Most underrated games of this generation?

Alan Wake.

I would like "Sanctum" to be added to that list.

E.Y.E Divine Cybermancy
Shattered Horizon
Left 4 Dead 1
Knights of the Old Republic 2

Analogue: A Hate Story now in indieroyale so everyone can get it cheap. More of an interactive book than a game but it's nice for a good read

1. Valkyria Chronicles
2. Resonance of Fate
3. Nier
4. N2O (I seriously feel like I'm the only person who knows what this game even is)
5. Dark Sector

Pokemon Green.

Singularity? That game had an excellent intro, but about halfway through, it became so friggin bad.

So many unnecessary ways to just instantly kill all people with TIME.

You are a brony but you list Bionic Commando in your top 10 which I approve, the universe is in balance.

Blackwell Series

999: 9 Hours, 9 Persons, 9 Doors for the DS.

Best story ever.

I expected to see Zero Gear somewhere here but it's nowhere. So Zero Gear.

I really thought Legendary was underrated. Despite the terrible characters, and sub standard graphics (only in certain places), the gameplay and level design were really good. Even the length of the campaign was decent!

Dark Seed 2!!

Always bet on Duke!

I like campaign, I like multiplayer, I like The Doctor Who Cloned Me add-on.

The game is awesome even when it could be much, much better.

Psychonauts?

L.A. Noire. was hated on entirely too hard for how brilliant and original it is

Enviro-Bear 2000: Operation: Hibernation (really, download it!)

Spec Ops: The Line.

Red orchestra 2

I´d put Nier and Enslaved on top of my list.. both are on my "best games ever" List and both are pretty much ignored by the public.
Its nice to see the Duke on your list ^^ The game was just as much overhyped beforehand as it was underrated later. I had my fun with it and if you like the Duke, you pretty much got everything you ever wished for ^^ I guess most people just hate it, because their expectations where to high. It was a descent game, not too great, but still lots of fun.

Apha Protocol is another story.. most official ratings i´ve seen were very fair (~60-70%), because it has sooo many downsides that destroy a lot of the fun and have to be considered to rate a whole game.. but it was underrated in the sense of "public awareness", because it has so many upsides and unique and great ideas in it.. I wish they´d make another game like this at some point.. with better gameplay and controls, this could´ve been easily one of the best games ever.. but as it is, its just an interesting game with great ideas, characters and storytelling but bad gameplay.

I think Siren Blood Curse is the most underrated game this generation, it was the only survival horror game released on this generation's consoles, and one of the best in class. Runner ups include Risen, Gothic 3, Singularity and The Darkness.

Super Monday Night Combat

The Yakuza series and just to put it in the Steambot Chronicles series from last generation.

Definitely Alpha Protocol is on top of the list. Despite being original and awesome, had cold receive.

Gotta agree with you on Bionic Commando as well. Not sure if The Darkness wasn't well received, but yeah, it's also a good one.

Singularity! Awesome singleplayer and story and the multiplayer was frickin awsome but no one played it :(