arcanum

Looks like most of the people dont really get what this award is for..picking like5 years old games :D

easily final fantasy 6....been playing that game for years, owned it on the snes, then for a while emulators...now i own it again on steam!

I picked KotOR. Loved the shit out of that game, and i found that even if graphics haven't aged well it's still tons of fun and a blast to play.

Colonization (1994)

my favorite game of all time. and still so much fun today.

Grand Theft Auto 2

Age of Empire 2

I nominated Left 4 Dead 2.
Yes, I'm aware that it's not a very old game.

ADOM

Borderlands 2 :)

This was the easiest choice of all... Bioshock

Gothic 1

Jet Set Radio

I would have to vote for something I did not play when I was younger, for nostalgia to not get in the way. I think "I have no Mouth and I must Scream" makes for a good candidate here.

Super Meat Boy all the way, every time I return to that game I still can't get over how perfect it is.

Civilization

Prince of Persia <3

Dark Souls 1. Brilliant game that I could replay over and over.

System Shock 2

Was a tough choice though.

Seems that RPGs are generally favored candidates for this category. Mine too, but I picked Divine Divinity.

Splinter cell chaos theory ?

X-COM: UFO Defense

Phantasy Star IV: The End of the Millennium. I'm playing it in an emulator and it's awesome.

I find this category the hardest.. I mean, there's a lot of old games that have a special place in my heart but that's not what this category is for.. it's for games that you're still playing every now and then and are still as good as they were back in the day.. And I don't really play those games from back in the day anymore ;-)

Shining Force 2