In the end, it's all random. Just be glad you could bring some joy into others' lives, even if they didn't win.

Some of the restrictions put on private and/or group giveaways include:

  • Membership in a particular group or groups.
  • CV amount (either above or below a set limit).
  • Number of wins (above or below a set limit).
  • Time spent on SteamGifts (usually by # of months).
  • Entry by special invite only.

An example of the last type was the "Not Your Giveaway" giveaway, where the only people who could enter were those who were nominated by others. (You couldn't enter yourself.) I hope all of the suggestions you're getting help you find the manner in which you wish to give.

10 years ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

I always worry that people are going to think that when I win a giveaway from them. I have over 400 games on Steam, and have only played about 10 of them. That looks terrible. I actually don't have much extra money for games though, and have probably spent an average of about $0.30 per game in my library. The reason I've played so few of my games is because Steam stopped working on my computer so I couldn't play any of them until I got a new computer a few days ago, but also because I got a lot of them with Steam Family Sharing in mind.

I can't guarantee that the person who won the game from you is grateful, but I hope he/she is. I understand your concern, but don't assume that just because someone hasn't gotten to playing a lot of their games yet doesn't mean that they don't appreciate your gift.

Also, thank you for your generosity!

10 years ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

I think it would be nice if Steam Gifts allowed limiting giveaways by number of wins or date of last win. Support does accept suggestions, so going that way is a good idea, even though it guarantees nothing.

As for thanks, I don't think you should expect a lot of detailed posts. The chance of winning is very low, and I wouldn't expect anyone to make thousands of posts of why they'd like to win a game.

10 years ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

As has already been said, what you want can be done, but it requires more work and effort.

  • If you set up a group you need to go through everybody who wants in to check if they qualify, and you will have a lot of unqualified applicants.

  • If you want to make private giveaways with special rules, you will need to have those rules approved by the mods (they will approve most rules if they're not too weird or crazy) - and you will still have a lot of idiots who don't qualify enter your giveaways anyways so you need to request re-rolls.

Good luck on your quest to find worthy receivers of your generosity :)

10 years ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

This is a bundles age. I have a lot of games that I never have played and will play just because there were a part of a bundle. My limit is two interesting games in bundlo. If the bundle consists of 7 games then I have 5 never been played games.

Keep in mind that you usually do not enter GAs of games you don't wanna play. Why would you do that? And the fact you do not play the game immidiately doesn't mean you are not gonna ever play it. There are some games (like GTA 4) that I am almost afraid of start playing because I know I will love it and spend much time with it... and that's what I cannot afford.

10 years ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

On the other hand, keep in mind that many people here can afford to buy games, and they choose to buy other games over the ones given away. The games they enter for are ones they have interest in, but are nowhere near the top of their list. So the behaviour of not playing the games is an expected one.

10 years ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

The person who won my giveaway activated the games but didn't play them yet. They haven't played a game at all since October... I'm pretty sure you have to give it to them anyway unless it was a private giveaway with rules. It's kind of sad, I only gave away too small, cheap games but I hoped the person who won would actually play them and enjoy them. Ah well.

10 years ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

Deleted

This comment was deleted 4 months ago.

10 years ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

Already did that two times.

10 years ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

I like how you think Op, because the same just happened to me. If you happen to make a group, feel free to invite me as I enjoy playing as much as I enjoy gifting.

10 years ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

Make a group that only people with few games can enter and make giveaways only to that group.

10 years ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

Well, like people have said, giving away in private groups tends to earn you gratitude much more reliably.

That being said. And I am speaking from experience here. By far the best and most earnest kind of gratitude comes from public giveaways.

Public giveaways will, most of the time, get you winners that don't really care too much that they win, they won't say thanks in the giveaway, they won't say thanks when they win and more often than not they won't even play the game. There is that 1 in 20 though where you manage to get a winner that really wanted THAT game and will be extremely grateful practically playing the game before you send it. In my humble opinion getting that one winner can make up for a lot asshole winners.

EDIT: And despite what people seem to think, high CV, even 5000, doesn't guarantee any sort of gratitude. Anything 2000 or below is about the same as 0 in terms of people saying thanks/playing the game as far as my experience goes.

10 years ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

I never say thanks on the giveaway, I prefer saying it by email or through steam personally if I win. I just feel like saying the same thing over and over makes it lose all meaning.

10 years ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

And people like you are the reason why making public giveaways are so unrewarding 19 out of 20 times. :)

10 years ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

dunno why. I thank them personally and play the games. I personally just hate seeing 100 copy paste comments that are just ty, thnx, thx and other stuff like that. Unless the giveaway creator specifies that he wants people to say thanks on the comments I will not say it cuz I think its dumb but oh well. If they feel like it's such a big deal they can just reroll me for not saying thanks or blacklist me.

10 years ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

No offence to either the OP or anyone here who agreed with him but you can't expect people to have played all the games they bought or even all the games they win here. Most steam users who are not in school/highschool have huge backlogs because they simply don't have the time to play everything they own. You can't expect people to skip out on all the other stuff they have to do just to play the game they've just won from you and that does not mean they are any less thankful for it. C'mon there's even support groups around for helping people deal with this kind of thing. I'm sure everyone will get around at some point to playing everything in their library.

Sure, there are also some collectors who just want to have as many games as possible, the person you're talking about sounds like one, but i'm guessing even they are thankful in their own way for your contribution to their collection :)

10 years ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

1: They should at least play what they have before they ask for more. Otherwise, i think it is very greedy.
2: I dont wish to contribute to their collection if that's the case, im not burning €20 to raise a number by one for someone so he can show off his gigantic e-penis. If it is their goal to collect, they should be able to do it without any "help".

10 years ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

And why is that? Let's say someone has a very hard year in school, he doesn't want to get distracted for too long, so any BIG PLAYTIME game is out of question. It doiesn't mean that in 3-4 months he may have a vacation and a lot of free time to play games.

So he buy himsewlf a Skyrim on sale, knowing that he will not play it now, but when he has more free time. Does it mean he would not enjoy a short game he won on SG? He may install it and beat it before Skyrim, just because he has enough time for this particular title.

10 years ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

1: I think its a VERY small amount of the people who are in the position you are discribing.
2: 100+ unplayed games should be enough for several long vacations.

10 years ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

I never said collectors are a good thing, i dislike them as well however there's no rule against being one so like them or not they're here to stay, make your own group and make group giveaways to avoid them. I don't think you have the right to judge or to call anyone greedy here, no one is asking you to give them anything, everyone gives of their own free will to boost their contribution e-peen, have their e-peen stroked by randoms thanking them on the internet, be able to enter higher contribution value giveaways or make someone else happy.

I don't have that much money, so i am happy when i do win something regardless of weather i do have the time to play it or not, which i'v not had much of for a while now. Does that mean i should stop entering giveaways for games i want but i know i won't be able to afford any time soon? I have played, at least as much as my time allowed almost every game i'v won here, i will get around to playing them all and i only enter giveaways for games i actually want.

10 years ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

I was glad when I saw that the person who won my first giveaway got their first win there too. I knew I probably made them happy.
But judging people by games in their inventory seems a bit unjust. I, for example, have Bastion and Superbrothers on my Steam, both with 0 hours played. But I beat Bastion on my brother's account long before Steam Family Sharing, and played Superbrothers on his iPad. I have some games from bundles too, they're waiting for their time but don't interest me right now, when I don't want to distract myself with too many new things. But when I see a big game giveaway, for something that I've really wanted for some time but had no money, I enter, because, well, I know I'll not be able to buy it soon. I think many people could be in similar situation - they have some games, the small games they could afford, but without the funds for, I don't know, Skyrim or Tomb Raider.

10 years ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

A little example. You created 3 giveaways for games A, B, C.

User 1 really wants to win A, user 2 - B, user 3 - C. You probably know how this story ends: user 1 wins C, user 2 wins A, user 3 wins B.

10 years ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

Closed 10 years ago by Ranef.