Best Total War
My favorite of the old games was the Viking Invasion expansion, and Napoleon of the newer games.
But the greatest Expansion of all time was Medieval II Kingdoms - which added 4 whole scenarios as big as the base game. Best value for money ever.
Edit: and the worst campaign, in my experience, is Alexander.
Comment has been collapsed.
You missed https://store.steampowered.com/app/364360/Total_War_WARHAMMER/ on your pool!
Comment has been collapsed.
To tell the truth I remember I played some Total War games when I was younger but never got too deep in them but right now I have Total War: WARHAMMER and I need Total War: WARHAMMER II and also Three Kingdoms and Saga :P So propably I would vote for Total War: WARHAMMER.
Comment has been collapsed.
I skipped Warhammer because I consider it a separate thing (no matter how awesome).
I wanted to include Britannica and Three Kingdoms, but was limited to 20 entries. Also, people always have an inherent bias against the newest entries - either favorably because it's new and shiny, or negatively because of the changes.
Comment has been collapsed.
The first two games, the overland map feels much more like a boardgame (especially Risk). Starting with Rome, they changed the overland map to be more dynamic, and started developing more complex technology trees. From there on in, the tighter-focused campaigns (Rome, Napoleon, Shogun II, and some of the Rome II DLC) are much better, whereas the more sprawling campaigns (Empire, Rome II, Attila) are more of a mess.
Warhammer was a breath of fresh air, bringing in a lot of new mechanics and ideas, which were then introduced into Britannia and Three Kingdoms but I can't comment as I haven't played those yet
Comment has been collapsed.
I never could get into the Total War series. After spending 5-10 minutes in one of those battles I forget what I was doing on the strategic level. I do better with games like Civilization or Paradox games where all the combat is abstract and simplified.
Comment has been collapsed.
"auto-win", LOL
I still remember one my playthrough, when auto-play resulted in defeat (repeatedly), and playing the same battle myself I got a heroic victory
Comment has been collapsed.
Always a pleasure to play a NTW campaign with LME mod. Can't say enough thank you to those modders who made the game (and the others) even better.
I also liked Empire but for me Napoleon is better. My last TW game was Shogun II, you know when the serie became more Total KIT War.
Comment has been collapsed.
Total War's an interesting franchise for sure. I personally love Rome 1 for the campaign management and Shogun 2 or Rome 2 for the battles themselves. I definitely do think that the strategic complexity of the campaign map itself has been extremely dumbed down and become unbearably boring with anything after Medieval 2. With economy management becoming even more basic, no stack splits, no reinforcement, no populations, no culture, no historical effects like slavery vs. population and no population happiness management. It's now just a "click this for money or click this for alternate bonus" type of management.
Not saying Rome 1 was complex, but it was definitely more complex than what it is now.
Haven't played anything after Rome 2 though, so hopefully it's gotten better.
Comment has been collapsed.
I prefer the campaign management part of the game, which is why I couldn't get into Empire or Shogun II, and why Rome II got boring after a while Rome II is definitely too big
On the other hand, Napoleon's almost disregard for campaign management forced/pulled me in to the battles, and I thoroughly enjoyed that game
Comment has been collapsed.
Favourite is by far Warhammer (not played Warhammer 2 yet). The reason for that is simple, Total War has always had a really lackluster AI. The AI ended up being really predictable, and that made the games feel repetitive. Warhammer has much greater unit variety that things feel more varied, so the AI issue does not cause the game to feel as repetitive.
Comment has been collapsed.
I wish we had another pew pew Total War like Napoleon or Empire.
Comment has been collapsed.
With 50-60 provinces, for me the game becomes boring on the management aspect; on that point of view, Rise of Rome or Anibal at gates have more fun. But at the long term the big campaign have battles more interesting to me because the armies are more balanced.
In that aspect, Empire never gives me balanced battles in campaign (AI always comes with surreal combinations of artillery and elite troops), but I get fun thinking the action in three diferent theatres, without chances of get fast support on any there, is a nice challenge.
Comment has been collapsed.
Loved Rome, and really enjoyed Attila. I know it wasn't popular but it was quite satisfying to finish the Western Roman Empire campaign :D
Comment has been collapsed.
Definitely enjoyed medieval 2 the most. Probably also played it the most but i wouldnt know, seeing as i had it on physical disc rather than steam.
Comment has been collapsed.
Kingdoms also had an amazing soundtrack, good times!
Comment has been collapsed.
29 Comments - Last post 2 hours ago by adam1224
7 Comments - Last post 4 hours ago by xXSAFOXx
16,297 Comments - Last post 5 hours ago by SebastianCrenshaw
52 Comments - Last post 6 hours ago by adam1224
206 Comments - Last post 9 hours ago by Joey2741
31 Comments - Last post 10 hours ago by Pika8
1,519 Comments - Last post 11 hours ago by Tristar
727 Comments - Last post 5 minutes ago by eeev
7,977 Comments - Last post 6 minutes ago by eeev
104 Comments - Last post 26 minutes ago by Axelflox
42 Comments - Last post 44 minutes ago by Gelweo
23 Comments - Last post 52 minutes ago by FateOfOne
12 Comments - Last post 1 hour ago by Mikalye
43 Comments - Last post 1 hour ago by Vincer
So it looks like the next Total War will be Total War Troy to be officially announced imminently
Here's a rough timeline of the different games: please correct me if I'm wrong
Americas
1521 Medieval II Kingdoms
1783 Empire Warpath Campaign
China
220 Three Kingdoms
290 Eight Princes DLC
Europe
430BC Rome II Wrath of Sparta
336BC Rome - Alexander
272BC Rome II
270BC Rome
218BC Rome II Hannibal at the Gates
58BC Rome II Caesar in Gaul
32BC Rome II Imperatur Augustus
235 Rome II Empire divided
363 Rome - Barbarian Invasion
395 Attila
520 Attila The Last Roman
768 Attila Age of Charlemagne
1080 Medieval II
1086 Medieval
1174 Medieval - Kingdoms - Crusades
1250 Medieval - Kingdoms - Teutonic
1700 Empire
1796 Napoleon
England
793 Medieval - Viking Invasion
878 Thrones of Britannia
1258 Medieval II Kingdoms
Japan:
1180 Shogun II Rise of the Samurai
1250 Shogun Mongol Invasion
1450s Shogun
1550 Shogun II
1850 Fall of the Samurai
Comment has been collapsed.