Point and click recomendation and GA

charnel house trilogy is a pretty good horror point & click. i think the middle chapter didn’t really do it for me but 1 and 3 still made it worth it.

I noticed, you don't have Haunted. It's currently in that Fanatical Dollar bundle, so it shouldn't be too hard to get, trade (or even win here). I got it with some other bundle before and I really liked the story and the concept of that game.

I'm not huge into Point and Clicks but I really enjoyed these games. Sorry if you already played them or they don't fit the categories you were looking for!

• Fran Bow: (tag: Horror) It's like a darker version of Alice in Wonderland. It has an interesting mechanic and the puzzles aren't outrageous. I will say the beginning is the best part because it falls apart towards the middle a little and the ending I just didn't like. It's still one of my favorites though because it's pretty unique.
• The Cat Lady: (tag: Horror) It takes a while to get going but once you get into it, this is one of the creepiest and darkest games in my library. Good characters, dark themes, twisty and compelling story, etc. If you want a horror p&c game but you haven't played The Cat Lady, then I definitely recommend this one!
• Kentucky Route Zero: (tag: Mystery) This one isn't really a puzzle point and click game and there is no inventory (if I remember correctly, it's been a long while.) but you do click to move. It's just an interesting game with nice dialogue and atmosphere. Worth playing even though its taking years for the last episode to come out.
• Richard & Alice: (tag: Mystery) a dark and desolate tale of two people who meet while locked up during a apocalyptic snow. It has good story-telling and characters and is worth a check out.
• The Silent Age: (tag: Mystery) This is a time travel P&C that is surprisingly well done. Not much to say about it but you'll most likely feel satisfied when you finish it.

Runner Ups! (don't have a horror or mystery tag but are still good and still have mystery to them)

• Edna and Harvey: Harvey's New Eyes: I didn't really like the first Edna and Harvey (plus it's full of bugs) but the sequel can be played on it's own and it's much much better. Filled with dark humor and an interesting story, I think this one is a must play if you haven't already. It is much more of a comedy then a mystery
• The Last Time: This is a tiny little game but it's worth playing. It has a little mystery story in it, but the point and click puzzles are insanely easy.

Games in my library with horror or mystery tags but I've never played them so I don't know if they are good :P

• Agatha Christie - ABC Murders (Mystery)
• Broken Sword 5 - the Serpent's Curse (Mystery)
• Cognition: An Erica Reed Thriller (Mystery)
• Black Sails (Horror)

blackwell

All of the above and these classics:

Gabriel Knight series
Kings Quest series
Zork

point n click games:
gabriel knight sins of the fathers
timbleweed park
interactive adventures of dog mendonca and pizzaboy
secret files series
broken sword series
black mirror series
kentucky route zero
yesterday
the room

adventures:
fahrenheit indigo prophecy
the invisible hours
sherlock holmes crimes and punishment+ devils daughter
vanishing of ethan carter
virginia
blackwood crossing
wolf among us
layers of fear
firewatch
hektor
homesick
the sexy brutale
what remains of edith finch
life is strange
narcosis
soma

Sooo you can't go wrong with any of the Wadjet Eye Games.
The Blackwell serie will fit your mystery requirement. Otherwise Technobabylon or Gemini Rue if you're feeling more SF/Cyberpunk (still with mystery). http://store.steampowered.com/search/?publisher=Wadjet%20Eye%20Games

Although I only completed the first episode, the Last Door has quite a good reputation, and it's right down the horror alley ^^ http://store.steampowered.com/app/284390/The_Last_Door__Collectors_Edition/

What about Stasis? It's a bit different, notably it's a top-down view, but otherwise a P&C. A lot of horror in it in a sci-fi setting: http://store.steampowered.com/app/380150/STASIS/

I hope this help. I'll add more if I think of others!

Everything I would have suggested already has been, except for one.

The White Chamber. It's not on Steam but it is a free point and click. And it's a nice little horror adventure game.

Recently I played The Night of The Rabbit and The Silent Age. I really enjoyed both.

Bumping.
I'm mainly HOG over P&C.
But if you wanna check out a good/interesting adventure/mystery HOG series out I can recommend the whole Nightmares from the Deep Collection.

+1 to the Blackwell series. It's about someone who can talk to ghosts and tries to help them.

There's a bundle on steam for them, perfect to grab when it's on sale.

Amazing recommendations, thank you very much people!!!

"The Longest Journey" maybe?
That's a trilogy but other 2 games are not point & click.

All I can think of are the classics (mostly Lucas Arts games), though you said you played most of them, but I´ll list the ones i can think of now, maybe you missed some of them.
Indiana Jones and the last crusade
Indiana Jones the fate of Atlantis
Simon the sorcerer 1, 2 and 3
Sam & Max hit the road
The Sam & Max Telltale games (not quite classics but still good though)
Day of the tentacle
Maniac mansion
Loom
Monkey Island 1, 2 and 3
Tales from monkey island (ditto S&M)
Shadow of the comet
The dig
Full throttle
Kyrandia series
Police quest series
Quest for glory series
Grim fandango
Zak McKracken and the Alien Mindbenders
Escape from monkey island
Gabriel Knight sins of the fathers
Gabriel Knight 3
Space quest series
Leisure suit Larry series
Freddy Pharkas: Frontier Pharmacist
Discworld 1 and 2
Discworld noir
Toonstruck
King's Quest VI
Thimbleweed Park (new but looks and feels like a classic)
Broken Sword 1 and 2
The Last Express
The Longest Journey
The neverhood
Beneath a steel sky
Flight of the Amazon Queen
Syberia
I Have No Mouth, and I Must Scream
The Runaway series
Dark seed
Lure of the Temptress
Ripley's Believe It or Not!: The Riddle of Master Lu
Dragonsphere

Try Space Quest 6

Darkestville Castle from the latest games

Well, I recently finished Corrosion. Puzzles are very hard for my taste but story is awesome. It as kind a morbid and bizzare and at the same time funny with this plot twist.

I'm also wondering the same thing, so have a bump.

If no one has said, Broken Sword 1 & 2
and Monkey Island 1 & 2

Master piece!

You may have already played them, but worth mentioning them:

• Sanitarium
• City of the lost children

Adam Wolfe
Agatha Christie ABC Murders
Bear With Me
CAYNE (the game itself is free, but it has optional dlc)
Detective Grimoire
Gabriel Knight Sins of the Father (2014 remake, not familiar with the classic)
Orwell (not sure if this one fits your criteria, but might be worth a look?)
Silence
The Raven - Legacy of a Master Thief
The Silent Age
What Remains of Edith Finch

The first two Broken Sword games are classic, nice and enjoyable games. ^^

It is not horror or mystery but if you like point & click adventure games you can join my whitelist GA ;)

Goetia
Kathy Rain

And the best adventure game I played in recent years: Thimbleweed Park (just get it, you wont be disappointed)