War of the Roses disappointed me

I feel a bit the same. I played chivalry and Mount and Blade. In coparison WoR or how its called has nice graphics and i like the combat system(like M&B), but the combat feels a bit slow. However the customisation is great. I hope they improve the gamplayspeed a bit to make it more intense....

Played WoTR first and then Chivalry. So far I've spent more time on Chivalry and I think it's a better game overall. I only play duels in Chivalry as everything else just frustrates me. I do like WoTR's archery a lot better than Chivalry's, but that's about the only redeeming factor about it.

It's crap. No where near as good as chivalry. Tried it yesterday and absolutely HATE it!

War of the Roses is not Chivalry...

this game is just slow , hate it!

Chivalry: Medieval Warfare
64 HOURS PLAYED
LAST PLAYED YESTERDAY

'nuff said

WotR compared to chivalry is worse, you can now get Chivalry in Greenmangaming for a discount and using also coupon 20% off, Chivalry have better gameplay, better graphics, and it's more funny.

Lot better than Chivalry in my opinion. Maybe combat is slower, but it's more realistic that way. It's team oriented game and i think i have money well spent on WOTR.

Duly noted! - was curious about this, as, similarly, I was slightly disappointed in title Chivalry: Medieval Warfare, yet have fond memories of the original free HL2 mod (Chivalry) which was wicked fun! I suspect highly polished graphics & high fidelity effects / environments comes @ the sacrifice of engaging, satisfying & fast-paced / smooth combat mechanics - of which there's no substitute, in my opinion.

All of which are American dreams...

i am not a big fan of this kind of game but i tried war of the roses, warband and chivalry... Warband is the best,then chivalry ant last war of the roses IMO. If someone love these games dont do a crime to own all :) I bought war band and i am fine with that only...if i win the others well..good

Hmm I'm less excited about playing WoTR after reading this thread, I'll still give it a go because I've only got my time to lose :)

This Game ROX !!!!!!! too hard for the newbie :D

Also keep in mind this game is far from finished it's missing Siege mode (it's confirmed and coming soon) which will add tons of fun and a better replayability, besides Fatshark will be providing content updates on monthly basis. (and so far they delivered)

More here

So what? I had such disappointment not long ago, it was called "Max Payne 3", and where was my own reasons for that. It's a matter of taste here, you know.
With WotR I needed about half an hour to understand - this not my kind of game. Neither "WotR", nor "Chivalry".

this game is not for newbies. I think that's the problem (i master both, and wotr is much deeper than chivalry). Like comparing rainbow six with counter strike

Well, here's my ranking for those 3 games.

1. Mount and Blade: Warband
2. Chivalry
3. War of the Roses

WotR was very dissapointing for me, as well, I hoped it would be a lot more similar to mount and blade, which it wasn't. The archery combat was awesome but everything else pretty much bad. The combat felt very chunky, slow, hard and unresponsive, unlike Mount and Blade. I like Chivalry, as well, but Mount and Blade will remain my number 1.