I would like to have a tame pc vs console sorta thing

A console right now is $200 for the last gen and $400 (PS4) or $500 (Xbox one). A home computer on average costs $400-$600. Take last gen console price and a medium priced home PC and you have a sweet gaming rig that will run many games on max and higher end games on medium. End of argument PC wins. PC games are also cheaper and have a longer life saving you money. You also don't have to pay a monthly/yearly fee to play online. So much money is saved on PC it isn't even funny.

I prefer consoles for various reasons.

• The game will work. With PCs, conflicts with certain hardware can cause your new game to not work as I've gotten with Doom 3: BFG Edition.
• Physical media is still common, which is great for those of us with low datacaps.
• Native gamepad support for all the available games, rather than fiddling with 3rd party software like JoyToKey. Understand that gamepads are my preferred control option. I understand the mouse is more accurate, but very few games require pixel perfect aim, and I'll take everything else on a gamepad over a keyboard. Plus, my left hand is gimped and it hurts to use most of the fingers, making keyboards a poor option in any case.
• Several of the genre I prefer are either better on, or exclusive to consoles.

At any rate, the system I'm playing the game on doesn't much matter. What is important is that I'm enjoying the games I play.

I'd like to start with saying that DPI has nothing to do with how good a mouse performs.
I can guarantee you that almost everyone has at least one PC in their house, so it's not a "competition" between PC and just a console. If you have a console, you most likely also have a PC, which probably cost you anywhere between 300 to 600$ (for an average prebuilt PC). If you add the price of the console to the price of PC, the amount you pay would get you a fairly decent system that can run majority of games on high, especially if you're willing to lower resolution (and if we're comparing to consoles then you should, because console games run either at 720p and/or equivalent of low settings on a PC version).

Another thing you have to take into account is the price of games. I think everyone knows how ridiculously cheap are games on PC, compared to console games.

Edit: I would also like to state that "not everyone can afford a PC that runs games on ultra" argument is silly, because you don't play a game on console on "ultra", so you shouldn't seek ultra settings on a PC that cost you the same as a console.