Comment has been collapsed.
He gets the games from the developers, he is not one of them AFAIK.
Comment has been collapsed.
Which is why a lot of people, myself included, really frown upon them being known as developer giveaways. Not implying anything about deumas here but speaking in general, another issue is that people worry about how these games were acquired: were they given for the express purpose of the gifter being a middleman, or did they beg for free games? There's been more than one incident where it has been the latter.
Comment has been collapsed.
It did say it in the past and that featured giveaway tag was a compromise cg and myself came to over our differing views on the subject. I still feel like more could be done to stop abuse, but I'm content for now, especially as the highest cap for contributor giveaways is $2000 right now.
Comment has been collapsed.
"There's been more than one incident where it has been the latter." How do you know? :o
Comment has been collapsed.
What Crocross said, but I actually knew of at least two before I was a mod and even before developer giveaways were even a thing.
Comment has been collapsed.
That sentence was scrambled to hell, but I'm going to assume you're asking my gender? Most think I'm a he.
Comment has been collapsed.
He's not a dev. He begs devs for free keys to giveaway here.
Comment has been collapsed.
My views. It's been discussed a couple of times between the mods, but the status quo was upheld for now.
Comment has been collapsed.
It's been a while, but I believe the decision ended up being that they are bringing something to the site and (as long as they don't beg for the games), that is worth the contributor points, especially with the $2000 cap for contributor giveaways right now.
Comment has been collapsed.
I agree. The thing about dev giveaways is they didn't pay a cent for the games. Yes it's nice of them but they got all of them for free....
Comment has been collapsed.
And they gave them away rather than sell them. Sure, its to make more people want them, but it isn't like they couldn't have just sold the games.
Comment has been collapsed.
Yeah agreed.
There too many game available. Some are f2p and some are p2p. Too many competition and I bet devs need community to play them instead of wasting them. So that we(gamers) recommend to our friends, making the game more popular. Im speaking of unfamous new game though.
Comment has been collapsed.
If it weren't for his begging devs for keys, he'd only have bundle crap and free stuff given away.
Comment has been collapsed.
So? For about $50 or so dollars people can have about $500 contributor value. All but a few of the giveaways were under $150 contributor value. People are way too concerned about stuff like this. No one complained when he was handing out games. Also if getting keys from devs for free was so easy then someone go out and do it. Still sounds like sore losing from my stand point.
Comment has been collapsed.
Just because you work hard to scam doesn't make it any less of a scam or more justified, thats just my view though.
Comment has been collapsed.
I don't see it as scamming. It takes skill and salesmanship to work out bug deals like this. It is no different than taking someone out to lunch in order to close a multi-million dollar deal. I think he should have more tact, but I don't think he is to solely to blame.
Comment has been collapsed.
Good scams do take skill also you realize right? Many salesmen are scammers in all actuality.
Comment has been collapsed.
Then everything can be considered a scam. I agree that all salespeople could be considered scammers. However, all of our buying habits were influenced by someone convincing us that we are making the right choice for their own personal gain.
Edit* I am a saleperson by trade and agree that most sale pitches can fall into the scam category.
Another Edit* I view myself as a public servant giving people what they want and truly need. =p
Comment has been collapsed.
I guess it comes down to perspective.
I still see this as a scam in a way but it can be argued, I just don't see his wins as fair.
Anything can be argued, for example, what's good for one could be seen as evil to another.
Comment has been collapsed.
Very true. I agree that this isn't fair in a way, but I also don't believe this post was meant for the greater good. Everyone has an angle, and for someone who has been here as long as the OP it seems more like a witch hunt. They know and knew better than to call a user out.
Comment has been collapsed.
Not that I care to get involved but he has a win every week or so as it seems so posting 6 days after a giveaway or any time after it would be "too close" for you..
I don't know but there's no way of telling whether it was due to a certain giveaway or not.
Comment has been collapsed.
Yes he "brought" 28k worth of games into the site but he didn't "buy" the games like every other user that joins giveaways/creates giveaways does, I'd bet money that he didn't spend a dime on any of the contributor value that he has. That's the point that the OP and a lot of other people in this thread are stressing.
I could have sworn that there was a rule that developers couldn't enter giveaways (JadeFalcon has pointed out that Deumas isn't in fact a dev but just someone who "gets" keys from devs to give away [how he gets them is debatable]) so this user is gaining incredible contributor value while not actually earning it like the rest of us have to.
In the few months that I've been here I don't think I've seen one single other account that's done "dev" giveaways join a giveaway, be it group, private, public or contributor. What makes Deumas so special that he/she is allowed to do it?
I think everyone would like some clarification on whether or not users who are associated with "dev" giveaways are in fact allowed to use their "dev giveaway" contributor value to join regular giveaways.
Comment has been collapsed.
I'm not going to name names, but there is one other account that has made (beta) dev giveaways and won several very high contributor level giveaways. For some reason, though, after the win, support said that he is not allowed to enter giveaways anymore (and to report him if we see anymore entries). Yet they say nothing about Deumas.
Comment has been collapsed.
I think that's the cue for the users of Steamgifts to do something about this then, rules aren't selective, if they apply to one account they apply to all others.
Comment has been collapsed.
Yes, begging for keys from devs to give away here is so much better than giving away tons of exploited keys.
Comment has been collapsed.
Sure, he can help developers but can't receive contributor points for this... he didn't paid anything and didn't create the game...
Comment has been collapsed.
Yeah, the devs are totally just like "oh! Let's find someone random on this steamgifts website and give him all our keys to giveaway! This Deumas guy looks legit, let's give him a bunch of keys!"
Totally.
Comment has been collapsed.
I don't think he should have this contributor points. Featured and developer giveaways shouldn't count contributor points.
mabako got suspended because he asked for a reroll when deumas won his giveaway with this "fake" contributor points, it isn't fair... he should get unsuspended.
http://www.steamgifts.com/giveaway/OONS0/trine-2-collectors-edition
Comment has been collapsed.
worth the suspension. If he won a high contributor giveaway of mine, you can bet I would not give the game to him
Comment has been collapsed.
I wouldn't deliver the game too, why should I give game to someone that don't have actual contributor points.
Comment has been collapsed.
Agree fully. I made a thread about this as well 2 weeks ago
Comment has been collapsed.
Its people like the ones above me that have dragged this site down into the cesspool that it has become.
Comment has been collapsed.
Who the hell do you think you're? STFU bro, I owe nothing to you, you're nothing to me...
Every thread I see you posting you try to humiliate people. Oh boy he have 2k contributor points but wait...
http://www.steamgifts.com/user/Crossbourne http://www.steamgifts.com/user/MoneyHypeMike
Comment has been collapsed.
mh...for someone that was asking with at least 2 different accounts if he could join my group you are quite pissed now. Besides I didnt bring up my contributor value,you did that. Projecting something...?
oh and by your own logic: Deumas owes nothing to you and you are nothing to him,so STFU bro,who the hell do you think you are?
Comment has been collapsed.
Umm... That's kind of rich, actually, coming from you. DonVino's right. Also, see my post below.
Comment has been collapsed.
With fake contributor I meant games he just got for free from developers...
If get keys from developers is allowed so Metro 2033, Hitman Sniper Challenge and some other games shouldn't be exploited...
Comment has been collapsed.
A different video, equally unrelated. Much funnier though ;)
Comment has been collapsed.
That's ridiculous, sorry. Do you know how much time, and effort, it costs contacting devs, convincing them to give out some free promotional copies, maintain good contacts with them, and manage all these giveaways / key distributions for 1,000 copies of a game, 100, whatever? Like, seriously, think about it a second. I kind of see what you mean, but when someone does that much - read: "invests so much personal time" - for the gaming community (promoting games for devs, good for them, makes for more and better, more innovative, creative games from the smaller devs), steamgifts community (giveaways for you and me), don't you think it's kind of fair he can enter high contrib giveaways? Seeing as how, they're for rewarding people that in some way contribute?
..
.. looks at your profile
..
Thought so.
Comment has been collapsed.
Agree with my formatting choices or not, I used them for visual effect and to add an extra layer of communication to the message, so pretty resourceful and well reasoned use of that formatting, actually. Not a case of e-peening, like you suggest. Like, - funnily enough - well, you just did with your post.
Anyway, like I was saying - agree or not with the formatting, it's a superficial thing anyway. Try commenting on the message, the actual content, instead. Makes you sound smart.
Comment has been collapsed.
:)
Your argument was a personal attack on someone for their supposed attitude problem, like, funnily enough - well, you just did with me. My tongue-in-cheek point is that a well-reasoned argument need not rely on cheap tricks to gain legitimacy.
As to a factual comment, posted one an hour ago.
Tucks e-peen away ;)
Comment has been collapsed.
So he shouldn't get anything for convincing devs to give him games for the site to giveaway to you people jesus you guys are all selfish I remember why I hate this place as of recently.
You know he could just be selling those games or keeping them for himself but no he gives them away to others why are there so many un-greatful jackasses on this site now.
Comment has been collapsed.
In general, I think SG is a good avenue for developers to give their games some publicity. A developer giveaway generates a lot of goodwill toward that particular developer. It should be common sense to not squander that goodwill by generating controversy among the community you have just used resources to win over. In the case of deumas, the developer would have no control over his actions, so it seems a somewhat naive move in hindsight. Developers should have developer accounts, and fully reap the benefits of their promotions. Warranted or not, the controversy is there. That makes it bad publicity.
Comment has been collapsed.
I'm pretty sure that he can't go around selling the games. I don't think there would be a dev who would just give away the xxxx amount of copies to someone for their personal want of making money.
I mean, I get what you're saying but I highly doubt the option where he just sells the games is on the table. However he got the keys it was clearly for giving away purposes not selling them himself.
That's my thought on it at the least.
Comment has been collapsed.
that again? Don't overestimate the value of contributor...2k is the max needed to enter everything,with 500 you can enter 99,9%. Also,instead of complaining,try something similiar. Those are legit copies he got from the devs. besides...most guys complaining here are either bundlers or gave away something they got for free anywhere...so lol.
Comment has been collapsed.
Always the bundlers, people PURELY trying to "win sgifts", basically, who just see contrib. value as a stat you battle to get higher with the best available strategy, as cheaply as possible, for more free shit, who complain the loudest about stuff like this, and have the greatest lack of empathy / (used google trans) Einfühlungsvermögen. See my other, slightly bigger (literally :P) post on here. Only got 3 other posts here.
Comment has been collapsed.
I'm surprised that you have opened a thread like this, you should know very well that posting the name of another user always ends with the thread gets locked.
Comment has been collapsed.
I think a mod should shut this thread down . . . If you look at the giveaways won then there's no reason to comp. . I think if he's giving dev' giveaways under his own account he should be honest and make a dev accn't but that not here or there. This thread is calling out someone who's won 1 1$ giveaway that was 2k cont value. . . Meh. Calling out a gifter is crazy, exp when they've given more then they've taken. . .
Comment has been collapsed.
If you read the thread you'll notice that a moderator has actually posted in this thread at least twice.
So at least one moderator knows of this thread and they've decided to leave it open.
Comment has been collapsed.
316 Comments - Last post 9 minutes ago by Mitsukuni
447 Comments - Last post 1 hour ago by Hawkingmeister
14 Comments - Last post 1 hour ago by Fatality92
27 Comments - Last post 2 hours ago by tabbou
41 Comments - Last post 2 hours ago by XfinityX
33 Comments - Last post 2 hours ago by 76561198082881386
80 Comments - Last post 12 hours ago by Asteria94
112 Comments - Last post 3 minutes ago by Vincer
59 Comments - Last post 10 minutes ago by Fraden
54 Comments - Last post 11 minutes ago by Vincer
61 Comments - Last post 31 minutes ago by reallurker
171 Comments - Last post 43 minutes ago by meneldur
6,928 Comments - Last post 50 minutes ago by knsys
109 Comments - Last post 58 minutes ago by ceeexo
Fair play here.
Comment has been collapsed.