Good reason to reroll?

No, he did not break any site rules unless they were regifts.

How can someone get 123.45$ contribution value from The Ship?

Of course NOT!

No, it would be a good reason for him to be ashame. I guess they should make another limit or DR on such, to ensure a variety of games are gifted.

Seriously? You don't like the games he gave away so you want to stiff him? Take your moralizations some place else. If they didn't break the rules then they won fair and square.

Thanks for answers!