High scoring games you didn't like

When I saw the thread I immediately thought "Braid", but I see you already discovered that one.

For a second guess I'll go with "Hotline Miami". It was just too hard for me. Stupid reason to dislike a game I guess, but to see all the positive reviews and I can't even get past the first level, usually dying to the second or third guy.

Really enjoyed Limbo though.

Skyrim: The story was not very engaging for me and I tend to get sidetracked by exploration. Then I did get vampirism and after I googled how to get rid of it and did the tideous quest for it I just couldn't bring myself to continue since I explored already about 70% of the entire map and had no idea what the story up to this point was

Payday 2 I liked for quite a while (even with all the DLCs already in place) but at some point I just did not have any more fun with it (iirs was around the time they introduced the safes and (payed) keys)

I don't think I dislike many of the games I played since in most of them I did get some enjoyment out of them and I never had the feeling I had/was waisting time. There are though multiple games which I just stop playing to play something differently then pick it up later again and finish it (or at least progress with the story/game)

eurotruck simulator 2

Well, I will get hate for these, but I didn´t like games like
Bioshock 1 (never finished that game, it was just... boring for me so I quit it)
Borderlands 1 (well it is good game in coop and I finished it and 100%ish it, but I expect a bit more from such high rated game - jokes were just not my cup of tea)
Oblivion (hell I put in 5 hours and feel bad for it, there was just nothing for me and it is a bit sad I won it here - someone else would like it more then me - there is just no way I will ever get back to it)

Dark Souls 1 & 2
At first, I'm intrigued by the design of death and how it handles the "re-try". Then, I found out that my character is garbage because apparently, pyromancers didn't use intelligence. Wow. I mean, it's standard that mages and sorcerers use INT (or WIS) stat. That doesn't mean you can't take a different approach but at least give me some heads up for it. Players shouldn't be punished for their previous knowledge.

The second worst part is how I found that out. After trying a couple of times on PC (I'm primarily a PC player) I gave up because keyboard controls sucked and I didn't have a gamepad back then. Then, I watched AGDQ and they ran Dark Souls on that and mentioned that Dexterity is the way to go (I guess it was this run). Players shouldn't feel the need to seek help outside of the game when they fail. If they do, that means they are trying their best but cannot keep up (which is fine) or they feel they are doing something wrong but cannot put their finger on it (for me, that's an issue but for most of the people, it's not) or the worst scenario, they feel that it's unfair to play. Atsushi Inaba said "the priority should be on designing the situations first. If a functionality is designed to capitalise on that situation, then that's great. It's really easy to fall into a trap on a series. (And if you rely too much on players knowing the mechanics of the first game - disregarding novice players), you run a risk of becoming niche." Dark Souls is a niche game that I don't enjoy playing. But that's not the worst part.

The worst part is the community. The whole "git gud" comments and belittling disgusted me and I parted ways with these games for good.

I absolutely despise Terraria, Minecraft, and any game that focuses on building. I fucking hate them so much. For me its no story = no fun.

Also, pretty much any exclusive, especially the playstation ones. People act so retardedly whenever a game comes out on their toaster. Uncharted 4 is a good example.

Borderlands series - I liked mix of action rpg with fps untill later game parts then very beginning. When enemies have more health and your weapons... well It's dissappointing when I use sniper rifle (with good stats) in first person shooter and can't perform kill with one bullet to the head on simple enemy. Also sooooo much garbage in loot aaaand f***ing backtracking. You just finished mission in most remote corner of map? Good - now we give you 3 new mission and you have to go to the same location again.... and again and again.

Hearthstone, Idk why, probably because i'm bad at card game, but i find it not interesting at all compared to another card game that i've played.

Also +1 on LIMBO and Braid and SMB just because i never really like platformer genre.

I don't trust games whose reviews are full of old memories. When games were scarce, you could be fond of badly executed games easily, now you are not.

Morrowind. As a Skyrim fan, I keep hearing all about how I need to play Morrowind cuz its the pinnacle of Elder Scrolls perfection and for true gamers and smart people and etc. But it's just so dang tedious. A huge map with very little in it, the friggin RNG for damage that hates the player, NPCs with less character than a cardboard box, no hint of what to do next or keep track of what you've done and are supposed to be doing. I was always in this constant state of annoyance and was so worried about getting lost or dying and having to start over that couldn't get immersed in the game the same way I could with Skyrim. I will give it this, I actually like the graphics. And the guars and the cliffracers. Cute little critters.

Fallout 3. Good lord, that game was depressing. Its like Bethesda totally missed the humor and surrealism present in the first two games and just made a generic post-apocalyptic shooter. And the whole passive-aggressive shaming if you don't kill yourself at the end of the game. Even when theres a good chance you'll have one of three characters who can handle the situation better than you due to IMMUNITY TO RADIATION. And the game is also heavily geared towards a specific playstyle; the only armor that wasnt completely destroyed in one to two hits was the power armor, and heaven help you if you try to use any weapon besides guns. And even after fully maxing out speech stats, you can still fail speech checks. So basically, if you're not playing as a nuclear knight who shoots first and talks later, you're screwed. As someone who likes to play as a nimble fist-fighter who can talk or hack out of any situation, this is not fun.

Madmax
Batman Arkham Asylum
Both have overwhelmingly positive reviews. I find them both a chore.

CS:G0

Terraria

The Witcher series: Tried 1 didn't like it, tried 2 same thing.. won't waste the money on 3. Just don't like the controls I suppose.
Sadly, I struggle with everything before FFX/2. The text boxes just kept coming and coming and it just bores me now a days.
Undertale: See the above one.

I'll just stick with three I could probably make a very big list.