Choose A or B? - Instant regret

I think that all the choices in these games really do not affect anything. The only important choice is made at the end of the game.

Walking Dead has a great story and compelling characters, but like StarPONY said, the majority of choices don't really change anything. I think playing them once is probably the best, because it feels like the choices mattered.

The only choice I remade was in The Wolf Among Us, where I misunderstood the prompt - glassing someone didn't mean to raise your glass on them, but to smash the glass on their head :D
Otherwise I played those games with a " welp, that happened" attitude. I'm unsure if it will be doable about LiS, I think the feels will get me a lot more than with any TT game.

Play SOMA and you will want to kill yourself after choices :D

Really tho, it is the game that made me think, the most.

(Pillars of the Earth was very good as well and it is closer to games you mentioned above)

I usually like to consult the wiki or a guide to know which choice leads where, so I rarely regret the choice I make in games. In real life, however... I instantly regret pretty much every choice I make. And it's not even that I made a wrong decision, just that I'm never happy with myself. Jesus, now I'm depressed again :D

Uh, I have mixed feeling about these game. Like someone said, the only choice that really matters is the one at the end. Most of the minor choices give the exact same outcome, no matter if you choose A or B, just a different roundabout. It was espacially painfully visible in TWD.

If you REALLY wish for a game where choices matter LISA is the game that will really fuck with you and make you question your decisions.

Afterwards I ALWAYS wished I had chosen differently

Well the great thing in LiS is that you could always (well, almost always) rewind time and choose something else. A pity they removed in LiS BtS (and a shame they replaced it with that stupid backtalk minigame)

Play https://store.steampowered.com/app/282070/This_War_of_Mine/ and thank me later :o)

You NEVER have enough ressources to do all that you "should do". If you fullfill some requirement the protagonists suffer at something else. That push you the complete game under pressure and that is in the end a very intense game experience that teach you a lot about people in a emergency situation. A great game.

I'm pretty sure that the Walking Dead is designed to make you feel that way, ie: there are no good choices. I enjoyed the first season anyway, the second not quite as much, and stopped there because occasionally I do know how to quit while I'm ahead.

I rather like having bad choice options as it makes the game feel more realistic. (If you knew the outcome of every possible choice in any given situation in real life, would you pick the outcome that is always the most favorable? I know I would!) TWD is a great game, but to be fair, the world the game is set in is bleak anyway and that is what makes it's choice outcomes perfect... because it puts you in situations where you don't have much information to work with or time to think about the consequences.

I have same feeling mostly when I don't really understand what I choose. So I'm trying to make savegames from time to time to be able to fix it

The worst game in this regard I've ever played is an Italian VN Dry Drowning. I mean, it's a decently written and drawn dystopian noir detective, but each and every choice feels like a wrong one. If I load a previous save and choose a different option, it also feels like a wrong one. I mean, sure, that's kinda an issue in most of the similar games, but Dry Drowning was the first game that made me feel so bad about every decision that I abandoned it for good.

I think that's the beauty of these games, when done right they make it feel like everything is the result of your choice. I always go with the choices I make, and only change them if I misunderstood something and didn't actually make the choice I thought I was making (which is why I really like LiS's system, since you can see the immediate response to your choice before committing to it, but not the far reaching ramifications).