Which Borderlands 2 DLC should I get?

Season pass really. Go for one of the dlcs included in the season pass.

Ultimate Vault Hunter.

Tiny Tina's Assault on Dragon's Keep. Easily the best DLC out of the four.

psycho pack if you like AAWWWWWWWWWWWWWW JEAH

Get the Season Pass. If you can't right now, just get one or both of the characters, then get the Season Pass later. It's bound to be discounted again somewhere soon.

You can get the Season pass for slightly cheaper on Amazon with the code "gooncave." Brings it down to $18.28 for me. Not sure if that will help.

I Get the Season Pass in a page of brazil! at 13 dollars!

Honestly the season pass is more value than buying DLCs piece meal :< Could you maybe wait for a sale on it? flash or community

Dear Buttstallion,

Buy my DLC because its the best and you will feel reborn. Also, if you don't, I will eat you.

Or... buy the season pass and have yoself a fiiiiine experience. Either way, playa.

Love,
Tiny Tina

P.S.: I love crumpets.

I got quite mad about season pass not including the two playable character dlcs with the mechromancer and the bandit dude.

torgues campaign of carnage has the funniest dialogue, in my opinion.
tiny tinas dragons keep was fun too.
didn't like pirates booty or hammerlocks hunt much.

Right now, I would wait. Unfortunately the Season Pass didn't get discounted again, at 33% off it's too expensive. Heck, even buying the 5 DLC's within seperately is cheaper atm, GJ Steam.
Season Pass was 66% off at Steam in the start of the sale, and shortly before that BL2+Season Pass was like 13 Euro on GMG. Wait for a similar deal imo.

I got Tiny Tina's, Ultimate Vault hunter and with the remaining money I got Unepic.

First 3 DLCs were meh but the last one, Tiny Tina's Assault on Dragonborn or sth like that is pretty good. I'd say get that one.

Wait for good discounted season pass =)
I just finished my first playthrough with 72 hours played. Played a gunzerker till lvl 22 then started later new with the psycho "KRIEG"^^
I´ve got the season pass / mechromancer and psycho dlc, the only one i touched in these ours is the psycho. I´m about lvl 33 and think I´ll touch the first story dlc after I´ve beaten max lvl or maybe lvl 50...

So, Tiny Tina's Assault was the best. Scarlett's Booty was the worst. The hunting guy one was ok. Torgue's Campaign was interesting, but the last boss is retarded on a whole new level. Tiny Tina's is by far the best of the 4.

Mechromancer is OP, great fun if you build anarchy