You've got mail!

I have a secret to share, and it's a giveaway code! But you have to find at least 11 of the 16 keys hidden in the file above, and I do mean the email file not pastebin html, don't get ahead of yourself. Some keys are obvious, and some less, others still are hidden very, very well. Some may issue you a puzzling challenge. But bottom line is, you don't have to find all of them, just 11 out of 16.

The file is an actual *.eml file, something conforming to MIME etc, but if you don't have an email client that opens it, you don't really need it, you'll just have to decode the base64 encoded attachment yourself (it's an encrypted 7z file). Make sure you're not using something like XLATE for that part, this is a binary file not some obfuscated text. There are other online tools that would work, however. In general you are likely going to need a lot of tools, many of which if not all can be found online, but if you download something make sure you're not installing some shady stuff.

Side note: although you may indeed mess up the part above if using something like XLATE instead of proper decoder for binary files, generally speaking if you are unpacking an encrypted archive and your tool tells you the file is corrupted, 99 out of 100 times the file is allright, you are just putting in a wrong password. Seriously. Think again if the password really is what you think it is. Had some folks on my other puzzle who didn't realize that.

I don't even know why I'm telling you this. If you didn't realize that you are probably not going to do well anyway.

Anyway, you will not only need the keys, but actually you also have to know what to do with them. It is something heavily hinted at, but never fully explained. If you can't do your research, because using google for some keywords is too much for you, then finding the keys will not help you.

I have included a handy itstoohard quiz so you can confirm that you have found a proper key. It's there mainly as an aid, altough in the end I did decide to include a small reward for finding all keys and solving that quiz. But it's mainly a huge sense of achievement I guess?

This puzzle is a charlie foxtrot of hidden stuff. Knowing tropes that run on steamgifts is useful, including ideas of my own I used before. That's going to be extremely helpful as otherwise there are no hints and you're on your own. Although sometimes I invert the tropes instead of playing them straight, and sometimes I'm doing quite new stuff, too. Linking you Zelghadis's guide as a cop out instead of providing actual hints is all you get. Looking for my past puzzles, even if made well over a year ago, also may prove fruitful.

But otherwise yes, this is the epitome of this type of "puzzle" where the maker doesn't tell you much, stuff can be hidden anywhere, and.. good luck. If you don't have stomach for it, I suggest not trying. This is not for everyone. This is not something where I embed hints to make your life easier, I outright tell you to read about past puzzles, the ways people do stuff, for inspiration, if you don't already know what to do... but that is it. And there are likely elements noone else around here did yet, not even I.

Nonetheless, this is fourth puzzle in my current puzzling miniseries and will be required for the season's recap puzzle. I may start dropping some hints later on but no promises. Hints are more likely to be presented after the giveaway is done, to help with completion of the whole series, but first I have to see if people are interested in finding all of the keys not just a subset and maybe reward some folks for going the extra mile before dropping more hints.

As always, this is a challenge for individuals not for cooperating teams. Do not share keys, hints, etc.

Giveaway Timer (2014 01 23 1230 ZULU) (CV $32.10) (ENDED)
Bonus sweet timer (2014 01 25 2200 ZULU) (ENDED)

I may have made it last for too little time, so get onto it xD I just liked the date, 01-23 and made an ending hour to match. There's no particular reason why the date is as it is, I just fancied it like that.

Good luck, have fun.

Note: Turns out you are best off finding exactly the same tool that I used as other tools potentially may be implementing the idea differently. It should not be a problem once you've answered Q17 on the key confirmation sheet. I used the same format as the tool gave me. Other tools, even if you translate to their format, may not work, even if they claim to work on the same principle. Huh. Probably slightly different implementation or different data structure beyond the index or other elements. Have to admit I haven't checked other tools, but again, the one I used will be easy to google once you know what to do.


Giveaways ended, although puzzle to be considered still active!

Yup that's still active because it's a part of miniseries and for solving all puzzles there gonna be something extra, like I said multiple times (gawd I hope I haven't hyped that too much xD ).

So you'll have to wait like month for the full solution, maybe more, and please continue keeping it spoiler free here and on the main giveaway. Meanwhile, I posted a reasonably verbose, even though still just partial, solution/roadmap for all the keys on the giveaway page. For which, again, you just need to find 11 keys out of 16.

I'll just make it somewhat easier for future solvers for now: the main concept behind the keys (and answer to Q17) was Shamir's Secret Sharing Scheme (alternatively Shamir's Secret Sharing was accepted, too).

I did say where to look for inspiration - Zelghadis's guide, but also among my past puzzles. Pity it's not easy to find posts / threads made by users within SG, so you'd have to use google (something that Zelghadis's guide suggested actually). But most of the inspiration could've been found in my very first puzzle, A picture is worth 1000 words (615 days ago! :O 147 entries on first stage :O like 40 solvers on second :O - also, I have restored it to former glory :D originally paste was set to expire, but I found it in google's trash bin), also in Alchemia, and perhaps one bit in What sound does a (puzzle) giveaway make?. And alamarjan's Quick Fix 8 - X Marks The Spot could be a useful inspiration, too, by the way.

10 years ago*

Comment has been collapsed.

Maaaan, I can finally join the hundred-percenter-club... Kinda confused why I didn't join it one or two days ago, I could have sworn I did the same thing before multiple times...

And I have to agree with Award, while getting 100% is a pain in the a** you should not be scared of the first puzzle, 11/166 is quite manageable :-)

10 years ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

You guys putting pressure on the other solvers, eh? xD But yeah I bet getting all of them is just that extra bit of satisfaction :3

10 years ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

Allright, 19 hours to go, at least 16 solvers (11 entries), of which 7 folks decided to go the extra mile for 100% (6 entries).

10 years ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

Current prgress for 100%. Mising 6, 7, 9, 16.
Found a hint for 7 a while ago that I still don't understand yet.
Found something that's kind of related to key 11 but can't get anything from it.
Can't find anything else.

10 years ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

Most importantly though, you did solve main puzzle so happy that :) For 7 again, I think you're just bypassing proper route and getting confused by lack of context. This is a "hint" only insofar as to make you realize you are clearly missing something. Otherwise it's not really a hint just a clarification in case you get somehow confused by what you get from the proper context.

10 years ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

Solved 7. Not sure if this is the proper route that you had in mind though.
Also found a much easier way to find a previous key along the way.

10 years ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

Well if you've solved it then at least you've seen the most important part of the context, which many may be missing. That more important part still can be gotten to in a cruder way than the smoothest way possible, but regardless, if what you did worked for you in the end then all good :3 There's one part about 07 that confuses people but in the end I decided against further clarifications.

10 years ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

I always keep forgetting which key was hidden in which way, which makes following all discussions about keys really hard to follow :)

10 years ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

Keys.txt, knowing Award I made it at the beginning of the puzzle with all the keys and where I found them :P

10 years ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

+1

10 years ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

+1

10 years ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

A dragon freed, treasures buried, all keys hidden. Now I go home.
Thank you!

10 years ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

Oh, cool, another crazy person :3 Well, well done :) That dragon needed some free roaming indeed

10 years ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

Bump for 100%!

Edit: It bothers me that most people aren't getting to see the depth of this fantastic puzzle.

10 years ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

Hehe nice :3 Well the stuff you were struggling with for others was easier to find, and conversely for example 09 you found early on while others were/are struggling, similarly with 16.

10 years ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

Looks like GA is over, I already own the game though. Got 11 keys but couldn't figure out how to get the giveaway code afterwards

10 years ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

Yes the main giveaway is over, the bonus is still ongoing but that's a harder challenge. And even once that part is over, the puzzle will still be considered active for my miniseries, so I'll post solutions only after a month or so. But I'll probably explain that part what you had to do with the keys on Saturday.

10 years ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

Main giveaway is over now, ended with 16 solvers/11 entries (Brothers - Tale of Two Sons). Encore for the hardcore still ongoing for couple days but unless you really like this sort of stuff I won't encourage going that far xD Nonetheless, 9 people did decide to go that far, the more power to them :D

10 years ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

Damn, didn't win :-(

This GA again proved the weirdness of my thinking... with odds in 1/11 I'm surprised that I DIDN'T win, while at odds like 1/666 i was totally surprised THAT I won... I wonder where my cut-off is for feeling like I've practically won... guess around 20-30 :-)

10 years ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

Well I had my share of losing 2 entry giveaways, I'd guess I lost about half of them ;)

10 years ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

Um, wow. I just found key 6, but it was a situation where I just randomly tried something and didn't expect it to be the key at all.
Just 9, 16 left. (lol, square numbers)
Still haven't found a way to decode something that looks very suspicious but at the same time looks like it could just be a random coinidence.

10 years ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

Decided to give it another try so bump for finding key 7.
Still missing 6,9,11 but doubt ill be able to get more.

10 years ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

I'm free... I'M FREEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE!!!
AHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAH!!!!!!

Another 100% solver reporting in :P

10 years ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

Congratulations :3 Now, run free, little pyro, blowing bubbles and rainbows around.. oh wait..

10 years ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

Do you believe in magic? :D

10 years ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

Congratulations all solvers, bit extra gratz to the winners! And the hardcore encore 100%ers get extra respect points, too :)

Both giveaways have ended, although puzzle is to be considered still active, because it's a part of miniseries and for solving all puzzles there gonna be something extra, like I said multiple times (gawd I hope I haven't hyped that too much, though xD ).

So you'll have to wait like month for the full solution, maybe more, and please continue keeping it spoiler free here and on the main giveaway. Meanwhile, I posted a reasonably verbose, even though still just partial, solution/roadmap for all the keys on the giveaway page. For which, again, you just need to find 11 keys out of 16.

I'll just make it somewhat easier for future solvers for now: the main concept behind the keys (and answer to Q17) was Shamir's Secret Sharing Scheme (alternatively Shamir's Secret Sharing was accepted, too). Go search around what it is, and for a tool that would work on those keys I gave you.

I did say where to look for inspiration - Zelghadis's guide, but also among my past puzzles. Pity it's not easy to find posts / threads made by users within SG, so you'd have to use google (something that Zelghadis's guide suggested actually). But most of the inspiration could've been found in my very first puzzle, A picture is worth 1000 words (615 days ago! :O 147 entries on first stage :O like 40 solvers on second :O - also, I have restored it to former glory :D originally paste was set to expire, but I found it in google's trash bin), also in Alchemia, and perhaps one bit in What sound does a (puzzle) giveaway make?. And alamarjan's Quick Fix 8 - X Marks The Spot could be a useful inspiration, too, by the way.

EDIT: I did use some new ideas beyond whole Shamir's Scheme, too, of course.

10 years ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

Looking forward to the full detailed solution later, as even if I'm now sure where to look, I still don't know how to get some keys.

10 years ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

Closed 10 years ago by Award.