What games did you finish multiple times?

DMC3 (around once per difficulty +1 (since i had the orginal Japan version then switched to SE PAL version and saves weren't compatible)
Vice city (reset all save and then finish the whole thing in a weekend)
HL2&EP2(my favorite FPS ever ofc i played that thing a lot at least 3 full playthroughs and a lot of chapter picking )
MGS3 (twice on ps2 and once on Vita)

Bastion( around three times steam sync went haywire and i lost progress )

black (played it twice except for the last mission )

AC2 (once on my old laptop around release on horrible fps and gpu driver crashing in tombs then another on my ps3)

Dark souls (twice ..well technically a full playthrough and two halves since i loved the game too much my copy has been in circulation trying to get my friends to play for a while :P )

DMC4 (only twice since it didn't live up to DMC3 for me )

DooM2 (no idea how many times since i've been playing it since i was 5 did do a full playhthrough last year with doomsday for mouse aiming )
infamous 1 &2 ( you sorta have to)
kz3 (twice alone and once with friends in co-op )

portal ( two or three times )
portal 2 (twice)

uncharted 1-3 (twice for 1 and 3 and three times for 2 a long with a lot of chapter selecting for 2 )

timesplitters future perfect (twice )

tLoZ:WW, best game ever imo :P

the binding of isaac. Chest run two times a week . :-D

I've really only played Bioshock Infinite on my steam account multiple times (3 times, planning on replaying it again soon). The atmosphere and art is just too delightful.

A lot of games.

But I finished "that game" so many times, I know every last detail and line from that game.

Dragon Age: Origins, finished more than 10 times.

Starting from 7th of October, I won't be around for a month.Inquisition awaits.

My most played game of all time is Sid Meiers Alpha Centauri/Alien Crossfire. To this day I still play it, the best turn-based strategy game ever made.

Dead Space,
Hotline Miami,
Brothers in Arms,
Diablo + Diablo 2,
Medieval 2: Total War,
Pirates!,
Civilization 5,
Monkey Island Series,
Broken Sword,
Swat 3,
Neverwinter Nights

But the games I have replayed most in about 18 years of gaming are
Commandos 2 - Men of Courage and Operation Flashpoint (Cold War Crisis, Resistance, Red Hammer). I think I could play the last 2 games while asleep. Played both of them more than 50 times each. :D

final fantasy 7, 8, 9, 10
dead space
Batman arkham asylum ,city, origins
mafia 2 ,are the sigle player games i finished more than 3 times each the least i wont count games like diablo or endless ones

GTA San Andreas, MW 1/2/3, GTA Vice City, Super mario(lol)

Dark Souls

Bioshock Infinite, most recently.

Left 4 Dead 1 & 2 are two of my all time favorites; though have finished many others and replayed just because. Far too long to list and still so many more games to play... ;)

Incomplete list:
Tenchu: Stealth Assassins ::::: Tekken 1-5 :::: Virtua Fighter 1 & 2 :::: King of Fighters '97 ::: Twisted Metal 4 :::: Crash Team Racing :::: Resident Evil 2 :::: GTA: Vice City :::: Street Fighter Alpha 3 :::: Diablo 1-3 :::: Fighting Force :::: Mortal Kombat 1-Armageddon :::: Ridge Racer 4 :::: Dragon Ball: Super Butoden 1~3 :::: Killer Instinct (SNES) :::: Rival Schools :::: Art of Fighting :::: FIFA 2002 PC :::: FIFA Road to World Cup '98 :::: Fatal Fury: Wild Ambition :::: The Pro Wrestling 2 (Smackdown! for the PS1 is based on it but is surprisingly worse) :::: Final Fight 3 :::: Mighty Morphin Power Rangers: The Movie :::: Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles: Turtles in Time :::: Top Gear 2 :::: NFS 2-HP2 (2002) :::: WWE: SvR 07 :::: Golden Axe 1-3 :::: Def Jam: Fight for NY :::: Shadow Dancer :::: Road Rash 3D :::: RE 1-5 :::: Delta Force: Land Warrior :::: Nicktoons Racing :::: Max Payne 1 :::: Beneath a Steel Sky :::: Path of Exile :::: CHAMPIONS World Class Soccer :::: Clue (Genesis) :::: Muhammad Ali Heavyweight Boxing :::: Knockout Kings 2000 :::: Pocket Fighter

I literally owned hundreds of games in my youth, the majority of them were sadly left unfinished :(

Metal Gear Solid: Peace Walker, finished it about 3 times.

TBOI :D

Civilization 2 and 4 (3 and 5 played once and never again).
Alpha Centauri + Xfire
Diablo 2
some Total Wars (Medieval2+mod, Empire)
Hegemony (twice, before and after it was released as "Gold")
most of Paradox strategy games (CK2, Victoria, EU2, EU3, HOI, HOI2...)

Dark Souls,Demon Souls Banjo Kazooie, Banjo Tooie, Conker's Bad Fur Day, Pokemon X. I'm pretty sure there's a lot more, but those are the ones i can remember now

Dark Souls

Max Payne 3

Spec ops the line

Resident evil 6

Total war shogun 2

Mount and blade warband

• GTA SA - 13 times

• Kane and Lynch dead man - 3 times

• Saints Row The third - 2 times

• Every Cod games until world at war - 3-4 times

• Tons Of indie games

• Gun - 2 times

Can't remember most the games sadly

Luigi's Mansion,
Paper Mario: Thousand year door,
Halo CE,
Halo 2,
Halo 3,
Halo Reach,
Borderlands,
Spyro the Dragon,
Crash Bandicoot

Fallout 3

Multiple times, and on two different platforms :D

Star Wars: Knights of the Old Republic and Baldur's Gate II: Shadows of Amn

Shadowrun, Shining force 1&2, Shining in the darkness, FF7, Castelvania: Symphony of the night.

Bump for Diablo and StarCraft series

Neverwinter Nights.