Games have been shutting down for a long time now, that part isn't new. But it wasn't until The Crew that millions of people were affected, and the game was so beloved that owners began to ask questions about consumer protections, games preservation, and where the games industry is headed.

This video has been out for almost a day now but hasn't gotten a lot of views. I figured some of the community might be passionate about this topic, so if you haven't seen it, it's worth a watch. Essentially, one youtuber is trying to challenge EULA that limits access based on servers, and goes so far as to demand that companies should provide DRM free or offline versions of applications that consumers purchase rather than allow it to end service and be unplayable forever.

The video
The campaign website: StopKillingGames.com

7 months ago

Comment has been collapsed.

Do you think this will actually have any impact on the games industry?

View Results
Yes
No

I was looking for more options in the poll:
Maybe, if action is decided and acted upon (i.e. vote w your wallet AND let the publisher in question know why you're doing it). MEssage their support, email them, ,.. .

7 months ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

How about poll option three: I hope so, but am not optimistic.

7 months ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

Consumers from the US probably shouldn't even bother, but everyone else should definitely watch the video and if there's something you can do to support Ross and this quest of his, please do it. Especially if you're in France, the rest of the EU, and Australia. All we gotta do is catch a break with just one countries legal system and that could get the ball rolling on this.

7 months ago*
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

France, Australia, or the EU

Dang, France left the EU as well? Who's next?

View attached image.
7 months ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

Shoulda waited until I had my coffee. 🥴

I've edited my comment.

7 months ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

"the largest campaign ever"

"one youtuber"

7 months ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

no chance this will ever happen - does this person take them to court for not doing so? lol

7 months ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

I believe it's not that easy to make offline patch for this one (they don't wanna waste money on programmers, which is odd, since they could sell offline version for lower price, same as other games), because they actually did it for HOMM 6 recently. Yes, it bugged as hell but works offline.

7 months ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

Maybe the solution would be to release the server source code, or enable the possibility to host you own server for a game one the official ones are gone? Aren't there lots of games that have been working for years like that (Wolfenstein: ET comes to mind)?

7 months ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

Lol, they wont sell you a cheaper version just because its offline, the reason why a lot of games are always online even if they dont need to is so that you always have the store enabled, they dont want you to get the urge to buy something and stop just because you werent online, and as soon as you arent a potential buyer they dont care about you (even if you just spend 70 usd)

7 months ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

They did, HOMM 6

7 months ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

Even if it happens in one country, it doesn't mean it will affect companies. So they make a game to work after they shut down servers, and as the vid guy said "might as well do it globally". So a company has two choices: make the game keep working globally, or only in one or a few countries. They will choose mostly the 2nd option, because it wil lead to more game sales. It's like the light bulb 10,000 hours limit. Make the light bulb eventually fail and you'll keep selling more light bulbs.

Also, it has been happening because companies stop supporting games for new systems, same reason. Why spend money in making something work when they can get more sales? Some games have the luck of having a loyal community behind which make remakes or mods (without original copyrighted assets) so you can play old games. There's Dosbox and emulators.

But now think of this. Steam is a platform with a client that requires something higher than Windows 7 (not talking about Linux/MacOS, just Windows). Yet they keep selling games that only work with Windows 7 or lower. That's incompatible! Are you selling me a game that will not work out of the box? That I'll need to research, find and apply fixes? Not all users can do that. I remember refunding a game that included some DLCs but the game tried to download them from a server which doesn't exist anymore. Companies don't need to support a game forever, as things are now. But Steam stance with this is subject is borderline fraud. However, we agreed to Steam terms of service, which including making a portion of your library unplayable without a lot of work. However, they keep selling those games, and that irks me a lot.

I hope this will work. If it works in France it might extend to the whole EU as a directive (admittedly with many faults and holes, but EU has decent record on consumer protection). If more big countries follow (Japan and China, for example) then companies will take the first option from above. But for just a couple of countries? "Ok, we'll not sell the game in France and Vatican City."

7 months ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

I remember refunding a game that included some DLCs but the game tried to download them from a server which doesn't exist anymore. Companies don't need to support a game forever, as things are now.

And that's why...

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7yo8av6w4sc

7 months ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

Sadly, the game industry doesn't care about the consumer, only about money. And the saddest thing is that consumers aren't "voting with their wallets" on this. So I doubt this will change anything, but at least I opened my call there to show the insatisfaction with their business model. And I don't buy online-only games (sorry BattleBit Remastered).

7 months ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

Tried signing the UK petition, but it's now waiting to be "approved".

7 months ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

It's a great concept but braindead casuals who spend most of their time on their phones and kids whose parents buy them whatever they want throw more money at the gaming industry than "real" gamers. Look at what they call Final Fantasy now, that's unrecognizable from the first 9 games. Money talks as they say and developers are going to go where the money is and that's casual gaming and mutliplayer fps garbage. And they will cut every corner and rush things out the door as unfinished as possible with purchasable dlc that makes the game complete and playable if you are lucky. There's still some decent content coming out though.

7 months ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

I'm voting "No" because the option "I hope so" is not available.

Because I really hope so.

7 months ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

I own The Crew. I contacted ubisoft asking them kindly to fix the game. If you own that game or any of the games that they shat down, please, contact their support, ask them politely to fix the game. Don't mention servers, or shutdowns, just for a "fix" of the game that you own. Doesn't matter if it was a giveaway or you bought it. EU law is on your side. Use it. Don't let these corporate soulless fiends win this one.

7 months ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

I thought this was going to be about Adult Swim Games / Warner Bros.

7 months ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

I don't think it will change much because big companies only hear one thing: their shareholders selling shares and only care about one thing, money.
Once upon a time, negative press and campaigning might have had an impact on the first one but unfortunately nowadays shareholders only care about that if they think it might affect the profits, which it won't unless everyone stops buying games from companies like Ubisoft but let's be honest, it will never happen.

It is, however a good idea to try and raise concerns about how decisions like these might be against current consumer protection laws in Europe. I think the French justice system has bigger fish to fry but you never know.

Still, I give them props for trying and for being steadfast. Views don't mean much in the big scheme of things, and neither do retweets or likes but they are starting a conversation that need to happen so it's a step forward.

7 months ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

My thoughts exactly it's not only about bringing back The Crew but to clarify once and for all if corporations can take away immaterial goods you paid for like game licences. As Ubisoft would like to take away permanent ownership altogether now they may very well get more headwind than they bargained for. It's about time for governments to establish binding general rules for digital ownership.

7 months ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

It's about time for governments to establish binding general rules for digital ownership.

Agreed. And let's be clear, this would never happen with expensive professional software. They are getting away with it because customers like you and me are only money makers for them and we don't matter.

7 months ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

Thanks for making me aware of this campaign. I abhor DRM, just as much as software license revocation. They are both interlinked. Paying for a product that can be taken away from us, is more stealing than piracy. Yet it doesn't seem to be scrutinised enough.
Unfortunately the only way I see companies changing their policies, is a law made in EU to prohibit consumer games not functioning offline, along with losing the right to contest copyright on any community servers.

Players should get a quick education before starting their journeys not to ask their parents, or buy DRM games. Unless the game is a multiplayer game, which in that case it requires online to function (but still allowing the community to take over). Somebody should develop a quick start guide and spread it for the next generation.

Please stop giving money to unscrupulous companies. You don't have to play the latest game to have some fun. There are plenty of excellent offline games in the sea.

7 months ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

NATO vibe. No Action Talk Only.
The average customers don't care. See the yearly sports game (FIFA, Madden, NBA, FM)
I'm just waiting for the crash again.

7 months ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

If you like a got a lot. Acquire/Pirate a DRM free copy so you can play it forever.
Just be careful of virus. (use Sandbox like "Sandboxie-Plus" or a virtual machine to be safe)

It's the only way to be sure.

7 months ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

Next game to shut down will be THE DIVISION? its also on -85% right now.

https://steamcommunity.com/app/365590

7 months ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

"AAA" game studios will never give you what you want because you do not matter, they are beholden to their shareholders and for the most part what the shareholders say goes. Unfortunately shareholders are the ones that are demanding things that bring in the most revenue like predatory microtransactions and loot boxes that the majority of players hate, but whales love. And when it's a company like EA or Ubisoft even making bad games doesn't matter because there are legions of fanboys who will buy anything they put out regardless of whether it's actually good or not.

Basically you can vote with your wallet all you want but unless an overwhelming majority of gamers follow suit it won't have any impact, and if it's a game with microtransactions/loot boxes you'll also have to convince the whales to stop spending but good luck with that. And relying on politicians to do something about it is a fool's errand because politicians are often shareholders and have a vested interest in keeping the status quo going.

If you want any say in the matter your only hope is stick with smaller studios or indie devs that actually listen to their playerbase and make what changes they can based on feedback.

7 months ago
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

Next time vote with your wallet, 2012 is calling you back. Developers and AAA studios did this because you as a customer enabled it to begin with, they're the symptom.

but here we are people buying games on masse day 1, so it's a never ending cycle where nothing will get fixed.

7 months ago*
Permalink

Comment has been collapsed.

Sign in through Steam to add a comment.